Okay; I just thought you had something more specific in mind. Instead of this abstract objection, is there some particular conclusion you see as becoming shaky if the concept of entity is fuzzy? Also, when you say fuzzy, are you referring to the borderline problem, where one knows clearly many things that one wishes to include in the concept and also many things that one wishes to exclude, but there are also some things that one is not sure about, around the border?
Definitions are secondary to the underlying decision of what one wishes to conceptualize. Is there some slightly different way of conceptualizing “entity” that you think leads to different conclusions about philosophy?
Yes.
I’m a philosophy dilettante, so bear with me if this seems unsophisticated, but I am struggling with Objectivism and I think I see light…
The attempts at exemplary definition of “entity” do not seem to bear up to close scrutiny, and certainly do not meet with universal agreement (even among those who think they hold the same philosophy). This leads me to believe that entity is a subjective concept, open to interpretation by the individual. Is a forest an entity, is a gravitational field, is air, is reason, is God? Ask a dozen Objectivists and you’ll get a dozen answers (well, maybe not to all of those).
The same seems to hold true for “perception” which we tie closely to entities, although there is disagreement over whether an illusion or a pattern (e.g., a constellation) is an entity, a perception, both, or neither.
Concept seems to be pretty universal, if I read correctly, and refers to pretty much anything you can “get” via sensation, reason, imagination, or any combination (that’s probably a weak statement, but let it go unless it’s critical).
Reality is the place where percepts, concepts and entities tie together to either define (as in Objectivism) or muddy (as in existentialism) the concept (and even the possibility).
The problem I have is in the assertions that automatically equate perception to reality in the absence of [something else].
Here’s why: I dream. (ok, let me know when you’re finished rolling your eyes and groaning…)
Every night I have vivid dreams with “real” people, places, situations, etc., and I can’t tell, while I’m having them, that they are not “real.” Hypothetically, what if (I know… but just go through this), every night, while I slept, someone spirited me to a strange location with strange situations and strange people, so that every morning when I woke up, “things” were different. Further, suppose, that for whatever reason (or none) my dreams, while I was sleeping, maintained a causal constancy during the night and from one night to the next. I “dream” up this scenario, not to argue as children and bad poets (& philosophers) do, that “reality” might be a dream, and what we think are dreams, reality. I enter this scenario only to explore the relationships between percepts, concepts, entities and reality.
Don’t get me wrong: I know which is reality and which is dreams. But, I know which is real, not through direct, automatic perception, but through rational processing of my perceptions. In the scenario given, if my dreams were consistent and causal, and my waking experience was random and fragmented, I believe I would have a hard time making the distinction; in fact, I believe I might get it wrong. That’s not an argument that there’s a possibility that we do get it wrong and that we can’t fully trust our senses. It’s simply an argument that our rational faculties are what we use to interpret the concept of “reality” from our perceptions.
When I say “reality” I guess I mean our rational understanding of reality and its nature, not the strictly automatic causal reality that creates response from instinctive beings. In other words I guess I’m redefining “reality” as our rational cognition that reality is “real” as opposed to a non-thinking approach that governs an irrational creature’s response to its perceptions, which it cannot conceptualize as reality (or can it?).
Reason, in this point of view, is the glue that holds percepts, concepts and entities into a consistent, logical whole which we call “reality” and which provides us with a wholly consistent (and thus “true”) model of reality. It is the constancy, consistency and causality of reality that clue us in to its true nature.
Of course, I suppose one could argue that I’ve just transformed a trivial distinction of the definition of fundamentals into a trivial distinction of the definition of reality. I think my ultimate question is whether we come to a cognition of reality (including its nature) through perception or through rational processing of perception. And if the latter, is that consistent with Objectivism? (I think there’s enough leeway, but I’m not an expert)