This is a story of an Objectivist breaking it off with another, which is very sad. Maybe this should be on another thread, but here goes…
What do you do when a long-time friend (best man at our wedding) and Objectivist stops growing intellectually with you AND becomes so negative over time, he constantly clashes with your sense of life? A person I ran a study group with decided that I was attacking him for giving him suggestions about our group. He didn’t want to (or couldn’t) explain why he was angry (or how my suggestions where wrong), or to explain why he complained about his life all the time, and decided not to communicate with me about it anymore because it was “too painful for him.” Mind you, his lack of introspection and general unhappiness gradually occurred, and he was much nicer and more considerate when I first met him 13 years ago.
I wanted to work through this, but realized that he wasn’t open to developing any deeper understandings between us. The bottom line is, he wanted to be a victim. I realized that he was insecure, taking suggestions as personal insults, who wanted me as a friend (mainly because he was friends with my husband) but didn’t want to work on our friendship. I had to make the heart-wrenching decision not to associate with him anymore, even if it would cost me some mutual (and wonderful) Objectivist friends (and it did cost me leaving behind a study group that I put most of the energy and thought and planning into over 8 years).
Luckily, it all worked out for the best, and most people were very understanding. After a long while, I decided to start my own group, and we are flourishing. Anyway, that’s the closest, most traumatic, example I can come to in comparison. It’s still difficult for me, but I’m remembering to leave it behind every day and focus on what I can do instead of what I can’t (changing his mind and sense of life and trying to make our old group work, which, by the way, he still runs, to my displeasure). Anyway…
It sounds like your ex-friend is just awful. You spend so many years with him, enjoying each other, and admiring his judgment – then he throws every insult at you that he can think of, trying to convince you that it’s all your fault. Don’t fall for it. He has treated you badly and it’s time to find a better friend, and you will. Don’t fall for the old “our friends hate you” trick. If you have no evidence for it, and you truly admire your mutual friends, hang out with them without the ex around. Don’t think of your mutual friends as a group, but as individuals. If you feel comfortable, open up about the split to someone you trust.
I doubt if your ex-friend’s dislike for you has much to do with Objectivism, or any single political argument. It most likely has everything to do with how you are improving, psychologically and intellectually, and he is not. How secure you are with yourself and the world, and he is not. I’m sure there are plenty of indications besides talking Objectivism that show the world (and him) who you are, how you hold yourself, how careful you are with your words, and how much you take ideas seriously in general. It looks like he is threatened by that, he doesn’t want to change, and the easiest way for him to squash that threat is to try to squash you. He doesn’t want to face his own inefficacy.
Remember that real friends will always encourage what will make you happy, and they want to see you happy for their own selfish inspiration. Good luck and keep your chin up!