"Man's life"? Or, "your life"?

Back to basics. You guys need some revision, from page one:

"The first question that has to answered, as a precondition of any attempt to define, to judge or to accept any system of ethics, is: Why does man need any values at all – and why?

"Let me stress this. The first question is not: What particular code of values should man accept? The first question is: Does man need values at all–and why?

“Is the concept of *value*, of “good or evil” an arbitrary human invention, unrelated to, underived from and unsupported by any facts of reality–or is it based on a *metaphysical fact, on an unalterable condition of man’s existence? (I use the word “metaphysical” to mean: that which pertains to reality, to the nature of things, to existence).” p,1 The Objectivist Ethics.

Etc.

Right up to and beyond: “…holds man’s life as the standard of value…”

If there are sensible objections to Rand’s justification, fine, I will be glad to hear. If there’s agreement, then we agree on the basics, and can dive a little deeper. But we all should know the basics first, not garbled versions from secondary sources, or subjective reproductions that look good. “Independence” means not much, when one has subjective ‘standards’ of egoism. 

1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:

Man’s life is his process of self-generated and self-sustaining action. You appear to be focusing on only one aspect of man, his existence, and dropping the context of his action. Man’s life is not that which is fundamental to his existence, it’s that which is his existence. A man acting to stay alive (to continue existing) is his life. Of course, a man can also act to 

Yes yes. LIFE. Do I have to repeat goal-directed action, self-generated, etc, etc, in every post? You can read it higher up. 

2 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

This is the sense in which his own life is his standard of value, and his own death is his standard of vice.

I mean, I don’t disagree with your criticism here as far as whyNot’s reasoning about the topic (a quote battle isn’t helping anyone).

But wouldn’t this here be an example of trying to fit a bad phrasing to a fine concept? If you talk about an abstraction, you can’t be talking about literally your own life. The only thing that can have a life is a specific entity. Yeah, you abstract from your own life (to do otherwise is rationalism usually), but you can’t apply your own life as a standard to other people. In some sense, you could be the standard, to the extent that you are trying to take into account your individual differences. The problem with that is when we talk about standards, we are looking for what applies across all entities of a specific class. The word ‘standard’ would not be precise here.

 

 

6 hours ago, Eiuol said:

The problem with that is when we talk about standards, we are looking for what applies across all entities of a specific class. The word ‘standard’ would not be precise here.

Earlier you referenced Peikoff’s principle of two definitions, which he applied to the concept of value. I suspect that a similar principle applies to the concept of standard of value. In order to reach the narrower idea of a pro-life standard, you must begin with the broader set of standards, which includes all particular things and ideas by which you’ve evaluated your goals and actions. Consider this #2 definition of standard:

I just pulled it from Google, but I think it is accurate. A standard doesn’t have to be an abstraction. It can also be a real thing, i.e., your particular life. And since your life is an end in itself, it makes sense for it to be your concrete, metaphysical standard of value, the thing by which you should evaluate your actions. This doesn’t mean that it should replace an abstract, moral standard. The two should be in harmony, otherwise you have a problem.

This is a difficult idea to explain. I’ll work on a more comprehensive statement, but I too want to avoid a “quote-battle” with Whynot, and I worry that’s what it’ll turn into if I start analyzing Rand in more detail. Instead, I would very much like to see Whynot fully address SL’s “apple tree” example and your Peikoff reference to the principle of two definitions.

18 hours ago, Eiuol said:

I mean, I don’t disagree with your criticism here as far as whyNot’s reasoning about the topic (a quote battle isn’t helping anyone).

But wouldn’t this here be an example of trying to fit a bad phrasing to a fine concept? If you talk about an abstraction, you can’t be talking about literally your own life. The only thing that can have a life is a specific entity. Yeah, you abstract from your own life (to do otherwise is rationalism usually), but you can’t apply your own life as a standard to other people. In some sense, you could be the standard, to the extent that you are trying to take into account your individual differences. The problem with that is when we talk about standards, we are looking for what applies across all entities of a specific class. The word ‘standard’ would not be precise here.

