Question About Animal Cruelty

Having such respect [for animal life]does not mean that a person should refrain from killing animals when there is a purpose for doing so - i.e. food, clothing, removal of pests and, yes, even sport.

Having a purpose justifies killing an animal. Why is killing for pleasure not a valid purpose, but killing for sport is?

Those who would take pleasure from the suffering of an innocent creature - well, the very psychology that would make such pleasure possible is profoundly twisted. It is to hold with disregard the value of life itself.

It seems quite possible to me to value one’s own or other human’s lives without valuing the life of nonhumans.

Voting against it might perhaps be such a sanction. But abstaining from such a process most certainly is not. There are many reasons why a person might abstain.

But voting against it would definitely be a sanction, wouldn’t it?

And as for abstaining, if abusing/torturing/severly mistreating animals is a right of man that it is improper for the state to violate, what is the difference between the man who abstains from protecting the right to torture animals, and the man who abstains from protecting the right to abortion or IP? Even granting that there can be things more important, is a person morally justified in picking and choosing which rights he believes are important enough to protect?

If animals have no rights, theres no obvious reason why theres a problem with torturing them if it brings you pleasure.

If you want this to be objective, then youre going to need something a lot more substantial than vague notions of being ‘psychologically twisted’ or whatever.

Agreed.

Again, why not just put a gun to his head and pull the trigger?

Well, I would hesitate to equate preventing a man from torturing an animal to preventing him from living. And I wouldn’t prevent someone from destroying nonliving property.

Because doing so is a profound injustice - and, more importantly, because deriving pleasure from suffering is psychologically SICK.

Well… if you say so.

(“not giving money to the poor is a profound injustice, and people who dont feel sad when they see homeless people are psychologically SICK”/“homosexuality is psychologically SICK”/etc. What any particular person personally happens to find sick is philosophically uninteresting, since I’m only interested in what can be consistently defended.)

Children don’t know any better and do not fully realize the degree to which animals or even other people can suffer.

Its more likely that they dont care until they are taught to do so. Children who grew up in (eg) ancient rome, mongol civilisations, etc probably realised the degree to which slaves/enemies suffered when beaten, yet they dont seem to have considered this very interesting. Children (and adults) will generally pick up the values/morality of their surrounding society, and people will base their ideas of what is ‘sick’ on what they have been taught since childhood. But the question isnt what a particular group of people happen to think is acceptable/‘sick’ - its what things are capable of objective defence. And if animals objectively dont have rights, there doesnt seem to be any reason why torturing them is immoral (although since our culture frowns upon it, most of us will find it distasteful, myself included. But then I also find the thought of eating sheeps eyeball/octopus distasteful, and I dont think there anything objective involved in this judgement - its just how I’ve been brought up).

No - there is more to it than mere social convention.

Then, assuming animals have no rights, what else is there? Theres no obvious connection between torturing animals and being ‘psychologically damanged’, because in the past we have had entire societies where torturing humans was perfectly alright, and it seems strange to say that everyone who lived in them was ‘damaged’ somehow. However, we are able to say that these human-torturers were wrong, because we have an objective theory of human rights. But without an objective theory of animal rights, where can we stand to condemn animal-torturers? The disgust you feel animal torturers kicking cats is probably similar to the way that PETA activists feel when they see you eating a hamburger, but I dont see why your position can be called more objectively correct than theirs if animals are simply property.

I think the attempt to reconcile “animals have no rights” with “it is wrong to torture animals” is an attempt to both have your cake and eat it. Once you agree with the first statement, you have nothing left with which to consistently defend the second.

I’d also question the idea that a coherent distinction can be drawn between ‘torturing for pleasure’ and ‘torturing for a purpose’. Cosmetic testing is a good example here - animals are routinely tortured for the purposes of testing products (blinding is fairly common), yet the results are things like lipstick and shampoo which do not help to keep humans alive - these products simply exist for the sake of our vanity/pleasure. So it seems that its acceptable to torture animals for (non-essential-to-life) pleasure, as long as the pleasure isnt the actual tortuting itself?

To put it in a slightly more exaggerated way, does it really make that much of a difference that the person pulling the legs off his cat is doing so because he thinks that warm cat-blood looks nice on his face, rather than because he enjoys watching the cat suffer?

Well, I would hesitate to equate preventing a man from torturing an animal to preventing him from living. And I wouldn’t prevent someone from destroying nonliving property.

