I asked, “In Objectivist morality, one has a duty not to violate the rights of humans, right?” And I got two answers:
(1) “No. Morally, there is no “duty” to anyone or anything except for yourself.” [ex_banana-eater]
(2) “Wrong. Violating others’ rights is irrational and unselfish, but there is no duty to refrain from it.” [y_feldblum]
Either Objectivism is inconsistent, or it’s open-ended as to whether one has a duty to oneself, or one of the above is inconsistent with Objectivism.
Also, (1) seems to respond as if I had mentioned a duty to others, which I did not.
Both answers are corrects and say essentially the same thing.
Anyway, aside from whether ‘moral’ implies ‘duty’ (even duty to self), Objectivsm holds that it is not moral to violate the rights of others. And animals have no rights. Therefore, any immorality from torturing animals would have to be that torturing animals is not selfish, not an immorality of violating rights. Is that correct? That retains the meaning of my original questions but without ‘duty’.
On Objectivist ethics, egoism is moral and altruism is immoral. Respecting others’ right is moral because it is selfish, not because anybody is under a gategorical imperative to do so.
It follows from the premises. You just disagree with the premises. Moreover, if you believe there are no duties and if you belive there should not be laws against animal torture, then you must believe there is no duty not to torture animals and there should be no laws against animal torture. So even if you think that conclusion does not follow from the premises, the conclusion is still true in your view.
Do you really think playing word games is going to get you anywhere? It’s not relevant to this point whether some unrelated argument you made is valid. I’m neither going to confirm nor deny the validity or truth of your unrelated argument. I’m going to ignore it.
PC has nothing to do with it. But, it’s true that if you don’t believe that a moral theory needs to address things that nearly all people find morally repugnant, then you have no need for your moral theory to take account of such things.
Ethics - Ayn Rand’s, anyway - addresses all of human action. However, lots of people feeling one way about something is not relevant.
Because it accounts for what was discussed above.
It’s arbitrary. The arbitrary can account for nothing.
If one doesn’t feel that needs to be accounted for, then no solution is needed. But since there are people who do believe it needs to be accounted for, Moose’s proposal does offer a solution. It’s cogent since it gets to the essence of the contrast between reason and pain.
We need to account for lots of people feeling one way about something?
I’ve posted nothing that implies anything like that.
Your every single sentence reeks of the implication.
No it’s not. The original concerned physical pain only.
I’m not even going to pretend I care.
I’m not asking for personal moral guidance from you.
I was not offering it. I was pointing out that to seek moral guidance - from oneself -, one must have clearly identified one’s own standard of value. Have you?