Question About Animal Cruelty

hense any laws past would be irrational.

I didn’t ask anything about any laws. He made the moral evaluation;

You ought to value sentient beings more than inanimate objects.

Why does “sentient” property intrinsically have more value than inanimate property?

To take this a step back, does all sentient life have greater value than all inanimate objects merely because of their sentience?

The reason why rational faculty comes into play is because that is part of what determines rights. Dogs have no more rights than houses.

Indeed. I don’t drink much milk, but I eat meat, so cows are more valuable to me dead than alive, and my computer is more valuable than any cow because it enables me to more easily pursue my work. Property is property, regardless of any ancillary properties of that property. The ability to feel pain is not essential to rights, only rationality confers rights.

Non-sentient property is different from sentient property. You have a duty to care for living creatures you purchase

No, you only have a duty to the extent that the creature advances your life. This would be true for creatures purchased or found, and for inanimate objects as well. The difference between living and non-living objects is that a non-living object can’t die, but of course it can rust. The real issue is how robust the entity is. Cars can take more neglect than houseplants, which can take more neglect than cats. Dogs and milk cows are comparable, I’d say, in their neediness. I would bet that the guy in Dayton simply was clueless about his particular dog. I am happiest when it gets to be well below zero and we have lots of snow – I can stay in my pen outside for weeks if I need to. Emmilou Harris should be ashamed for advocating cruelty towards some dogs. OTOH my annoying Chihuahua colleague next door can’t stand the cold for more than a couple of minutes. As Helli Hansen says “There’s no bad weather, just bad clothing” (loses a bit in translation, I guess). I don’t even think it’s reasonable to criticize the poor guy for his cluelessness.

At any rate, animals have the same rights as lampposts, namely none. We tend to like animals (especially mammals) because they’re so cute and fun, but that doesn’t confer rights on them.

If I knew that my neighbour was torturing his cat then I would have no problem taking the cat from him, and I certainly wouldnt class this as being theft. I’m not sure how to interpret this in terms of animal rights, but meh.

I didn’t ask anything about any laws. He made the moral evaluation;

True, but I’ve often found that such views lead to the “there ought to be a law” discussion, and I was just launching a pre-emptive strike to knock that out of the water. As far as a moral evalution, I guess I can say that I don’t fit into his moral standard then because I value my leather jackets more than a cow bred and slaughtered on a far in the Mid-West.

If I knew that my neighbour was torturing his cat then I would have no problem taking the cat from him, and I certainly wouldnt class this as being theft. I’m not sure how to interpret this in terms of animal rights, but meh.

It’s not theft, it’d be a mugging or robbery. My suggestion would be to offer an inducement to _ buy _ the cat from him if it bothers you so much. Either that or go inside. Nothing else is within your rights.

If I knew that my neighbour was torturing his cat then I would have no problem taking the cat from him, and I certainly wouldnt class this as being theft. I’m not sure how to interpret this in terms of animal rights, but meh.

Well, it’s his property and presumably you are taking it against his will, so it doesn’t matter that you don’t think it’s theft, it still fits the elements of theft. Aside from that, the morality of the law aside, many if not all jurisdictions in the US have laws against “torturing” animals (perhaps the UK does too). Therefore, you would also be taking the law into your own hands rather than calling the appropriate third party (the police or animal control) to conduct an (hopefully) objective investigation to verify what you “knew” to be true.

Would you use (additional) force against him to take the cat? Would you break in to his house to take his cat?

If I knew that my neighbour was torturing his cat then I would have no problem taking the cat from him, and I certainly wouldnt class this as being theft.

How about if the neighbor was feeding the cat cheap catfood? If not, why not. Or, if he didn’t pet the cat enough. If not, why not?

When we were about ten me and one of my buddies would take these kittens and toss them as high in the air as we could to see if cats really landed on their feet all the time (his idea). We were having fun with the annoying little furballs until my Mom came out and saw what we were doing. Let’s just say that ruined our fun for quite awhile.

Dude, that’s your mom, you’re out of luck.

Would you use (additional) force against him to take the cat? Would you break in to his house to take his cat?

pffft, why not go one further… line him up against the wall, put a gun to the back of his head, and blow his brains out. If you’re going to violate rights, then at least be honest about it.

Honestly.

I hope this goes to illustrate that if animal “rights” are instituted, then human rights are necessarily violated.

pffft, why not go one further… line him up against the wall, put a gun to the back of his head, and blow his brains out. If you’re going to violate rights, then at least be honest about it.

Honestly.

I hope this goes to illustrate that if animal “rights” are instituted, then human rights are necessarily violated.

