Obama: Law Against Gay Marriage Unconstitutional

Obama declares Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional. The president orders the Department of Justice to stop defending Defense of Marriage Act in court.

http://www.newser.com/story/112721/obama-law-against-gay-marriage-unconstitutional.html

The Obama administration has concluded that the Defense of Marriage Act—the law that bars federal recognition of same-sex marriage—is unconstitutional and won’t defend it in court anymore, reports NPR. The president gave the Justice Department its new marching orders today, and Eric Holder says he agrees with the decision.

More information here:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/24/us/24marriage.html

Oh, how the Right-wing blogs are going to squeal!

An interesting time for Obama to decide he gives a flying fuck about the constitution.

Panem et circenses

In other words “Whatever I can do to be re-elected!”

Oh, how the Right-wing blogs are going to squeal!

This was on Fox News this morning and they had the Chairwoman for what…Family Marriage or whatever, basically the largest or second largest organization for protecting the “sanctity” of marriage on. You should have seen how into this the newswoman was. It was like she was being personally offended by this news and as if there was an all-consuming, critical battle about to be waged.

It was like she was being personally offended by this news and as if there was an all-consuming, critical battle about to be waged.

Well, in many ways there is. But not for the reasons she thinks.

I find it deeply offensive to my very core that Obama would dare talk about what is constitutional and what isn’t given his utter disregard for it on all other occassions when the Constitution presents an inconvenience to his collectivist, regressive agenda.

As someone who happens to be gay I find deeply and personally offensive his disingenuous about-face pandering. He has always waffled on the issue but usually come down on the side against gay marriage. This turn about comes at a time when the Democrats can no longer take the gay vote for granted.

There is no “victory” here whatsoever for “gay rights” or individual rights. All there is is a lying opportunistic politician whoring himself to a demographic he was starting to lose.

3 Likes

You should have seen how into this the newswoman was. It was like she was being personally offended by this news and as if there was an all-consuming, critical battle about to be waged.

From the point of view of the religious right, it is a critical battle. It’s one thing not to harras or prosecute gays, quite another to recognize them as equals. So I can respect their integrity if not the principles they apply it to.

As I read it, the act is not unconstitutional. http://frwebgate.acc…d=f:publ199.104

It states that the Federal government cannot “require” (force) one state to adhere to the marriage definitions of another state.

It also defines the term “marriage” as used in federal congressional acts to be specific to one man and one woman.

As for what the STATE’s ought to do – Ayn Rand was asked about that:

Q: Should the state prescribe the obligations of a marriage, or should this be left to the contractual desires of the couple?

Ayn Rand

: This is an important and difficult subject, because of two complex issues; the rights of children and property rights.

If two people are married, they may want or have children. Once a child is born, he is entitled to support until he is self supporting.

In general, a husband and wife can make any property arrangements they want. But today, the law is a bit too much on the side of the woman. There was a time when the woman was at the economic mercy of her husband; today, she is not. There is a great deal of irrationality and contradictions in many state marriage laws, so there’s room for improvement, provided thc basic principles are clearly stated and not arbitrary.

The government cannot undertake to enforce any contract any two people decide to make. If your contract falls under a certain legal category, then the government can undertake to enforce it; but it cannot be asked to enforce some contradictory contract. This is one reason why there must be a uniform code of law—why individuals are not entirely free to make contracts in any manner. But proper marriage law-- and even the mixed ones of today allow two parties to make legal contracts regarding their relationship. [FHF 68]

What is your view of laws prohibiting homosexuality and bigamy?

All laws against homosexual acts should be repealed. I do not approve of such practices or regard them as necessarily moral, but it is improper for the law to interfere with a relationship between consenting adults. Laws against corrupting the morals of minors are proper, but adults should be completely free.

Bigamy is a different issue. If a man wants a relationship with two women, he does not need the law to sanction it. But the state should have standards about what it considers a legal marriage. The law should be uniform, and there are good reasons why in most civilized countries marriage is a monogamous institution. lf a man wants a wife and another woman, he doesnʼt need the legality of bigamy if he’s open about it. Bigamy laws concern cases in which a man has two legal wives in two different cities, and leads a double life. Here there are good grounds, legally and morally, to prosecute him. [FHF 68]

–

[

Ayn Rand Answers

](http://www.amazon.com/Ayn-Rand-Answers-Best-Her/dp/0451216652)

Obama declares Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional.

Like Sapere Aude said, Obama is doing this in the hope for votes. I wouldn’t want him to be on the SCOTUS deciding what’s constitutional… this man who derided the “negative rights” of the constitution.

Nevertheless, I’m glad this is happening. Any set back to the religious right means that a less religious GOP candidate can promise to restore the pre-Obama status quo, rather than feel he needs to promise to go beyond the pre Obama status quo.