Too bad, because they are one in the same, if the animal is his property. Principles aren’t things you get to give up when things get ugly… that’s when you need them the most. If you’re willing to deprive a man of his right to property, you are depriving him of his means of living.

I suggest you retract your statement.

To put it in a slightly more exaggerated way, does it really make that much of a difference that the person pulling the legs off his cat is doing so because he thinks that warm cat-blood looks nice on his face, rather than because he enjoys watching the cat suffer?

Yes, although either way there is something wrong with him.

Someone who enjoys watching pain qua pain is somebody with a psychological problem. (i.e. “sicko”) It doesn’t matter that the particular thing in pain doesn’t have rights: the problem isn’t that an animal is being tortured… it’s that someone is enjoying being a torturer.

Yes, although either way there is something wrong with him.

Someone who enjoys watching pain qua pain is somebody with a psychological problem. (i.e. “sicko”) It doesn’t matter that the particular thing in pain doesn’t have rights: the problem isn’t that an animal is being tortured… it’s that someone is enjoying being a torturer.

I dont know what a ‘psychological problem’ is, other than that it seems to apply to people who do things that the user of the the term disapproves of. Do we have some sort of objective criteria for determining which sort of behavior constitutes having a problem? Is there a proven link between torturing animals and (proper) mental illnesses such as schizophrenia? Why is torturing animals that dont have rights any worse than deriving pleasure from killing enemies in violent computer games such as Grand Theft Auto (apparently people who play these games are sickos too according to certain tabloid newspapers…)?

I dont know what a ‘psychological problem’ is, other than that it seems to apply to people who do things that the user of the the term disapproves of. Do we have some sort of objective criteria for determining which sort of behavior constitutes having a problem? Is there a proven link between torturing animals and (proper) mental illnesses such as schizophrenia? Why is torturing animals that dont have rights any worse than killing enemies in a computer game?

Torture is a specific act: that of inflicting pain through the use of physical violence. The psychological problem is that a person should be averse to pain qua pain; that there is no way it would, qua pain, bring them pleasure. (This is not to say that a person can’t derive pleasure from justice, if that happens to involve someone being in pain; i.e. you’re not a sicko if you smile upon hearing that Osama Bin Laden just got shot in the b*lls)

As for your question of the computer game, that depends: just what sort of killing is this? (the topic isn’t: is killing animals a sign of psychological problems… it is: is deriving pleasure from torturing animals a sign of psychological problems.) If the game had a sufficiently graphic representation of torture and the person were enjoying it qua torture, then yes I would say that was an indicator of problems. To actually torture animals is only worse than that because it shows the resolve of the individual to not be deterred by the inconvenience of the mess, possibility of contracting some disease, etc. (i.e. he REALLY likes torturing)

Torture is a specific act: that of inflicting pain through the use of physical violence. The psychological problem is that a person should be averse to pain qua pain; that there is no way it would, qua pain, bring them pleasure.

Again, I would argue that the fact kids very often seem to derive pleasure from the pain of animal suffering calls this into question - pulling the legs off spiders and killing ants with a magnifying glass are fairly common things to do in childhood. Left to develop on their own, I dont think the average child would ever reach the conclusion that there’s anything wrong with hurting animals - it seems to be more a consequence of his socialisation into a society which condemns that sort of thing. As such, I dont think theres any real basis for equating enjoyment of torture with psychological problems - it does seem to be fairly natural.

As for your question of the computer game, that depends: just what sort of killing is this? (the topic isn’t: is killing animals a sign of psychological problems… it is: is deriving pleasure from torturing animals a sign of psychological problems.) If the game had a sufficiently graphic representation of torture and the person were enjoying it qua torture, then yes I would say that was an indicator of problems. To actually torture animals is only worse than that because it shows the resolve of the individual to not be deterred by the inconvenience of the mess, possibility of contracting some disease, etc. (i.e. he REALLY likes torturing)

Thats fair enough, at least youre consistent. If you really dont think theres much difference between enjoying incredibly graphic (fake) violence in videogames/films, and torturing (real) animals then I can accept that, although I disagree.

Again, I would argue that the fact kids very often seem to derive pleasure from the pain of animal suffering calls this into question - pulling the legs off spiders and killing ants with a magnifying glass are fairly common things to do in childhood.

My answer is the same as others here: a child does not necessarily know what he/she is doing. Furthermore, you do not know for a fact that they are enjoying torture qua torture. Perhaps they are just exploring how the things in their environment work by taking them apart. Maybe they just think bugs are icky things that should die. (I know I do…) You can’t just switch the context from an adult with full knowledge who is enjoying torture qua torture to a child who may not know what they are doing and may be doing it for any number of reasons.