I agree with this senario, ultimately bestowing rights upon a non-rational entity can only result in an absurd/attrocious conclusion. However, I would argue that one would treat animals in a humane manner, as one would value a piece of inanimate property and not destroy it on a mere whim, so too would be the case with a pet. But in order to accomplish this, a person would have to be rational and also free to choose a values system, which would be the only way in which morality could actually exist.

Animal rights is not rational, period.

However, I would argue that one would treat animals in a humane manner, as one would value a piece of inanimate property and not destroy it on a mere whim, so too would be the case with a pet.

Just to be sure I understand what you are saying, are you saying that one should not act on whim (which is a very general statement), and also that there is no significant difference between animals, plants, and non-living matter in terms of how humans should behave?

Just to be sure I understand what you are saying, are you saying that one should not act on whim (which is a very general statement), and also that there is no significant difference between animals, plants, and non-living matter in terms of how humans should behave?

I meant it more as an analogy serving the concept of always being rational (thus not acting on whim) no matter what form of property one chooses to own. There is obviously a metaphysical difference between animals, plants, and inanimate objects that requires perspective in each given case. However, each one of these 3 entities are equally unable to form concepts, so none of them reserve any rights that would supercede the rights of man. The fact that animals particularly can not discuss such things as rights with their human masters, in of itself, draws the entire notion of “animal rights” into the realm of irrationality, for nothing that is unable to understand such things as rights can be given them since they are unable to affirm or deny them.

How about if the neighbor was feeding the cat cheap catfood? If not, why not. Or, if he didn’t pet the cat enough. If not, why not?

I wouldnt consider either of these things to be abuse. Similar to how I dont think a child should be taken away from its parents if they give it poor quality baby food or fail to fufill their weekly cuddle quota. But if they start hitting it with a frying pan, thats a different story.

On a sidenote, if animals are to be treated like any other piece of property, then we need to be consistent. For example, if I tell my neighbour that I dont want his dog to be in my garden, then I am surely entitled to keep/shoot/whatever the dog if it comes into my garden (compare to my neighbour throwing garbage onto my lawn). Similarly if I see my neighbours cat out in the street, it shouldnt be classed as theft for me to pick it up and keep it, just like it isnt theft to keep the money in a lost wallet which you find lying around (at least I dont think it is).

A human baby is not property in the sense that a cat is; infant humans, although they don’t have their full quota of adult rights yet (they don’t have the right to liberty, for instance, because they can’t exercise it) still have some rights.

Operating on principle means that you have to accept people that will take that principle all the way to its logical extreme. If you want free speech, that means you have to defend purveyors of pornography and crucifixes in a jar of pee. Rights are an all-or-nothing thing.

although they don’t have their full quota of adult rights yet they still have some rights.

…

Rights are an all-or-nothing thing.

hmmmm

On a sidenote, if animals are to be treated like any other piece of property, then we need to be consistent. For example, if I tell my neighbour that I dont want his dog to be in my garden, then I am surely entitled to keep/shoot/whatever the dog if it comes into my garden (compare to my neighbour throwing garbage onto my lawn). Similarly if I see my neighbours cat out in the street, it shouldnt be classed as theft for me to pick it up and keep it, just like it isnt theft to keep the money in a lost wallet which you find lying around (at least I dont think it is).

It’s not? It’s certainly theft to use someone’s credit cards if they lose them. I think the only reason it’s not “considered” theft to take cash that you find is because it doesn’t have any identifying marks that can be easily traced back to an owner. Now, if it’s in a wallet with someone’s driver’s license, that’s another story.

And that’s just answering whether you can be legally prosecuted for a crime: taking property that doesn’t belong to you is still theft whether it’s a dime or a thousand dollars. If someone crashes their car into your house, you can sue them for damages but you do not become owner of the vehicle.

hmmmm

Are you trying to pretend that those statements are contradictory? They aren’t . . . having a different number of rights does not mean that the exercise of those rights are somehow limited. I didn’t say that “either you have all rights or you have no rights”, I said “either you can exercise a right completely or you cannot.”

Humans with substantially differing capacities may never acquire the full complement of adult rights; someone so severely retarded that they cannot know good from evil is not entitled to liberty no matter their age, but what rights they do have they can still exercise to the fullest.

I wouldnt consider either of these things to be abuse.

Nor do I, so the question is what is “abuse”? I’m denying that the frozen dog situation is (necessarily) abuse. I could imagine accidentally hitting a dog or baby with a frying pan. You didn’t answer the question (which, admittedly, wasn’t posed to you, but ya know what happens when you blink in public). What defines “abuse”?