So I have read numerous pieces on both health care and abortion and the like in general, and I agree with all of them. I seem to have come to a point that I am having trouble giving an answer that I feel is sufficient however, not only to myself but also to those of the more liberal mindset that have different views on economics and the like.
There was some commentary made about the recent Planned Parenthood funding debacle, and the fact that peopel are not entitled to basic health care, and that it is a violation of individual rights, and therefore unethical, to force people to pay for these things, particularly if they do not agree with what those services might be.
However, I am unsure how to give a sufficient answer to some of these people about their situation given how much of a mess health care in general, and particularly the insurance companies are these days, as well as the big problem of general access. I am aware that in one state for instance, there is either only one clinic that provides abortion services, or none at all. (This is a pretty redneck state if I remember correctly). In others there are only one or two.
So a questions were posed to me, and I do not want to answer them withotu a sufficient answer. If I cannot find my own answers satisfactory, certainly neither will they, but I KNOW there is a satisfactory answer. These are the questions that were posed to me:
"What would be your alternative? Considering privatized health care allows physicians to decide whether to treat a woman based on irrational ‘moral’ ideals, what are individuals who seek a certain type of care to do if their doctor refuses to treat them?
I then responded: I am guessing you are talking about availability of abortion services correct?
Their response:
Not entirely, I’ve been turned down for birth control before and I know women who don’t get PAP tests, breast exams, etc. because they can’t afford them. Some insurance companies don’t cover birth control either.
Another poster:
I agree with Rachel. Pharmacists are legally allowed to deny birth control/morning after pill due to religious reasons. When I first got on the pill it cost me over $30 a month, insurance covers nothing…I eventually got a different prescription after fighting my doctor over it (she wasn’t happy about an unmarried woman wanting birth control so she stuck me with an expensive prescription when I SPECIFICALLY asked for the generic walmart version that was about $20 cheaper.), but some women aren’t as lucky as me. I’m so fucking tired of someone else’s religion dictating when I can take my reproductive freedom into my own hands.
An objectivist poster responds:
why can’t Planned Parenthood rely on funding through charitable donations? If people think it’s worthwhile, then donate. What I don’t understand is why you think forcing people against their will to fund it is at all morally acceptable?
The original questioner:
They get funding from donations, it’s not enough
An objectivist:
So many Conservatives are happy because they reject abortion, no matter how funded— it’s not about abortion, it’s about using tax $$ for something other than defence & courts, but the most GOPers dunno that
So many Liberals (w/ big ell) are unhappy because they see this as more than an attack on abortion, but the usurpation of advancing their social causes— it’s not about abortion but using tax $$ for something other than defence & the courts, but Liberals don’t see that:
Nothing i stand for concerns a woman & her personal choices regarding her body-- i would help her, if i knew her.
neither one of the parties get it…
One of the liberals:
that’s kind of an illogical conclusion Michael. Planned Parenthood mostly helps poor or young (also poor) people get reproductive health care, how are the people who can’t afford condoms and birth control supposed to fund the entire organization, hmm? I would give as much money as I could to planned parenthood, but I’m a college student with little money.
The other liberal:
Obviously we need more donations but donations do not cover it. I want to hear alternatives other than finding another doctor.
I apologize for the mess of quotes…but the conversation evolved into these posts whilst I was posting this…and I figured if I am going to post about this I might as well try to get the best answer I can…I appreciate any assistance in this matter.