Something I’ve been concerned more about recently is the treatment of animals and how it relates to our ethical intuitions.
As Objectivists or those sympathetic with much of the philosophy, I think we can all agree that to some extent the suffering of animals is undesirable. It is normally stated that we should not support the needless suffering of animals. I think this is a position you must take as not only a rational person, but a person with in tact human faculties of empathy. To lack any sort of feeling of disgust when presented with the suffering of animals is considered a tell-tale sign of antisocial behavior. However, I think our ethical intuitions regarding the suffering of animals goes further than this. Beyond simple feelings of sympathy, empathy and disgust at the suffering of conscious beings, I think we need to admit that it is not just the needless suffering of animals that is to be appalled, but even the suffering of animals when we might need it.
So, my question is, when is the suffering of animals justified? Let me suggest two propositions that should be at the ends of this continuum:
-
The Suffering of Lab Rats in Human Medical Research
-
The Suffering of Calves In Processing Veal.
At one end, we have what most people consider a justifiable practice that involves the suffering of animals for human benefit and at the other end we have an unjustifiable, or at least much less justifiable case.
One exists for the long-term benefit of humans, who I think we can all agree on this forum have a privileged state of consciousness that ought to go into our ethical calculations. If a lab rat or even a Great Ape most suffer so that many human beings can prosper, this is justified.
The other exists as a short term benefit of our taste buds. As a person that has eaten veal on several occasions, I have to admit that I absolutely loved the taste. It made for a great (even if costly) meal. However, it is much more difficult for me to justify eating veal than it is for me to endorse the use of medicine that was tested on animals. But calves suffer greatly and with a wide array of experience during this process. It isn’t that cows have a low-level experience for pain. They can experience pain in very much the same way we do. They even show signs of empathy with their calf brothers.
The torture calves endure is not like that of a slug who we salt on our basement floors. Both have some short term benefit, but one seems less severe. If we have the choice to salt a slug or torture a calf for years or even for a moment, I think we’d do well with salting the slug. Their pain sensations, if they even exist, are unlikely to be much more than an on/off switch.
So, if you agree that there is a difference between the production and consumption of animal tested medicine and the consumption of veal, wherein lies the difference? ANd how vast a continuum is it? Are there merely two nodes or is the difference between these two practices very large?
Should we as empathetic creatures stop supporting the veal industry, even protest it? What about farms that treat their cattle and other animals unnecessarily cruelly? Say what you will of PETA (And I’d say a bunch), they have compiled a lot of footage that displays unnecessarily cruel behavior on cows, pigs, chickens and all other form of livestock, who all show a high sensitivity for pain and emotional anguish. I’d say it is unethical to support the torture of animals when it can be reasonably avoided. Why should we allow farms that needlessly harm animals to continue, within a free market? Why give them our support if we agree that it’s more than just psychotic, but unethical to treat animals in this way?
I find it concerning that many Objectivists will simply brush under the rug the concern we ought to have for the suffering of conscious creatures. Is it that Objectivism, libertarianism and various individualistic philosophies attract those with low levels of empathy? I’ve seen Objectivists that do have a great deal of concern for the suffering of animals, but more often I see it shrugged off as not important. And perhaps in terms of ethical concerns it can rate low, but I think it deserves more than a passing thought and an “Oh well, that’s the state of the world” attitude.
I don’t suggest one radically change their diet to cut out meat. I think there are ethical ways to eat meat and I think it’s a necessary part of a good diet for most people. If it were the case that it were either veganism or the torturing of animals, I would suggest the torturing of animals. However, that isn’t our only choice and I think we should stop acting as if it were.