 

 

The whole thing starts wrong with not applying the law of identity to man. With the premise that consciousness and one’s own mind do not also have specific identity. The very first of which is its autonomy. Staying with just that single attribute, autonomy dictates that one can *only* be mind-independent.

In dismissal of the “is/ought dichotomy”, a man must act according to, and to the extent of his nature, using all his attributes: rationality, reason, free will, especially.

From the identification of the attributes of “man” given to us by an objective metaphysician is how most individuals arrived at identifying one’s own capacities. Few ever could achieve that by introspection and induction, nor a lifetime of observation of individual men.

That outlines the necessity of a metaphysics, in this case the absolute reality of “man” and man’s life. Switching to value - again, the all fits the one. What is one’s and one’s life-value is anything but arbitrary, subjective, intrinsic. Individual value - explicitly - comes about by one recognizing the “standard of value” (man’s life) - to repeat, based upon the identity of those capacities man has. This abstract principle is nothing to fret about in one’s daily, general living and pursuit of values, as I see this.

E.g. “Am I - properly - living up to the standard of value, man’s life?”

It ‘only’ needs to be grasped and acknowledged, (as with the abstraction “reality” denoting every instance of reality). When explicitly recognized, and at times, revisited, the subconscious mind admits and holds that as a guiding principle for one’s value-choices . 

18 hours ago, Eiuol said:

, but you can’t apply your own life as a standard to other people.  

 

 

There are I think two tremendous errors and bad consequences of accepting “one’s own life is the standard of value”. One is the circular illogic of applying one’s own standard of value to one’s own *value". (And losing any standard). The other is applying one’s life as the standard of value - to others. Which means one sets the benchmark of value by one’s life for what other individual lives and their values, must match.

On one hand, an individual could end up in self-conflict, anxiety and confusion -  subconsciously knowing he’s living in self-contradiction. On the other, one may turn to “Nietzschean egoism”: whatever I say goes. Whatever I choose is good. A possible additional side-effect being second-handedness.

Hard to tell which is worse, they are both equally self-less outcomes.

Morally, they boil down to self-sacrifice -or- sacrifice of others.  

23 hours ago, whYNOT said:

There are I think two tremendous errors and bad consequences of accepting “one’s own life is the standard of value”. One is the circular illogic of applying one’s own standard of value to one’s own *value". (And losing any standard). The other is applying one’s life as the standard of value - to others. Which means one sets the benchmark of value by one’s life for what other individual lives and their values, must match.

You don’t lose your standard simply because your ultimate value (your own life) sets a standard by which you evaluate your actions as good or bad. If your actions result in you continuing to live and flourish, then you can evaluate them as good. If they result in you getting sick and declining in health, your actions are bad. Your life is an end in itself. If you’re acting successfully then you are living your standard of value. Just because you’ve achieved your standard doesn’t mean you don’t have it anymore. You have your life until you die.

As far as applying your own life as the standard for other people, that’s a straw man that I think comes from not appreciating the relational nature of values. If, in a particular sense, my life is my standard of value, then it’s not going to be your particular or general standard, because my particular values (including my own life) relate to me, not you. (Only an abstract or general standard can apply to everyone.) If my life is of value to you, it’s not in the same way as its value to me. It’s not your ultimate value or standard, but it is mine.

1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:

You don’t lose your standard simply because your ultimate value (your own life) sets a standard by which you evaluate your actions as good or bad. If your actions result in you continuing to live and flourish, then you can evaluate them as good. If they result in you getting sick and declining in health, your actions are bad. Your life is an end in itself. If you’re acting successfully then you are living your standard of value. Just because you’ve achieved your standard doesn’t mean you don’t have it anymore. You have your life until you die.

I like your post.

