Having such respect [for animal life]does not mean that a person should refrain from killing animals when there is a purpose for doing so - i.e. food, clothing, removal of pests and, yes, even sport.
Having a purpose justifies killing an animal. Why is killing for pleasure not a valid purpose, but killing for sport is?
Those who would take pleasure from the suffering of an innocent creature - well, the very psychology that would make such pleasure possible is profoundly twisted. It is to hold with disregard the value of life itself.
It seems quite possible to me to value one’s own or other human’s lives without valuing the life of nonhumans.
Voting against it might perhaps be such a sanction. But abstaining from such a process most certainly is not. There are many reasons why a person might abstain.
But voting against it would definitely be a sanction, wouldn’t it?
And as for abstaining, if abusing/torturing/severly mistreating animals is a right of man that it is improper for the state to violate, what is the difference between the man who abstains from protecting the right to torture animals, and the man who abstains from protecting the right to abortion or IP? Even granting that there can be things more important, is a person morally justified in picking and choosing which rights he believes are important enough to protect?
If animals have no rights, theres no obvious reason why theres a problem with torturing them if it brings you pleasure.
If you want this to be objective, then youre going to need something a lot more substantial than vague notions of being ‘psychologically twisted’ or whatever.
Agreed.
Again, why not just put a gun to his head and pull the trigger?
Well, I would hesitate to equate preventing a man from torturing an animal to preventing him from living. And I wouldn’t prevent someone from destroying nonliving property.