Question About Animal Cruelty

I asked, “In Objectivist morality, one has a duty not to violate the rights of humans, right?” And I got two answers:

(1) “No. Morally, there is no “duty” to anyone or anything except for yourself.” [ex_banana-eater]

(2) “Wrong. Violating others’ rights is irrational and unselfish, but there is no duty to refrain from it.” [y_feldblum]

Either Objectivism is inconsistent, or it’s open-ended as to whether one has a duty to oneself, or one of the above is inconsistent with Objectivism.

Also, (1) seems to respond as if I had mentioned a duty to others, which I did not.

Both answers are corrects and say essentially the same thing.

Anyway, aside from whether ‘moral’ implies ‘duty’ (even duty to self), Objectivsm holds that it is not moral to violate the rights of others. And animals have no rights. Therefore, any immorality from torturing animals would have to be that torturing animals is not selfish, not an immorality of violating rights. Is that correct? That retains the meaning of my original questions but without ‘duty’.

On Objectivist ethics, egoism is moral and altruism is immoral. Respecting others’ right is moral because it is selfish, not because anybody is under a gategorical imperative to do so.

It follows from the premises. You just disagree with the premises. Moreover, if you believe there are no duties and if you belive there should not be laws against animal torture, then you must believe there is no duty not to torture animals and there should be no laws against animal torture. So even if you think that conclusion does not follow from the premises, the conclusion is still true in your view.

Do you really think playing word games is going to get you anywhere? It’s not relevant to this point whether some unrelated argument you made is valid. I’m neither going to confirm nor deny the validity or truth of your unrelated argument. I’m going to ignore it.

PC has nothing to do with it. But, it’s true that if you don’t believe that a moral theory needs to address things that nearly all people find morally repugnant, then you have no need for your moral theory to take account of such things.

Ethics - Ayn Rand’s, anyway - addresses all of human action. However, lots of people feeling one way about something is not relevant.

Because it accounts for what was discussed above.

It’s arbitrary. The arbitrary can account for nothing.

If one doesn’t feel that needs to be accounted for, then no solution is needed. But since there are people who do believe it needs to be accounted for, Moose’s proposal does offer a solution. It’s cogent since it gets to the essence of the contrast between reason and pain.

We need to account for lots of people feeling one way about something?

I’ve posted nothing that implies anything like that.

Your every single sentence reeks of the implication.

No it’s not. The original concerned physical pain only.

I’m not even going to pretend I care.

I’m not asking for personal moral guidance from you.

I was not offering it. I was pointing out that to seek moral guidance - from oneself -, one must have clearly identified one’s own standard of value. Have you?

Animals do not have rights. Rights are derived from man’s rational faculty, his ability to use reason. Animals have no such faculty. They have no rights.

Men are not duty-bound to animals in any way. We may torture them if we wish, but one would have to ask what value you could gain from it. If you gain a value (like scientific knowledge or whatever) it would not be immoral. Each case is contextual.

Objectivism is neither open-ended or inconsistent. Neither statements you quoted from ex-banana-eater and y_feldblum contradicted each other.

If you define duty as ‘moral obligation’ then the only duty you have is to yourself. You have a moral obligation to sustain your own life by your own effort. If you define duty as ‘an action required of you for no reason’ (as most of us understand the term used today) you have no duties whatsoever.

The problem I think you are having here is differentiating between have and should.

You have to sustain your life by some means. You should sustain your life through your own work and effort, but that is a choice you have to make. You can be a producer or a leech. Objectivism holds that the only moral way to live is by your own effort.

Both answers are corrects and say essentially the same thing.

No they don’t. (1) says one has duties to oneself and (2) says one has no duties.

Both answers are corrects and say essentially the same thing.

On Objectivist ethics, egoism is moral and altruism is immoral. Respecting others’ right is moral because it is selfish, not because anybody is under a gategorical imperative to do so.

Who said anything about a categorical imperative?

It’s not relevant to this point whether some unrelated argument you made is valid.

You cared enough to claim that it was not.

We need to account for lots of people feeling one way about something

I make no claim about your needs.

Your every single sentence reeks of the implication.