From the point of view of the religious right, it is a critical battle. It’s one thing not to harras or prosecute gays, quite another to recognize them as equals. So I can respect their integrity if not the principles they apply it to.

I understand why they view it as a critical battle, the thing is it just frustrates me when this pretty young blonde woman is having these extravagant movements and everything on the news like this, yet is completely distant and normal acting when she talks about Libyans getting ripped apart by aircraft guns. I guess this is why I never watch Fox news anymore, the people on there are just so pathetic and I have never seen flat out lies or levels of sensationalism that have matched that channel news network so consistently (MSNBC was pretty bad at times but I have not watched them in years). CNN is relatively tolerable now that that jackoff got kicked off the air. As far as respecting their integrity, you have the right to have that opinion, as far as me personally…I don’t respect these types of people whatsoever and I think its nauseating that we even have to have debates over things like this in the 21st century.

Well, in many ways there is. But not for the reasons she thinks.

I find it deeply offensive to my very core that Obama would dare talk about what is constitutional and what isn’t given his utter disregard for it on all other occassions when the Constitution presents an inconvenience to his collectivist, regressive agenda.

As someone who happens to be gay I find deeply and personally offensive his disingenuous about-face pandering. He has always waffled on the issue but usually come down on the side against gay marriage. This turn about comes at a time when the Democrats can no longer take the gay vote for granted.

There is no “victory” here whatsoever for “gay rights” or individual rights. All there is is a lying opportunistic politician whoring himself to a demographic he was starting to lose.

I agree with all of this, but I am not exactly surprised. In fact I am not really even offended by the Constitutionality thing anymore these days. Do I get greatly annoyed? Yes. Offended? No. Why? Because I realize that pretty much every single President under the sun is whimsical and self-serving in their suggestions of what is Constitutional and what is not. I mean…Bush did it, Clinton did it (the guy that signed DOMA into law), Reagan, FDR, Kennedy, just go down the list. This is how politics works nowadays and most people don’t understand the Constitution and many that do try to misapply it and subvert it. I am not really surprised they use this tactic in a pragmatic fashion, even if it annoys me a great deal.

EDIT: I wrote the above paragraph before seeing you mentioning yourself that you were gay, so I can certainly see how you view this as offensive to the core.I have a great number of gay and lesbian friends, and a few bisexual friends, and I really feel for what they have to go through with these religious bigots and this constant tug-of-war and as a result I am more outspoken than the average person about such issues as a result. I’m fully aware this was a political move, I mainly posted this to inform people that may not know about it this, particularly the foreigners who do not get this news as easily.

I understand why they view it as a critical battle, the thing is it just frustrates me when this pretty young blonde woman is having these extravagant movements and everything on the news like this, yet is completely distant and normal acting when she talks about Libyans getting ripped apart by aircraft guns. I guess this is why I never watch Fox news anymore, the people on there are just so pathetic and I have never seen flat out lies or levels of sensationalism that have matched that channel news network so consistently (MSNBC was pretty bad at times but I have not watched them in years). CNN is relatively tolerable now that that jackoff got kicked off the air. As far as respecting their integrity, you have the right to have that opinion, as far as me personally…I don’t respect these types of people whatsoever and I think its nauseating that we even have to have debates over things like this in the 21st century.

I agree with all of this, but I am not exactly surprised. In fact I am not really even offended by the Constitutionality thing anymore these days. Do I get greatly annoyed? Yes. Offended? No. Why? Because I realize that pretty much every single President under the sun is whimsical and self-serving in their suggestions of what is Constitutional and what is not. I mean…Bush did it, Clinton did it (the guy that signed DOMA into law), Reagan, FDR, Kennedy, just go down the list. This is how politics works nowadays and most people don’t understand the Constitution and many that do try to misapply it and subvert it. I am not really surprised they use this tactic in a pragmatic fashion, even if it annoys me a great deal.

EDIT: I wrote the above paragraph before seeing you mentioning yourself that you were gay, so I can certainly see how you view this as offensive to the core.I have a great number of gay and lesbian friends, and a few bisexual friends, and I really feel for what they have to go through with these religious bigots and this constant tug-of-war and as a result I am more outspoken than the average person about such issues as a result. I’m fully aware this was a political move, I mainly posted this to inform people that may not know about it this, particularly the foreigners who do not get this news as easily.

No worries, even without the aside I wouldn’t have been offended.

I fully understand why people don’t want gay marriage and I can respect it despite the bias against me personally.

The “rights” that come with marriage are necessary only because the government is violating rights in other ways such as taxation.