But note, setting your own life as the standard by which you evaluate actions does not necessitate any “trial and error” which this paragraph might imply to some on a first reading.

Nor does it require the abandonment of conceptualization and abstract knowledge.  You can evaluate any potential action based on what you know, namely the likelihood of outcomes based on your nature (i.e. all you know about what it is to be a man and all the possibilities and potentialities that entails), without ever having to wait for any specifically personal “results” from a personally tried action (trial and error).  One can know whether a potential action is “good” by the application of principles and knowledge of what you are and keeping context.

1 Like

3 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

But note, setting your own life as the standard by which you evaluate actions does not necessitate any “trial and error” which this paragraph might imply to some on a first reading.

I get the impression that “trial and error” is being misused here. I don’t see why it should be set counter to evaluating potential actions based on your knowledge. The two processes go hand-in-hand. It’s not like you perform trials for the sake of performing trials. You test out certain actions to see what works, then you store and logically build on that knowledge by advancing your trials to the next stages of development. Also, very early on you learn to be careful in this process so that you don’t take wild risks with your life. So it’s not as if the “trial and error” process represents some irrational disregard for one’s standard of value.

4 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

One can know whether a potential action is “good” by the application of principles and knowledge of what you are and keeping context.

Sure, but what if you don’t have the necessary knowledge to form the proper principle to apply to that potential action? You would need to somehow gain the knowledge, which might require performing trials and making errors.

On 10/21/2019 at 11:57 AM, whYNOT said:

On the other, one may turn to “Nietzschean egoism”: whatever I say goes.

I think this deserves some clarification. Nietzsche wouldn’t even say there’s a standard of value. It’s not that whatever you say goes, but that by acknowledging that in his view there is no standard of value to apply across all people, we end up with completely different ways of thinking and action than the usual “good and bad”. To him, saying your life as a standard of value would be subjugating yourself to some outside commandment or duty. At least, if you are what he calls new philosophers.

I’m not arguing for his view, though I am saying it helps support the idea that your individual life as a standard of value is mental gymnastics at best. 

9 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

You don’t lose your standard simply because your ultimate value (your own life) sets a standard by which you evaluate your actions as good or bad. If your actions result in you continuing to live and flourish, then you can evaluate them as good.

Of course you would judge the actions within the context of your life as good or bad. But it doesn’t mean you used your particular life to set a standard. It doesn’t make sense to say that your ultimate value set a standard, because if the standard is objective, you wouldn’t be using facts unique to you and your life. The unique facts about your life are information that you take into account (like your education when deciding what career to pursue). 

In other words, I think you’re confusing conceptual development with using measurements. Yes, your life is a critical referent. But you form the abstraction of a standard by abstracting away your particular life. Your life is there, part of the concept. If you didn’t abstract away your particular life, you wouldn’t be able to apply any moral standards to other people objectively. At best, it sounds like you’re trying to say that your life is your standard, because you have high standards for yourself, and you do it for your sake. But that’s just a shallow understanding, and there is good reason that Rand never tried to speak about standards in this way. You are using it as definition 1, while Rand was using 2.

Your life isn’t an abstraction. The closest thing to focusing only on that is how Max Stirner thinks of the ego. To him, he doesn’t talk about oneself being something we just think about, or frame of mind, or life having some intrinsic worth. Rather, our lives, our ego, is that concrete thing. When we say ‘I’, he doesn’t think of it as an abstraction, he sees it as a nameless thing that you can only refer to by pointing to it. The problem with this is that he doesn’t think we could abstract from our lives to reach objective moral principles. He doesn’t say this explicitly, but it is very clear when he spends a lot of time trying to refute the notion of an abstract self and life and therefore refute any way to apply abstract moral principles. But in fact, we can find abstract moral principles, because we can abstract away our individual lives. 

The two definition idea only applies to say that your individual life could be called a standard in the sense of 2, even if normatively it should not be. We are discussing the normative level, since I’m not disputing whether your life could be called a standard. Basically, my claim is that it is easy to dismantle your idea. Your life can’t be applied as a standard to other people even if you tried, therefore, it can’t be a standard in the normative sense.

