Prove that god doesn't exist. (Proving a negative)

By Pantheist I really meant that I just dig the universe. That I am a reality worshiper. I don’t see the problem with this in terms of Objectivism. I may be using the term wrong. I really, really, am an atheist, I just dig reality and tend wax poetic.

From Wikipedia:

(Greek: πάν ( ‘pan’ ) = all and θεός ( ‘theos’ ) = God, it literally means “God is All” and “All is God”.) Pantheism is the view that everything is of an all-encompassing immanent abstract God; or that the Universe, or nature, and God are equivalent.

Doesn’t sound like “Pantheist” is a good term to describe someone who rejects the concept of God.

By Pantheist I really meant that I just dig the universe. That I am a reality worshiper. I don’t see the problem with this in terms of Objectivism. I may be using the term wrong. I really, really, am an atheist, I just dig reality and tend wax poetic.

Yeah, i just dont see the value of “All is God”/“God is All”, instead of “All is All”. Also, i must obviously mention here, that we are talking about naturalistic pantheism here, if it hasnt been mentioned already, as there are many other types of pantheism, that clearly believe in the supernatural etc.

This is really difficult for me to debate, because im really not sure what im debating here. Becuase it still seems like calling the universe God, doesnt make any sense…

If you want to differentiate yourself from relativist or “there is no reality”-type atheists, i wouldnt recommend using the word pantheist. I think the word Objectivist is quite sufficient in describing “what kind of” atheist you are.

I think the wikipedia article on Naturalistic pantheism, has one very telling paragraph: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_pantheism

Naturalistic pantheism places little emphasis on the concept of God. This raises the concern that it is really no longer pantheism at all, but something more like “spiritual naturalism” or “feel-good atheism”. After all, these critics ask, if you remove the concept of God from your philosophy, what is the purpose of using the term “pantheism?” It is charged that the etymology of the word reveals it is inappropriately used in describing an anti-theist philosophy. In answer to this objection, naturalistic pantheists maintain that the “pan-” prefix modifies the “-theism” suffix to such an extent that pantheism in fact has little to do with traditional theism.

The fact that someone thinks that the prefix “pan-”, that means “all”, or in this case “all is”, somehow modifies the suffix after it is totally absurd? How does the statement “All is God”, modify the meaning of “God”?

also in the same article:

An argument intended to show that the term “pantheism” remains appropriate for the modern, or naturalistic interpretation of pantheism is that the contemporary pantheist sees the term “God” as a synonym for “nature”. If nature is equivalent to the theological concept of God, then saying “all is God” (pan-theism) is the same as saying “all is nature”. Accordingly, this is the way that many pantheists choose to view the term “pantheism” — all is nature, nature is all. Pantheism, then, is (in this view) essentially a form of spirituality based on nature rather than on supernatural entities such as deities. Accordingly, it is widely accepted that the modern interpretation of pantheism is essentially naturalistic, and therefore constitutes a form of naturalistic spirituality.

If “all is nature”, then “all is nature”. If you want to base your spirituality on nature instead of deities, then dont use the word of a deity, God, but use the word for nature, that is…ummmm…let me think…NATURE!

I really cant wrap my head around this, because im not even sure what im trying to debate here. Its like someone called baseball basketball, but still meant baseball.

first of all, the libertarian part obviously struck my eye, but what is weird is that “critic of homosexuality” is listed in such a short summation of Ayn Rand. Sure, she was a critic, but that is not in any way a cornerstone of her philosophy, so why would someone add it in such a short summation…

It is non-essential, but it is a view that Miss Rand held and thus valid, although there are MANY here who evade that fact. I personally think the evasion of that fact is many, many times more immoral than homosexuality could ever be considered.

It is non-essential, but it is a view that Miss Rand held and thus valid, although there are MANY here who evade that fact. I personally think the evasion of that fact is many, many times more immoral than homosexuality could ever be considered.