Thats fair enough, at least youre consistent. If you really dont think theres much difference between enjoying incredibly graphic (fake) violence in videogames/films, and torturing (real) animals then I can accept that, although I disagree.

Indeed I do not think there’s much difference. As I said, it is only then a question of how far the sicko is willing to go to indulge in his pleasure that he derives from inflicting pain.

This evaluation of “sicko” is one based on a rational assessment of their consciousness and evaluated on the basis of: “how much of a threat does this person pose to me, those I love, and my property?”

My answer is the same as others here: a child does not necessarily know what he/she is doing.

What knowledge is the child lacking? (dont say “that its wrong to torture animals”; this just begs the question). Its not as simple as saying he doesnt know that the animals suffer, because there are plenty of cultures where people are taught that inflicting suffering is ok. Theres no obvious reason why the child should care about the suffering of animals unless he is made to, perhaps by being shouted at whenever he kicks the family cat.

Furthermore, you do not know for a fact that they are enjoying torture qua torture. Perhaps they are just exploring how the things in their environment work by taking them apart.

You could say the same about adult torturers.

This evaluation of “sicko” is one based on a rational assessment of their consciousness and evaluated on the basis of: “how much of a threat does this person pose to me, those I love, and my property?”

Is there any real evidence linking animal cruelty to human cruelty? Animals apparently dont have rights, whereas humans do, so the two things seem as different as chalk and cheese.

I think the attempt to reconcile “animals have no rights” with “it is wrong to torture animals” is an attempt to both have your cake and eat it. Once you agree with the first statement, you have nothing left with which to consistently defend the second.

So, would you agree then that attempting to reconcile “You have the right to take hard drugs” and “It is immoral to take hard drugs” is also trying to have your cake and eat it?

What knowledge is the child lacking? (dont say “that its wrong to torture animals”; this just begs the question). Its not as simple as saying he doesnt know that the animals suffer, because there are plenty of cultures where people are taught that inflicting suffering is ok.

Yes, it is as simple as saying he doesn’t know that the animals suffer. If he knows that they suffer and he’s doing it for no other reason than to inflict suffering, then he’s a sick little bastard. And cultures that teach that inflicting suffering for its own sake is okay are sick, sick cultures.

Theres no obvious reason why the child should care about the suffering of animals unless he is made to, perhaps by being shouted at whenever he kicks the family cat.

It’s not that he should care about the suffering of animals. It’s that he should not derive pleasure from the inflicting of suffering qua inflicting of suffering. If he were totally indifferent to animal suffering and felt no pleasure at all from it, then there wouldn’t be this problem. Again, this isn’t about animals suffering; it’s about a person enjoying the inflicting of pain.

You could say the same about adult torturers.

Except that they are adults and are expected to know better. If I saw an adult eating grass or wandering into the street, I would treat him as more likely to be insane (i.e. threatening) than a child who did the same.

Is there any real evidence linking animal cruelty to human cruelty?

Yes, if not causally, then at least correlatively.

Animals apparently dont have rights, whereas humans do, so the two things seem as different as chalk and cheese.

Yes they are. But again, it’s not about the animals.

However, my guess is that when you read of some innocent stranger who is brutally murdered and when you hear of terrorist attacks on completely innocent strangers you are profoundly outraged.

This is still contextual for me. In some cases I may be affected, and in some cases not. I have seen many brutal murders up close and personal and articles about “innocent” people are frequently inaccurate. I have to admit to some degree of skepticism about what I read in the papers or see on the news. While no one deserves to be murdered, some people live lives that habitually place themselves in situations that are conducive to being murdered (and even that is contextual to any sympathy I may have). However, as I said, generally the feeling I would get would be “man, what if that were me?” In the cases of children suffering horrible deaths, instead I would probably think “what if that were my son?”

In the police “sub-culture”, the death of a law enforcement officer causes an immediate and profound emotional reaction among the majority of police officers I know. Frequently, this is devoid of any concern or knowledge of the context of the LEO’s death. I on the other hand want to know more about why and how the LEO died before I determine how I feel about it. Now, if it is an LEO I know and value, it would be more likely that I would have a significant emotional reaction right away and then take a deep breath and ask how and why.