A non sequitur drawn through your nose.

I was not offering it.

So your “I cannot answer this for you, Lauric, until you state your standard of value” is vacuous utterance.

Have you?

It’s not the question of this thread.

Okay, so if animals do not have rights, does that mean that it’s morally okay to torture them?

In the usual sense in which this is meant, the answer is NO it is not moral to torture animals. However, this does not come from the idea of rights.

More broadly, morality is not based on rights. Rights are based on morality. Objectivism does not say: “We have rights, therefore this is moral/immoral.” Rather, it says: “This is moral. Therefore, when we deal with others, we have rights.”

PS: When you say “torture”, I assume you do not mean activities like scientific experiments, but rather a wanton infliction of pain, almost “for the heck of it”.

Okay, so it is immoral, but what is it that makes it immoral?

Okay, so it is immoral, but what is it that makes it immoral?

Quite simple. The moral is that which is in your rational self-interest. Torturing an animal for the sake of torture can never be in one’s rational self-interest. In fact, it’s usually a sign of psychological illness. I don’t have any solid figures on hand, but many psychopaths, murderers, rapists, etc have had histories of animal cruelty.

We may torture them if we wish, but one would have to ask what value you could gain from it.  If you gain a value (like scientific knowledge or whatever) it would not be immoral.

What are the Objectivist definitions of ‘a right’, ‘moral’, and ‘immoral’? What are the necessary and sufficient conditions upon which an act is a violation of rights, an act is moral, and an act is immoral?

Is an act moral if and only if it is selfish of the person doing it and not in violation of rights? Or is it moral if and only if it is thought to be selfish by the person doing it and not in violation of rights? Or neither of those? Also, is there a difference between selfishness and rational selfishness?

Is it immoral just to kick a pebble if one has no scientific knowledge to gain from doing so nor any gain other than the merest wisp of amusement in watching it move? If it is not immoral to kick a pebble, then why would it be immoral to torture an animal?

If you define duty as ‘moral obligation’ then the only duty you have is to yourself.  You have a moral obligation to sustain your own life by your own effort.  If you define duty as ‘an action required of you for no reason’ (as most of us understand the term used today) you have no duties whatsoever.

Usually in the field of ethics, ‘duty’ is meant in the first sense you mentioned. So, does one have a duty (to oneself) not to violate the rights of others?

The problem I think you are having here is differentiating between have and should.

What about my posts makes you think that?

You have to sustain your life by some means.  You should sustain your life through your own work and effort, but that is a choice you have to make.  You can be a producer or a leech.  Objectivism holds that the only moral way to live is by your own effort.

I take it that ‘should’ is synonymous with ‘have a moral obligation’. And I take it that one’s moral obligations are to promote one’s (rational) selfishness (but does Objectivism hold that there is a moral obligation not to violate rights of others as a corollary of one’s moral obligation to oneself?). Now, what is the proof that it is not in one’s (rational) self-interest to live off others if it were economically rewarding to do so? For that matter, how does anyone determine the rationality or selfishness of another person’s decisions about how to promote his own survival and happiness? If someone decides on a certain set of enjoyments or a lifetime of them, then how does another person decide that that program of enjoyments and the means to them is irrational? If the program gets the person the pleasures, enjoyments, benefits, or utility the person wants, then how would it be irrational? And if the program turns out unsuccessful, then how is that not just a mistaken calculation, just as a mistaken financial investment is not a mistake of morality? Or is a mistaken investment also an immoral act?

This forum is really a supplement to Ayn Rand’s writings, LauricAcid, where these issues are addressed over and over in VOS, CUI, and OPAR.

Thank you, ex_banana-eater. I found FaSheezy’s post to be lucid and helpful. I am hoping that he or someone else will shed light on the questions as I have focused them, if you’ll forgive the unmixed metaphor.

Okay, so if animals do not have rights, does that mean that it’s morally okay to torture them?

What do you mean by “torture”..?!

The flaky use of language around here is very bizarre to me.

What is the purpose of a human beings action on an animal? If it’s purpose is to

simply inflict pain then it’s immoral, unless pain measurement for some other

purpose is the goal.

