I just got home from a Health Care Forum sponsored by a local news station (Denver, 9news). The governor and six of Colorado’s U.S. congresspeople and senators answered questions. I plan on blogging about it once I organize my notes. But there is one very specific topic I would like to hear your opinions on.
As I striving/budding Objectivist I understand that health care is not a right. One man in the audience talked about his daughter being born with issues requiring 27 surgeries, and Ed Perlmutter (Colorado Congressman) mentioned his epileptic daughter in his response. The citizen complained of not being able to get insurance for his daughter’s pre-existing condition.
Here are my questions - please understand I’m not arguing for these positions, I’m asking how the Objectivist explains rights and values regarding these situations.
First, is it necessary for all couples who plan on having a child to be financially able to deal with all possible birth defects before giving birth to that child? I would think the answer is no, so then those unlucky parents who don’t have the means are just that - unlucky, and they just have to do the best they can? For a modern civilization like ours, with the knowledge and means to repair many birth defects, does society have a duty to heal those children? If no, why not? I can see part of the problem is defining which parents can and cannot afford that care. But I need much help on this issue.
Secondly, one of my favorite charities is Operation Smile. Doctors and nurses donate their time and materials to travel around the world, mostly to quite impoverished areas, and perform cleft lip and cleft palate surgery on children whose parents have no possible means to get that service. Now, my first solution to that problem is rights protected by rule of law and free-market capitalism to empower those people. But until that happens how do you justify not helping such a child left behind after Operation Smile has spent all their donations and has to return home. I assume part of the explanation is how do you define who needs what, and where does the definition of “need” end? And I can accept that. But repairing a birth defect like a cleft palate is a simple operation and many of these kids suffer unnecessarily for years. Surely that does fall under any definition of “need” that could be defined? Is it really enough to say, well they are a third world country and the rest of the world just can’t fix everyone else’s problems?
Bob
I first looked into your thread because of the title “Pre-existing Conditions”, which I expect few really understand. However, your thread is not about that. I suggest that you change it something about children. First let me make a brief comment about pre-existing conditions. All this term means, in insurance speak, is that the person is already sick or injured. Someone complaining about not having insurance because of a pre-existing condition is like someone whose house is on fire complaining that he can’t now get fire insurance.
You are conflating two different ideas, and your opponents are doing their best to maintain that confusion. No one with any benevolence at all wants a child to be hurt, impaired, or mistreated. They will wish that they could do what they could or what needs to be done. But this desire is always considered within the context of a person’s own context, their own values.
What your opponents want is to use this desire as a justification to force everyone to finance that and much more. They are saying that since you want to help a child we will enslave you. After these bills are passed, you will see some people’s children get wonderful care and other’s get almost nothing, depending on time, luck, who they know. The priority of helping your own children or your brother’s children, your own values will be undercut.
So they are using your own benevolence to undercut your resistance to force.
They do this all the time. When they forced through the various acts giving the disabled special privileges some Senator or Congressman always had a sob story about their close relative. Everyone cried and voted to force U.S. citizens to submit. Sad, sob stories are always attempts to blur the issue.
Steadfastness and clear answers are always the best response. Answers must always clearly identify the morality involved.
What issues a couple should consider before having a baby is very contextual. I think that it would be tough to be thinking that their child would have manor medical problems. Nonetheless, they do need to have thought about their financial situation and how they will take care of their baby.
Your last question needs to be stated more broadly, in that there are lots of situations that need to be fixed. It certainly is the case that a any particular time there is only a certain amount of assets. Only a limited amount can be done. Our ability to do anything is being limited by the effects of government on our productive ability. This is all within the context of our own values, too. So, yes, we can’t do everything. But the real problem in your last paragraph is that it is a thrid world country. It can’t do anything for itself because it remains a thrid world country. Really, the best thing that can be done for them is to teach them in some manner how to be a productive country. Then they can save their own children.