Question About Animal Cruelty

Nor do I, so the question is what is “abuse”? I’m denying that the frozen dog situation is (necessarily) abuse. I could imagine accidentally hitting a dog or baby with a frying pan. You didn’t answer the question (which, admittedly, wasn’t posed to you, but ya know what happens when you blink in public). What defines “abuse”?

I’m not prepared to define a rigid boundary between abuse and non-abuse, but I could you give you some examples of the sort of things which would definitely lie on either side of the line, wherever its drawn.

It’s not? It’s certainly theft to use someone’s credit cards if they lose them.

Yeah, I said ‘money’ though. I think you could be right about the identifying marks thing, it makes intuitive sense.

Are you trying to pretend that those statements are contradictory? They aren’t . . . having a different number of rights does not mean that the exercise of those rights are somehow limited. I didn’t say that “either you have all rights or you have no rights”, I said “either you can exercise a right completely or you cannot.”

Ok, I misunderstood you. But given youre prepared to grant rights to beings which arent rational (and perhaps not even self-conscious), I’m not sure why youre so opposed to granting them to animals too. Animals obviously shouldnt be entitled to the same set of rights as adult humans, but that doesnt automatically mean they shouldnt be granted any rights at all (in a similar way to babies and the severely brain damaged).

For example, if I tell my neighbour that I dont want his dog to be in my garden, then I am surely entitled to keep/shoot/whatever the dog if it comes into my garden (compare to my neighbour throwing garbage onto my lawn).

No, you have don’t have a right to retaliate with force yourself unless it’s an emergency situation. If he continues to let his dog come onto your property, you have the right to legal recourse (whatever it may happen to be based on the situation). Same thing with trash if he litters on your property.

Aside from that, “throwing garbage away” vs. “letting a dog wander” are not treated the same because they are contextually different situations separate from the consistency of the use of the term “property”. “Garbage” implies that the owner does not want the property anymore and that you could keep it or shoot it if you wanted (though shooting it might violate some local ordinance depending on where you live - discharging a firearm in city limits) without using force against him. I’m not sure why you would want to keep or shoot trash, but whatever. In letting the dog wander, the owner is not implying “I wish to relinguish ownership of this dog.” He’s being irresponsible perhaps, and perhaps violating other’s property rights, which opens the door to your legal recourse. But taking or shooting the dog would represent a use of retaliatory force against the other person’s property rights. Unless the dog were attacking you, I would say the proper recourse is through a magistrate or the police.

Edit: On second consideration, it may well be proper to defend your property if the dog is actively causing damage to it, depending on the specific situation.

Ok, I misunderstood you. But given youre prepared to grant rights to beings which arent rational (and perhaps not even self-conscious), I’m not sure why youre so opposed to granting them to animals too. Animals obviously shouldnt be entitled to the same set of rights as adult humans, but that doesnt automatically mean they shouldnt be granted any rights at all (in a similar way to babies and the severely brain damaged).

I think recognizing that babies and retarded adults are “broken units” and granting them some rights is different from stretching the rights to include animals. The rights of babies are derived from starting at the perfect adult state and working backwards to include when humans may not possess that state. Whereas you can’t start with an adult, rational, competent cat and work backwards to include the non-rational, subadult cat, because there is no rational cat.

Meh. That wasn’t entirely clear; I’m hoping you can grasp the idea, because I’m not entirely certain how to explain it. More thinking is in order.

If wolf kills a sheep - is the wolf guilty of violating the sheep’s rights? If not, then on what basis would I be violating a sheep’s rights by killing it?

Torturing or deliberate cruelty towards another living creature is profoundly immoral - and it is no coincidence that engaging in such behavior is very frequently an early warning sign that a person will also engage in similar behavior on human beings.

Obviously, there are occasions when human beings kill and cause pain to animals in order to obtain values such as food, clothing, testing new medicines and to remove animals which, in certain contexts, jeopardize one’s values, such as gophers, rats, wolves, tigers, etc. But people who engage in that sort of behavior for a living tend to be very respectful for the life that they are taking and do what they reasonably can to minimize its suffering - which is the morally proper thing to do.

