As I read it, the act is not unconstitutional. http://frwebgate.acc…d=f:publ199.104
It states that the Federal government cannot “require” (force) one state to adhere to the marriage definitions of another state.
It also defines the term “marriage” as used in federal congressional acts to be specific to one man and one woman.
As for what the STATE’s ought to do – Ayn Rand was asked about that:
Q: Should the state prescribe the obligations of a marriage, or should this be left to the contractual desires of the couple?
Ayn Rand
: This is an important and difficult subject, because of two complex issues; the rights of children and property rights.
If two people are married, they may want or have children. Once a child is born, he is entitled to support until he is self supporting.
In general, a husband and wife can make any property arrangements they want. But today, the law is a bit too much on the side of the woman. There was a time when the woman was at the economic mercy of her husband; today, she is not. There is a great deal of irrationality and contradictions in many state marriage laws, so there’s room for improvement, provided thc basic principles are clearly stated and not arbitrary.
The government cannot undertake to enforce any contract any two people decide to make. If your contract falls under a certain legal category, then the government can undertake to enforce it; but it cannot be asked to enforce some contradictory contract. This is one reason why there must be a uniform code of law—why individuals are not entirely free to make contracts in any manner. But proper marriage law-- and even the mixed ones of today allow two parties to make legal contracts regarding their relationship. [FHF 68]
What is your view of laws prohibiting homosexuality and bigamy?
All laws against homosexual acts should be repealed. I do not approve of such practices or regard them as necessarily moral, but it is improper for the law to interfere with a relationship between consenting adults. Laws against corrupting the morals of minors are proper, but adults should be completely free.
Bigamy is a different issue. If a man wants a relationship with two women, he does not need the law to sanction it. But the state should have standards about what it considers a legal marriage. The law should be uniform, and there are good reasons why in most civilized countries marriage is a monogamous institution. lf a man wants a wife and another woman, he doesnʼt need the legality of bigamy if he’s open about it. Bigamy laws concern cases in which a man has two legal wives in two different cities, and leads a double life. Here there are good grounds, legally and morally, to prosecute him. [FHF 68]
–
[
Ayn Rand Answers
](http://www.amazon.com/Ayn-Rand-Answers-Best-Her/dp/0451216652)