2 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

I get the impression that “trial and error” is being misused here. I don’t see why it should be set counter to evaluating potential actions based on your knowledge. The two processes go hand-in-hand. It’s not like you perform trials for the sake of performing trials. You test out certain actions to see what works, then you store and logically build on that knowledge by advancing your trials to the next stages of development. Also, very early on you learn to be careful in this process so that you don’t take wild risks with your life. So it’s not as if the “trial and error” process represents some irrational disregard for one’s standard of value.

Sure, but what if you don’t have the necessary knowledge to form the proper principle to apply to that potential action? You would need to somehow gain the knowledge, which might require performing trials and making errors.

People who wish to know and escape from ignorance generally seek knowledge and education.  “Somehow” is not any kind of barrier.  

Much is known and has been written about the nature of humans.  

Certainly we all learn from experience but education and instruction whether self directed or from parents or others who have more experience than you, is incredibly important… especially in the formative years.

I was not saying what you wrote was wrong only warning that some might misconstrue it.

2 hours ago, Eiuol said:

Your life can’t be applied as a standard to other people even if you tried, therefore, it can’t be a standard in the normative sense.

I think MS does not care.  I think he knows and accepts the Objectivist Ethics has normative standards which could be used to judge other people … contextually, but he is more or less talking about his own ethics which he does not need nor want to apply to anyone else… when he needs to judge others he can use Rand’s ethics.

19 hours ago, Eiuol said:

Of course you would judge the actions within the context of your life as good or bad. But it doesn’t mean you used your particular life to set a standard. It doesn’t make sense to say that your ultimate value set a standard, because if the standard is objective, you wouldn’t be using facts unique to you and your life. The unique facts about your life are information that you take into account (like your education when deciding what career to pursue). 

I’m not sure how you’re using “objective” here. Why can’t your own life be an objective standard? Your life exists no matter what you subjectively or faithfully believe about it.

Let’s take a hypothetical. Say I’m a child with no knowledge of Rand or moral theories. My mommy tells me to look both ways before crossing the road. I understand that this rule is to help prevent getting hit by a car. Getting hit by a car is bad. People who get hit by cars get hurt. To avoid getting hurt myself, I’ll look both ways before crossing a road. Here I have grasped an abstract moral principle and applied it to my own life.

The next day I play under a tree. I hear something, look up, and get smacked in the forehead by a falling pine cone. My head hurts. I’m bleeding a little. It occurs to me that playing under that pine tree can be dangerous. Going forward, I decide to avoid playing under that pine tree or to cover my head instead of looking up when I hear that sound. Also, I warn my brother to be careful under that pine tree. Here I have formed a rule based on my own life as the standard, and I recognized the rule’s application for other people, since I’m not the only one who could be injured by falling pine cones.

1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:

Why can’t your own life be an objective standard?

To begin with, a standard can’t just include one thing. You need something to compare it to. If you use your own individual life as a standard, you are admitting that you have nothing for comparison. At best, your standards would be arbitrary and conceptually invalid. Not even objective or subjective. Even if you came up with some philosophy like “objective hedonism”, that only focuses on yourself, you would probably talk about life in general anyway. You would refer to the pleasure of certain actions, and the objective facts which lead to that pleasure arising. If you truly want to only focus on your life explicitly, that would mean you reject the concept of moral standards - if you want to be consistent about it.

The way I see it, you’re trying to find a way to defend your use of “my life is a standard of value” instead of just saying it’s bad phrasing. What you say is consistent with life as a standard of value, not your particular life. The only error is that you are insisting that your examples illustrate your life as a standard of value. They don’t. Applying an abstract moral principle to your life is not taking your life as a standard of value. That’s what we mean by life as a standard of value: it’s an abstract principle and an abstract standard. The standard is applied to your life, and then you can recognize if that standard impacted your life.