In a free society, the proper response towards profoundly immoral but non-rights violating behavior is ostracization. If it can be proved that someone tortures animals, than rather than calling the police and putting the person in jail for a few months, the thing to do would be for local newspapers and television stations to run stories on such a person. Civilized people would want nothing to do with such a scum bag and would probably avoid contact with him at all costs.

Another example of profoundly immoral but non-rights violating behavior which is sometimes illegal is racism. If a business owner refuses to employ people or serve customers because they are of a certain racial background - well, strictly speaking, they have every right in the world to do so. But I would want nothing to do with such a person - and, in fact, have refused to have dealings with people I have discovered were racists. And if I run across people who are not aware someone I know is a racist, I usually warn them.

I am told that one of the worst forms of hell in American society is to have your name on the registered sex offenders database. Imagine trying to get a job and have much of a social life with something like THAT being public knowledge. A similar sort of hell is exactly what racists and those who torture animals deserve and what they would get in a free society. In a free society, one’s reputation becomes much more important because people are free to take it into consideration and act accordingly. Today, if you work for a large company, you are presumed to have certain alleged “rights” as an employee and, if you rent or try to buy a house, you have certain alleged “rights” that the property owner must obey. It is pretty hard for a company or a prospective landlord to openly refuse to deal with you on the stated and explicty grounds that you are considered to be a scum bag.

If wolf kills a sheep - is the wolf guilty of violating the sheep’s rights?

It would seem so: the wolf will likely receive the death penalty for its crimes, at the hand of the rancher-judge.

Seriously, though, it is unfortunate that some budding Objectivists don’t grasp the distinction between “what is right” (moral) and “rights”. I absolutely support the use of ostracism (osterizing?) as a means of dealing with certain kinds of morally disgusting persons. In fact, I am somewhat surprised to have hardly ever seen an Objectivist advocate it as a response to sickos.

In a free society, the proper response towards profoundly immoral but non-rights violating behavior is ostracization. If it can be proved that someone tortures animals, than rather than calling the police and putting the person in jail for a few months, the thing to do would be for local newspapers and television stations to run stories on such a person. Civilized people would want nothing to do with such a scum bag and would probably avoid contact with him at all costs.

That’s an interesting point and a good one as well. I wonder, is it your conclusion that the current set of laws on the books which prohibit animal cruelty are improper and should be repealed? Do animal cruelty laws violate the rights of man?

That’s an interesting point and a good one as well. I wonder, is it your conclusion that the current set of laws on the books which prohibit animal cruelty are improper and should be repealed?

I guess my answer depends on the context in which the question is asked.

I would NOT go out in public and/or put up a posting on the Internet proactively campaigning for the repeal of such laws - and I would seriously question the motives of anyone behind such a campaign in 2006. My reason for that is because there are so many examples of morally innocent and decent people who whose rights are violated and who suffer as a result of irrational, unjust and inappropriate laws - for example, anti-trust laws, eminant domain laws, tax laws, securities laws, wetlands protection laws and regulations far too numerous to count.

While I recognize that there are times when the defense of freedom requires one to stand up for the rights of those one despises to commit behavior which one considers evil (for example, defending Jacques Kerry’s and Algore’s free speech rights), one does so in the name of the good and decent people whose rights and freedom are also at risk as a result. Laws which prohibit people from torturing or being needlessly cruel to animals do not apply to good and decent people - the only kind of people who would engage in such acts in the first place are scum bags.

Yes - scum bags have rights too. But the issue here is this: what does it say about a person who chooses to spend his limited time, energy and resources campaigning on behalf of the repeal of laws inappropriately directed at scum bags instead of spending it on behalf of victims who are good and decent? Why defend a pathetic and sick-o cruel sadist who tortures kitty cats when innocent, productive people such as Martha Stewart are being locked up behind bars?

What most people will conclude when they see such a campaign is that the purpose behind it is probably a bunch of nihilists wanting to stand besides the wicked for the sake of standing besides the wicked - and any and all talk about individual rights would be viewed as merely a rationalization.

If one wishes to advocate individual rights, one must be very selective about ones battles both in terms of what issues one has a chance of making an impact with and in terms of how it will reflect on the cause of individual rights in general.