Yes, but it was not one of the foundations of her philosophy, it was a conclusion she made by using her philosophy. Every conclusion she may have made using her philosophy, is not the same thing as saying that all those conclusions are correct. As far as i have understood/applied Objectivism, is by looking at it from the bottom up. The critique of homosexuality is not something that lies near the “bottom” part of her philosophy, so its odd that it was singled out in a description of her. Its a bit like saying that: “Ayn Rand, novelist and philosopher, critic of the IRS, and founder of the objectivist school of metaphysics, famous for writing Atlas Shrugged and The Virtue of Selfishness.”. Sure, she probably was a critic of the IRS, but i wouldnt choose to include that fact in a short summation of her.

edit: i edited out the comments about homosexuality, as i really dont want to have this debate now…

Uh-oh… Here we go again…

Uh-oh… Here we go again…

yeah, i edited them out, as i noticed that i made one of the most annoying things a “debater” can do. I said “i dont want this to become a discussion about topic X…after which i myself discussed topic X”

So yeah, the thing i was trying to say was that the topic whether homosexuality is moral or immoral, is not at the foundation of Objectivism. Objectivism is true, even if homosexuality is moral or immoral. The only debatable thing that remains is, whether it is or not. It was a conclusion Rand made by using her philosophical foundation, but that does not equate, that every conclusion she made using her philosophy, is necessarily true…

It was a conclusion Rand made by using her philosophical foundation, but that does not equate, that every conclusion she made using her philosophy, is necessarily true…

I have never claimed or would \ *ever * claim this. In fact, the exact opposite has almost always been true in regards to myself, i.e., what I have always thought has been explicitly stated in Miss Rand works. When I was a kid I always kind of wished that there was “some book on life” or something that explained the world as I saw it. I discovered this book (or essentially a whole library of them–the Objectivist corpus) at about the age of 24, quite by accident. I think if anyone that has ever met me in real life heard someone accuse me of not being a completely *independent thinker* they would laugh in your face. But, this is way off-topic, of course.

I have never claimed or would \ *ever * claim this. In fact, the exact opposite has almost always been true in regards to myself, i.e., what I have always thought has been explicitly stated in Miss Rand works. When I was a kid I always kind of wished that there was “some book on life” or something that explained the world as I saw it. I discovered this book (or essentially a whole library of them–the Objectivist corpus) at about the age of 24, quite by accident. I think if anyone that has ever met me in real life heard someone accuse me of not being a completely *independent thinker* they would laugh in your face. But, this is way off-topic, of course.

I didnt mean to claim that you did claim that, and im sorry if it looked like that. I just wanted to point out that the topic of homosexuality is different to the topic of, let’s say, what reality is. And i would even go as far as saying that it is fairly irrelevant to an honest Objectivist, WHAT, Rand herself thought of homosexuality.

The fact whether homosexuality is wrong or not, is based on “what is a homosexual”. If you apply the Objectivist principles to decide whether it is wrong, but have faulty information of what a homosexual is, you can make a faulty judgement on the subject. However, that does not mean that Objectivism itself is wrong, just your judgement based on faulty information. Therefore Ayn Rands views on homosexuality are not in any way central to her philosophy, and her possibly having faulty information about a certain subject, has no bearing on whether Objectivism is a valid philosophy.

Therefore, i think it was quite intellectually dishonest(or just an ignorant mistake) of the person that made the wikipedia entry, to have her view on homosexuality printed, without any explanation on the foundations of her philosophy, as that makes it seem like her view on homosexuality is somehow at the foundation of what Objectivism is.

So…back to pantheism.

Words have meanings, God has a meaning (even if it’s a completely malleable definition to almost anyone who actually believes in god), nature has a meaning, theism has a meaning. The prefix “-pan” has a meaning. I see no reason to call oneself a “pantheist” if one rejects the concept of God. God =/= nature, and God =/= universe. Using those terms interchangeably is folly.

So…back to pantheism.

Words have meanings, God has a meaning (even if it’s a completely malleable definition to almost anyone who actually believes in god), nature has a meaning, theism has a meaning. The prefix “-pan” has a meaning. I see no reason to call oneself a “pantheist” if one rejects the concept of God. God =/= nature, and God =/= universe. Using those terms interchangeably is folly.

Eh, very well then.

Edit: Just to be safe and explain what I mean, I suppose “naturalistic pantheist” describes what I meant best. God is, at best, a personification of the underlying order of the universe. I really haven’t commented on the discussion because its not really an essential thing and you all made fairly good points. I suppose it was just a very, very odd way of describing things. It didn’t really matter. I have a tendency to use words strange sometimes. Sorry for the confusion, I guess?

It is simple to prove god does not exist, well simple after reading Ms. Rand. One need only use Ms. Rand’s argument on existence. Thesist argue that god created existence, but we know existence exists, an axiom validated on every statement if only by the fact someone is making it. Without existence, there can be no consciousness; there could be no god. To quote Ms. Rand, “a consciousness with nothing to be conscious of is a contradiction in terms.” So god as a consciousness could not have existed prior to existence meaning the god theists defend could not exist as they define him. Existence, even this god’s own, MUST have preceded consciousness meaning god could not have created existence nor been conscious prior to existence meaning this god could not exist as defined and identified by theists. So, even if some powerful entity did exist, this entity would be finite and subject to the physical laws of the universe, as Peikoff explained in OPAR. This would not be and could not be a god, nor could an infinite, omnipotent deity possibly exist.