1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:

Also, I warn my brother to be careful under that pine tree. Here I have formed a rule based on my own life as the standard, and I recognized the rule’s application for other people, since I’m not the only one who could be injured by falling pine cones.

If your own life is standard of value there, by definition, the rule does not apply to other people. You would need a new rule. Or if the rule does apply to other people, you’ve already admitted that you aren’t using your life as a standard of value. What you’re describing is maybe a theory of moral development, but not moral theory itself.

2 hours ago, Eiuol said:

To begin with, a standard can’t just include one thing. You need something to compare it to. If you use your own individual life as a standard, you are admitting that you have nothing for comparison.

Man is the entity. Life is his particular process of self-sustaining action. That process occurs over time and changes states. He therefore compares one state with another. One minute he is healthy, the next minute he’s injured from a falling pine cone. His standard is not the injured state, but the healthy, uninjured state. He therefore takes action to return to and maintain a healthy condition and avoid the unhealthy one. Understanding life as a process is critical here. We aren’t talking about a static thing that doesn’t change and doesn’t have memory and doesn’t compare its existence now to its existence in the past–or even its imaginary existence in the future.

Right, it’s a comparison among more than one thing. You would be comparing states. So you could use one state as a standard of comparison. Unfortunately, you wouldn’t be able to use principles of medicine to fix any issues. It would be concrete bound and stuck to exactly and only you.

But that doesn’t matter much. You aren’t changing states between life and not life. Life doesn’t change and alter like states of health. On top of that, we are talking about moral standards. Moral standards apply to yourself and to other people. If your standards can be applied to other people, then you necessarily didn’t use yourself as the standard of value. If your standards can’t be applied to other people, then you aren’t even talking about morality anymore.

Just to clarify, I’m not saying you can’t use your individual life as the standard for something. If you had a progressive disease like ALS, you might only be able to compare your state today to your state yesterday as a way to judge adaptations required for living with the disease. Such a standard can’t apply to anyone else at all. 

14 hours ago, Eiuol said:

You aren’t changing states between life and not life. Life doesn’t change and alter like states of health.

Your health is an aspect of your life. Health is you functioning properly, your self-sustaining action. It’s your organs operating successfully, your mind operating successfully, your choices and movements maintaining your existence as a living organism. You are constantly changing states, either growing and living, or deteriorating and dying. This is why you need to act, either automatically or voluntarily. Some actions–carelessly playing under a pine tree, looking up and getting hit in the forehead with a pine cone, bleeding from a cut–are states of deteriorating and dying. Other actions–blood clotting, skin scabbing, letting the wound heal, deciding to not play under pine trees, being more careful near trees in the future–are states of growing and living. Not everything you do is living. If it were, you wouldn’t need values. You wouldn’t need ethics. You would just live. 

Life is a binary thing, you go towards it or not. Health is not a binary thing, because there are many kinds of states of health. If life wasn’t binary, there could be many kinds of states of life, which is the type of argument people use to either argue for the nonexistence of morality, or that morality is relative.

I don’t disagree with what you wrote, I think you stated it pretty well. But you also gave all the reasons that Rand said life is a standard of value… It’s an important reason why Rand isn’t Nietzsche-lite. 

19 hours ago, Eiuol said:

If life wasn’t binary, there could be many kinds of states of life, which is the type of argument people use to either argue for the nonexistence of morality, or that morality is relative.

I wouldn’t characterize life as binary. Existence might be binary. An existent is either alive or not alive. You, the human entity, are either living or dead. But life itself–your life–goes through stages of development. Offhand I can think of the three main human stages: infancy, adolescence, and maturity or adulthood. Each stage represents an essential change in your life process. Infancy to adolescence is the change from involuntary to voluntary self-sustaining action. And adolescence to mature adulthood is the change to rational action, meaning primary reliance on one’s rational faculty, rather than reflexes and mimicking.