Because you recognize the profound value of human life

Okay, perhaps I should approach this a different way. What do you mean by “the profound value of human life”? How do you differentiate this “profound value” from intrinsic value?

I value human life “in general” to some degree for specific reasons. I do not see this to be the same thing as life having some “profound value” in and of itself. However, I would distinquish having no general value for life from deriving value from the destruction of life (solely for the sake of destruction or pleasure from misery). Having no general value for human life does not mean that one would engage in actions to bring about the destruction of life just for the sake of torture or destruction. It takes a “special” person to actually enjoy the purposeless or needless pain, misery or torture of another life. I agree that that is indicative of some serious psychological issue, generally relating to control, and that control aspect is generally NOT limited to animal life. I would not trust individuals like that around my life, nor the life of anyone in my family.

Anybody else who doesn’t see anything wrong with deriving pleasure solely from torturing and/or destroying life is certainly free to invite such people over to their houses for dinner, play their “reindeer games” with them (in so much as they wish to risk the penalty of the laws that do exist) or what have you, let them babysit their children, etc. I’m sure they have nothing to worry about.

I think the attempt to reconcile “animals have no rights” with “it is wrong to torture animals” is an attempt to both have your cake and eat it. Once you agree with the first statement, you have nothing left with which to consistently defend the second.

This is fallacious. There is nothing that requires immorality to be inextricably linked to rights violations. There are any manner of immoral acts that have nothing to do with rights.

I agree that that is indicative of some serious psychological issue, generally relating to control, and that control aspect is generally NOT limited to animal life. I would not trust individuals like that around my life, nor the life of anyone in my family.

Anybody else who doesn’t see anything wrong with deriving pleasure solely from torturing and/or destroying life is certainly free to invite such people over to their houses for dinner, play their “reindeer games” with them (in so much as they wish to risk the penalty of the laws that do exist) or what have you, let them babysit their children, etc. I’m sure they have nothing to worry about.

Well said. That matches, almost word for word, what I had planned out to reply to Hal if he once again asked for “proof” on that question.

Too bad, because they are one in the same, if the animal is his property. Principles aren’t things you get to give up when things get ugly… that’s when you need them the most. If you’re willing to deprive a man of his right to property, you are depriving him of his means of living.

If protecting a man’s right to property requires protecting every use of property…

why doesn’t a right to property being moral require every use of property be moral?

Don’t you need “principle” for both?

So, would you agree then that attempting to reconcile “You have the right to take hard drugs” and “It is immoral to take hard drugs” is also trying to have your cake and eat it?

:slight_smile: Good point. Considering an act legal doesn’t automatically eliminate any basis for considering it immoral.

So, would you agree then that attempting to reconcile “You have the right to take hard drugs” and “It is immoral to take hard drugs” is also trying to have your cake and eat it?

No, because the immorality of hard drug use (in particular contexts) is founded on the argument that it is bad for the life of the user in the long term. As I’ve said though, I dont think theres any such demonstrable link when it comes to animal torturing.

If protecting a man’s right to property requires protecting every use of property…

why doesn’t a right to property being moral require every use of property be moral?

Don’t you need “principle” for both?

Are you actually asking this? I ask because I find it hard to believe that you would ask such a question. Are you truly that ignorant of the basis and application of rights? If so, let me know and I will treat that question seriously.

Hmm. Sharp words, those are.

But I do not see my error, so please treat it seriously.

Hmm. Sharp words, those are.

But I do not see my error, so please treat it seriously.

Very well, I shall treat the question seriously.

Rights are conditions required for man to survive in a society. Man’s nature requires that he be free from the initiation of force.

Men do not require other men in their society to be entirely rational or entirely moral. It certainly helps, but it is not a requirement that, if not met, deprives man of his means of survival. But man DOES require that force is not initiated.

Since any attempt to force other men to use their property only morally would be destroying a requirement of life for the sake of a minor perk, then NO a right to property does not require every use of property to be moral.

Are you totally ignorant of Objectivist politics?

The idea that people should be forced to be moral is that of statism; i.e. Communism, Fascism, etc.

Since it was asked for…

http://www.pet-abuse.com/pages/abuse_connection.php

http://vivisection-absurd.org.uk/abs02.html

Animal Abuse and juveniles

http://www.rcpets.org/partnersincrime.htm

http://www.critcrim.org/redfeather/journal…m/001Myers.html

http://aacantiques.com/animalabuse.htm

I realize that some of these are somewhat biased in their other goals, but the information remains the same.