Many people are rightly concerned that they may be forced to be more than “tolerant” of gay marriage- they may be forced to become party to it. This is not as far-fetched as many left-leaning people would like you to believe. There have already been lawsuits filed against private businesses for not catering to gay relationships and gay union ceremonies. Amongst these have been photographers, florists, musicians and the list goes on.

When a liberal politician defies common sense, the constitution or even just “the societal norms” to “help” gays I see it only as setting my cause further back. There are in fact a large number of gays that do want to “force their lifestyle” on social conservatives. They aren’t the majority but neither are they some anomaly, right-wing myth or boogie-man.

It is in my self interest to want the same priveleges as straight people as I am a gay individual in a long term committed relationship. We own property and businesses together.

But it is, for myself at least, in my more rational self interest to forgo government created “rights” and priveleges if the likelihood is that my gaining privelege will be turned around and used to violate peoples’ most basic rights such as freedom of association.

The “rights” that come with marriage are necessary only because the government is violating rights in other ways such as taxation.

Many people are rightly concerned that they may be forced to be more than “tolerant” of gay marriage- they may be forced to become party to it. This is not as far-fetched as many left-leaning people would like you to believe. There have already been lawsuits filed against private businesses for not catering to gay relationships and gay union ceremonies. Amongst these have been photographers, florists, musicians and the list goes on.

Here in the UK we have gay ‘civil partnerships’ and have seen a successful civil case brought against Christian hotel owners for not allowing two gay civil partners to sleep in the same room. This was not specifically an anti-gay rule, they did not allow any unmarried couple to sleep in the same room. They were forced to pay £3600 (around $5800) in compensation.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/8266097/Gay-couple-awarded-damages-after-Christian-hotel-owners-refused-to-let-them-share-double-room.html

Further, Catholic adoption agencies were left with forced to compromise their principles or close when the government forced them accept gay adoption.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7806780.stm

Yes, and not only is Obama trawling for the gay vote but I believe he is baiting the Republicans in order to derail them from their cut-spending agenda (which is so pathetic as to be almost unmentionable, though better than the alternative) and I’m sure the GOP will oblige him as they have already engaged on the abortion issue.

Another issue I find interesting is the idea that the Executive branch can decide not to enforce the laws passed by the Legislative branch. Gives a ray of hope that the next President may decide not to enforce Obamacare, maybe other laws.

Here in the UK we have gay ‘civil partnerships’ and have seen a successful civil case brought against Christian hotel …

Further, Catholic adoption agencies were left with forced to compromise their principles or close when the government forced them accept gay adoption…

That’s injustice. However, if we accept that gay people have a right to marry, then we ought to fight both injustices.

Republicans in order to derail them from their cut-spending agenda

Has this developed fairly recently? Last I checked they were just making a pathetic and half-assed attempt and I would have ended up cutting much more waste than these clowns all by myself. That is not to say that it would still be better than Obama’s “I am 5 years old with an unlimited credit card” mentality.

Has this developed fairly recently? Last I checked they were just making a pathetic and half-assed attempt and I would have ended up cutting much more waste than these clowns all by myself. That is not to say that it would still be better than Obama’s “I am 5 years old with an unlimited credit card” mentality.

Right, which is exactly what I said. :thumbsup:

Another issue I find interesting is the idea that the Executive branch can decide not to enforce the laws passed by the Legislative branch. Gives a ray of hope that the next President may decide not to enforce Obamacare, maybe other laws.

Pretty much par for the course for this administration. “Don’t like Obamacare? Are you my buddy? Then don’t worry about it. I’ll give you a waiver.” “Oh, the court system outlawed my oil drilling moratorium. No matter, I’ll just have my bureaucrats sit on the applications.” “I got a czar for everything.”

My question is, why isn’t anyone calling him on it?

My question is, why isn’t anyone calling him on it?

Many are. Unfortunately, the media in this country appears to be state run now.

From the point of view of the religious right, it is a critical battle. It’s one thing not to harras or prosecute gays, quite another to recognize them as equals. So I can respect their integrity if not the principles they apply it to.

D’kian, I’d advise you to check your premises re this sort of apologetic: if the end is wrong, then the means is too. Just so, integrity in pursuing wrong goals is more dangerous than its lack, if the goal is inimical to freedom.

  • ico

That’s injustice. However, if we accept that gay people have a right to marry, then we ought to fight both injustices.

Marriage laws should be extended independent of gender, and independent of children. If one partner gets ill, then the other will need to support them and perhaps even make medical decisions for them. There are of course other examples where one partner needs the support of the other in a proprietary situation, such that only a marriage contract can establish a family bond allowing the competent partner to make decisions for their potentially incapacitated spouse.

There is no excuse for marriage in the absence of children to be anything more, nor less, than a means to formally tell the world who you want to speak for you, legally, should you lose your voice.

  • ico