So, in that sense, I would not go around making a point to advocate that such laws be repealed. Reasonable people would properly classify me as being just some other libertarian-esque kook.

On the other hand, if you ask me whether such laws are a proper response to grotesquely immoral but non-rights violating behavior - my answer would be no.

Do animal cruelty laws violate the rights of man?

Laws which prohibit one from engaging in non-rights violating behavior constitute a violation of rights. A law which prohibits me from drinking Drain-O is a violation of my rights despite the fact that no person who is in his right mind and wishes to remain alive would wish to do so.

It would seem so: the wolf will likely receive the death penalty for its crimes, at the hand of the rancher-judge.

Except, of course, that the death penalty would not be because the wolf violated the sheep’s rights but rather because it destroyed the rancher’s property.

This reminds me of one more illustration of the silliness that animals somehow have rights. People definitely have rights - and that includes ranchers and farmers. But when the wolf ate the rancher’s sheep or when a rabbit eats a farmer’s carrot crop, are the farmer and rancher’s rights violated? Were Roy Horn’s rights violated when he was attacked by one of his tigers? Of course not. Only people can violate rights and only people can have rights.

I once knew a lady who was a vegetarian and a member of PETA and asked her if why she saw nothing wrong with animals killing other animals but was offended when people kill those same animals. Her response was a smug: “Well, since we are human beings, we ought to know better.” Translation: Since, unlike the animals, we have the capacity to choose to subordinate ourselves below every other living creature, we have a moral obligation to do so. And the notion that such a capacity makes us superior to other creatures - well, that is the root of all evil in her blighted and pathetic worldview.

Seriously, though, it is unfortunate that some budding Objectivists don’t grasp the distinction between “what is right” (moral) and “rights”. I absolutely support the use of ostracism (osterizing?) as a means of dealing with certain kinds of morally disgusting persons. In fact, I am somewhat surprised to have hardly ever seen an Objectivist advocate it as a response to sickos.

Most Objectivists I know actually do, on a personal level, ostracize people they do not like or find repulsive. But, in today’s culture, it is very hard to do that on a widespread organized basis across an entire society. In today’s culture,unfortunately, the mere fact that one regards certain people as scum bags will result in a sizable percentage of the population not taking you very seriously.

Thanks Dismuke. I have similar thoughts on animal cruelty laws. David’s suggestion was appropriate. There should be mandatory Osterizing for abusers.

David’s suggestion was appropriate. There should be mandatory Osterizing for abusers.

:warn: That’s good. I like it.

Only problem is it might get some flack from the Kerry/Kennedy/Algore crowd. I am sure they would consider something like that to be intolerant and inflammatory. No doubt they would insist that we be just as respectful to scum bags as they are to terrorists! :yarr:

Yes - scum bags have rights too. But the issue here is this: what does it say about a person who chooses to spend his limited time, energy and resources campaigning on behalf of the repeal of laws inappropriately directed at scum bags instead of spending it on behalf of victims who are good and decent? Why defend a pathetic and sick-o cruel sadist who tortures kitty cats when innocent, productive people such as Martha Stewart are being locked up behind bars?

Note that this same observation applies to the Libertarians and their insistence upon shoving to the forefront of politics the rights of drug users to obliterate their minds.

Note that this same observation applies to the Libertarians and their insistence upon shoving to the forefront of politics the rights of drug users to obliterate their minds.

Indeed. And the freedom to walk around in public naked and to fornicate on one’s front porch also seems to be a hot button issue for certain members of the Libertarian crowd. Sure shows where their priorities are. As someone aptly said…hippies of the right.

Count me as one of the unfortunates who haven’t grasped this whole subject.

If it is not immoral to kick a pebble, then why would it be immoral to torture an animal?

Indeed. I have seen surprisingly few arguments as to why torturing animals is immoral. If a person tortures an animal for the sake of his pleasure, what is the argument that he is being immoral?

If I knew that my neighbour was torturing his cat then I would have no problem taking the cat from him, and I certainly wouldnt class this as being theft. I’m not sure how to interpret this in terms of animal rights, but meh.

