5 hours ago, SelfishRandroid said:
Something I’ve struggled with since becoming an Objectivist is that I am totally at odds with the culture at large, including many of my formerly close friends. I’ve found myself pulling away from years-long friendships because I find their political and philosophical views to be appalling. I live in an extremely liberal, “progressive” part of the United States, and the majority of people I know are pro-Socialism or even pro-Communism.
I can, to some degree, tolerate mixed premises or unarticulated, uncritical acceptance of some of society’s edicts, but I can’t stand people who are active proponents of what I consider to be evil. My friends are educated exponents of these ideas, having graduated from prestigious universities, so it’s difficult for me to enjoy their company when our values are so at odds. I’m finding myself growing increasingly friendless as I discard friendships with people with strongly leftist, collectivistic ideas. Unfortunately, those are the overwhelming majority of people I seem to be surrounded with.
I’m curious as to how many of you have friends with very different political and philosophical views than your own, and how you make those relationships “work,” so to speak? I don’t want to compromise on my values, but is there some way I can be more accepting of my friends’ virtues despite their unpalatable convictions? Or am I doing the right—albeit painful—thing by ending these relationships?
Any advice or personal anecdotes on this topic would be welcome. Thanks!
Paraphrasing a quote here, Rand saw herself as primarily a proponent, not of capitalism, but egoism… and not primarily egoism, but reason. I approach my friendships and other relations the same sort of way: I seek people who are fundamentally reasonable. Your mileage may vary, but I’ve found people who demonstrate varying degrees of reason in every walk of life, and subscribing to most every sort of view – at the very least, nominally. At the same time, I have met people whose stated beliefs I judge as correct, yet they are not very reasonable in their dealings, in their lives – and they don’t make for great friends.
This fundamental orientation to reason can show up in many ways, from hobbies and activities, to career pursuits and romantic involvements, discussions/arguments and so forth. The more reasonable they are, in this basic sense, the more apt we are to get along… even where and when we disagree. The people who are less fundamentally reasonable, though we may agree on everything else (howsoever superficially), the smallest disagreement could wind up being an unmanageable obstacle.
Consequently, I’ve maintained friends among Christians, Hindus, Atheists, Buddhists, and politically on the left, right and in the “middle.” The more zealous socialists I’ve known can be trying, at times, and not least because – to the extent they adhere to their own professed beliefs – they often feel required not to be friends with someone who believes as I do. Yet even with one or two of these, I have found that I can identify sufficiently with their virtues to overcome other deficits (like intelligence and taking ideas seriously).
My closest friend in the world (apart from my wife) is a Methodist. He’s sincere in his religious beliefs, but not very dogmatic. We made peace about our diverging views very long ago, and though we still argue them from time to time in one form or another, we understand that our bonds are based on fundamental things that, perhaps, aren’t completely captured or expressed in our stated philosophies. We do not fear disagreement.