Kritiker, I thought that argument was good enough too - but nope, they (theists) have an excuse for everything. Just read my thread about a recent exchange I had with a very rock-headed theist in my philosophy class:

http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.php?showtopic=13013

all religious people are 100% ATHEIST when it comes to Shiva, Ra, and Joseph Smith, you can point that out, but that doesn’t solve the core issue:

they consider their mind a “soul” outside their grasp. they have their reasons, the mind is still to be fully understood. But it belongs to reallity (that where we differ)

The irritating thing about religionists is that while they use mysticism as a defence from the unknown, they at the other hand claim to know the absolute truth: “god”

Hi,

Just had an idea about disproving a default god figure.

premise 1: god is perfect

premise 2: god created man

premise 3: man is imperfect

question 1: if a perfect god created an imperfect man, why does man have to constantly apologize to god about his sins, although it’s not actually man’s fault that he’s imperfect?

question 2: if it’s not man’s fault that he’s imperfect, then it’s god’s fault, but how can it be god’s fault if he’s perfect?

conclusion 1: god is contradictory to himself

*OR*

conclusion 2: one of the premises are wrong. but which one? that god is perfect, that god created man, or that man is imperfect? either way, religion is wrong, because this means that either:

  1. god isn’t perfect

  2. god didn’t create man

  3. man is perfect

now, you could debate about the meaning of “perfect”, but I used it here in a religious “sin”-thing sense

No. God IS perfect, and PERFECTLY created an IMPERFECT man so that the IMPERFECT man could persue an endless struggle towards PERFECTION.

That’s the Judeo/Christian theist’s argument. I won’t comment on the sanity of it.

my experience - don’t go too much logical with them… they just don’t get it :smiley:

BAD EXAMPLE:

atheist: god is absolutely righteous, right?

prehistoric man: yes

atheist: by being absolutely righteous, he is being absolutely objecitve, right?

prehistoric man: yes

atheist: god *wanted* to create the universe, right?

prehistoric man: yes

atheist: then in that moment, he acted subjectively, right?

prehistoric man: yes

atheist: so god is not absolutely objective, and thus not absolutely righteous, which makes him only partialy righteous?

prehistoric man: no, you see, it’s all written in the bible… once upon a time in a galaxy far, far away…

zZzZ…

ps: I was raised as a catholic so it took some time until I concluded that the existence of god makes things much more complicated than the nonexistence of god. And as we can see, nature has a habit of making things less complicated when possible, so it seems natural to me that god therefore doesn’t exist.

In order for the process of rational argument (and the associated potential persuasion) to work, the parties involved need to be rational. Arguing with an irrational person is doomed to fail, because at any point they can claim “A is B” to backup their position.

I’m convinced that it’s not possible to be both fully rational and be a religionist or any other type of mystic – which means that arguing with them is doomed to fail.

I think this is also the root cause of why religionists so often end up wanting to kill people who don’t believe the same thing they do – their irrationality works against them when they try to persuade non-believers, and in the end all that’s left is violence.

I’m also convinced that the majority of humans have a very difficult time separating things like feelings, imagination and dreams from objective reality. Most people I know believe that knowledge of their surroundings can be obtained through those mechanisms. Many even believe that they can learn about far-away places, alternate dimensions, other universes, etc, that way. They combine imagination with personal desire and emotion, and construct a virtual world that becomes their “reality,” and as a consequence, they also stop perceiving many details about the real world.

Great post NickS. I have thought about this before and am considering it again: I would like to create a wiki in which people can list all the lines of reasoning regarding the existence of God, the counterarguments, the counter-counter arguments, etc. In comparison to Wikipedia - each article would be an argument or a response to an argument (or both). And at the end of that article would be all the responses to that article. Since it seems to me that religious responses are commonly constructed to be syntactically/grammatically correct, but are usually incoherent (e.g. “God is existence; God loves you; So existence loves you”), I I think if we finally got something like that down into writing, we could determine under what conditions the religious resort to certain arguments. You could categorize everything, and then create a category tree to see which responses are most common, which are least common, and under what conditions certain responses are made (this would lead to further categorization). Maybe we could eventually learn something about the nature of this need for God.

The reality of the situation is beautiful.

This is a beautiful statement Nick! Did you come up with it yourself or is this something Rand said somewhere?