If simple sadism, the enjoyment of another beings pain, is the goal, then your

being a sadist, not an objectivist.

Your freakin’ fuzzyheadedness in asking this NON-QUESTION is amazing.

Now,.. ask a real question Moose.

-Iakeo

http://teachanimalobjectivity.homestead.co…les/return2.htm

I put in “I think therefore I am” in Google and I got that horrible essay. I wanted to scream at my computer when I got to the “what good has thinking done for us anyway” parts. I just can’t belive people can say this stuff with a straight face.

Have a look at this clip from Trading Spouses (http://www.break.com/articles/tradingspouses2.html).

A man was recently arrested in Dayton for leaving his dogs outdoors during a cold snap: they froze to death. Now, I like dogs (well, the nice kind), so I think this is sad, but he’s already lost his dogs, he doesn’t deserve to go to jail. It’s like putting someone in prison because they left their Christmas lights on and burned their house down.

A man was recently arrested in Dayton for leaving his dogs outdoors during a cold snap: they froze to death. Now, I like dogs (well, the nice kind), so I think this is sad, but he’s already lost his dogs, he doesn’t deserve to go to jail. It’s like putting someone in prison because they left their Christmas lights on and burned their house down.

I suppose that depends on whether you believe that choosing to purchase an animal for a pet constitutes a responsibility to look after it. Someone who mistakenly left their children outside would probably face legal penalties involving negligence, although I’m not convinced that this is justified since there was no intent and noone can be compensated.

I suppose that depends on whether you believe …

Well, let’s look at a key difference here within this context;

Children (not property, volitional being with rights)

vs.

Pets (property, no rights)

House (property, no rights)

For my take on animal rights, see this post in an earlier thread.

http://teachanimalobjectivity.homestead.co…les/return2.htm

I put in “I think therefore I am” in Google and I got that horrible essay. I wanted to scream at my computer when I got to the “what good has thinking done for us anyway” parts. I just can’t belive people can say this stuff with a straight face.

I just finished reading “The Ominous Parallels” and I found the part about emotionalism in the Weimar Republic rather intriguing, and I now know why, because every time I have encountered people whom write garbage like this I was thinking exactly what Peikoff described, I am speaking to future intellectual advocates and storm-troopers for what could be the future tyrant of Fascist America. The unfortunate thing about this is that you can not force-feed logical thought into people, because that would probably be the only way to solve a problem like this.

The greenfreaks, enviro-mystics and animal nazis get these kids when their early, and the result is “I think therefore I am not”. May Mother Gaia burn in hell, and may all her worshippers discover their true nature, as my emoticon reveals it to them. :slight_smile:

Some fool who burns his house down is a wee bit different conceptually from someone who leaves living beings outside to freeze to death because of his incompetence. In one respect, he is only harming himself. In the other, he is harming other sentient creatures. It’s a very bad analogy.

Non-sentient property is different from sentient property. You have a duty to care for living creatures you purchase. It really doesn’t matter whether or not they are volitional or in possion of “rational” attributes. He shouldn’t even be an animal owner. He’s not responsible or intelligent enough. Quite often, killing something that can feel is worse ethically stand accidentally destroying your own property.

Dogs, like many other animals, have interests of avoiding pain and death. Freezing to death by someone’s ineptitude is contrary to that. A house has no interests. It’s not even possible because it lacks fundamental sentience as a prerequisite. You ought to value sentient beings more than inanimate objects. You can always buy another identical inanimate item.

You ought to value sentient beings more than inanimate objects.

This sounds as if you are saying that “sentient beings” are intrinsically more valuable than inanimate objects. How do you objectively determine which has more value to everyone, in every situation?

This sounds as if you are saying that “sentient beings” are intrinsically more valuable than inanimate objects. How do you objectively determine which has more value to everyone, in every situation?

As far as I can gather this can’t be done, such values are relative to the individual in possession of both types of property, hense any laws past would be irrational. I reserve the right to my opinion that people who irrationally destroy their own property are immoral because of their actions, but there is no way I can justify “any opinion” being made into law without becoming a tyrant in the process.