*Agrees*

I would NOT go out in public and/or put up a posting on the Internet proactively campaigning for the repeal of [anti-torture] laws - and I would seriously question the motives of anyone behind such a campaign in 2006. My reason for that is because there are so many examples of morally innocent and decent people who whose rights are violated…

But isn’t this to say that while there are more important rights to focus on, voting against or abstaining from a process to repeal animal torture laws would be sanctioning the violation of man’s rights?

Indeed. I have seen surprisingly few arguments as to why torturing animals is immoral. If a person tortures an animal for the sake of his pleasure, what is the argument that he is being immoral?

What is immoral - and, more than that, mentally deranged - is the mere fact that a grown adult derives pleasure from the suffering of another living creature.

Creatures with lower forms of consciousness, such as snakes and fish, may not be advanced enough to actually be aware that they are experiencing pain - but higher level animals most definitely are aware of pain and are capable of suffering tremendously. They feel the exact same sort of pain that you and I do if we were subjected to torture.

The fact that animals do not have rights does not mean that their lives are without value. Life itself is a profoundly precious value - and the fact that the higher animals do have a certain level of awareness and are capable of suffering is something which a mentally healthy human properly respects.

Having such respect does not mean that a person should refrain from killing animals when there is a purpose for doing so - i.e. food, clothing, removal of pests and, yes, even sport. But this respect DOES mean that one does what one can to minimize the animal’s suffering.

Those who would take pleasure from the suffering of an innocent creature - well, the very psychology that would make such pleasure possible is profoundly twisted. It is to hold with disregard the value of life itself. If life, as such, is not a value - then why should one regard a human life as being of value? And why would one subscribe to the notion that man has rights in the first place if human life was not a value? Again, the fact that a person takes pleasure from the suffering of animals is a very strong warning sign of someone who will eventually seek to do the same with human beings - and this fact is not a mere coincidence.

The fact that we have a rational faculty while they do not brings about a huge gulf between human beings and all other creatures. But there is also a major common bond - we are all LIVING creatures. And the more advanced an animal’s consciousness, the greater that bond becomes.

Values exist in a hierarchy. To say that a human life is infinitely more precious than an dog’s or cat’s is not to say that the dog or cat’s life is without value and not morally worthy of respect.

But isn’t this to say that while there are more important rights to focus on, voting against or abstaining from a process to repeal animal torture laws would be sanctioning the violation of man’s rights?

Voting against it might perhaps be such a sanction. But abstaining from such a process most certainly is not. There are many reasons why a person might abstain. Maybe they are busy with living their lives. Or, as I indicated in my previous posting, perhaps they have bigger and more important fish to fry. Or, perhaps the people leading the crusade for such repeal are a bunch of sickos and kooks that one wishes to have nothing to do with.

What is immoral - and, more than that, mentally deranged - is the mere fact that a grown adult derives pleasure from the suffering of another living creature.

Well said.

[Edit - Abbreviated Quoted Section - RC]

If life, as such, is not a value - then why should one regard a human life as being of value? And why would one subscribe to the notion that man has rights in the first place if human life was not a value?

I agree with most everything you have said, and I think I understand the intent of what you are trying to get across. If perhaps I have misunderstood you, I certainly welcome clarification/correction. Below are my thoughts on the parts with which I am having difficulty.

Life (as such) is not a value without context anymore than any other “thing” is a value without context. One other reason why one would subscribe to the notion that man has rights in the first place is not necessarily because human life (in and of itself) is a value, but because their life is a value. By extension, some other specific human lives have value to them as well, but not necessary human life in general. Now I would agree that “human life in general” certainly can be a legitimate value and probably is for a great many people. From my own point of view, the world would be a lonely place if I was the only one in it.

I can think of quite a few humans I would like to see dead. Their lives have NO value to me. In many other instances, the life or death of many individuals is of no noticeable consequence to me. I do not wish them death, nor would I endeavor to bring about their death, but I will not feel loss if they die. In fact, many human deaths are actually a valuable reminder to me about just how much I love my own life and why “is/ought” is so important. On the other hand, there are other lives that hold quite significant value to me, such as my son and my wife.

I hold valuable the death of many animals that provide food for my table. I grew up hunting animals, and my father taught me not to kill senselessly or needlessly so I take no pleasure in torturing animals. (though admittedly I’ll tease my cats and dogs sometimes :slight_smile: ) Now since the time my father taught me this, I have since evaluated these ideas on my own so that I didn’t just act on “how I was brought up”.

I can also agree that such senseless or needless torture is indicative of some serious psychological issue and/or should be morally judged. I would say that such behavior is not necessarily indicative of the person not valuing human life (or life) in general so much as they do not properly value their own life.

I can relate to “respectably” killing animals when there is a need. However, the main reason why I think the killing should be respectably carried out is because I empathize with what it would be like if I (or someone I loved) were to be killed in some torturous manner. But in the end, dead is dead. No matter how respectably one might have killed the animal, the “value” of it’s life is extinguished. Whoever killed it didn’t value it’s life that much. One obvious exception to this would be the pet owner who euthanizes a long time pet who is now suffering through what’s left of it’s existence.

The fact that animals do not have rights does not mean that their lives are without value. Life itself is a profoundly precious value

This sounds like intrinsicism - a value to whom? The life of the average spider is of no value whatsoever to me, and I suppose other people feel the same about cats/cows/whatever.

Having such respect does not mean that a person should refrain from killing animals when there is a purpose for doing so - i.e. food, clothing, removal of pests and, yes, even sport.

What if my purpose is simply because I derive pleasure from it? Some people derive pleasure from hunting rabbits or (painfully) killing fish - why cant I derive pleasure from tortuning a cat?

Those who would take pleasure from the suffering of an innocent creature - well, the very psychology that would make such pleasure possible is profoundly twisted.

No - a lot of children derive pleasure from (eg) pulling the legs of spiders or hurting the family dog, and I dont think this is grounds for sending them to a psychiatrist. When they grow older, they learn that we, as a society, tend to frown upon that sort of thing and hence stop doing it. But in the absence of an animal rights framework, this cant be said to be objectively correct - its just what we happen to do as a culture.

. If life, as such, is not a value - then why should one regard a human life as being of value?

The life of the average human is of no value to me - I couldnt care less about the deaths of people I do not know. However, I refrain from initiating force against others because I believe that all humans have a basic set of rights regardless of whether I value the individuals in question. Buf if animals have no rights, theres no obvious reason why theres a problem with torturing them if it brings you pleasure (hunting or fishing for instance, or just pulling the legs off cats, which is pretty much the same thing).

Values exist in a hierarchy. To say that a human life is infinitely more precious than an dog’s or cat’s is not to say that the dog or cat’s life is without value and not morally worthy of respect.

Again, this is intrinsicism. You cant have it both ways.If nothing is intrinsically valuable and animals have no rights, there is no good reason to view torturing them as immoral, unless you can show that this is likely to have negative effects on the torturers. And if you want this to be objective, then youre going to need something a lot more substantial than vague notions of being ‘psychologically twisted’ or whatever.

*Agrees* [about stealing the cat]

Again, why not just put a gun to his head and pull the trigger?

What if he were skeet-shooting priceless artwork? Would you steal that? Is this urge to violate rights based on the fact that it’s an animal, or that he is wasting his property?

Life (as such) is not a value without context anymore than any other “thing” is a value without context.

I agree completely. I hold that life is a profound value. But there are certain living beings whose existence in my proximity is a huge disvalue to me and I would have no problem killing such a being. My only point was that I would not wish for it to suffer a painful and tortuous death.

One other reason why one would subscribe to the notion that man has rights in the first place is not necessarily because human life (in and of itself) is a value, but because their life is a value.

I agree completely. And, to take it further, the bond that I have with all other living creatures is that I profoundly value my life - and, in the same way, I have a profound RESPECT for life, as such. Having such respect does not mean, however, that I equate all forms of life or even all human lives with my own. Nor does it suggest that I attach value to particular lives, human or otherwise.

By extension, some other specific human lives have value to them as well, but not necessary human life in general. Now I would agree that “human life in general” certainly can be a legitimate value and probably is for a great many people. From my own point of view, the world would be a lonely place if I was the only one in it.

I can think of quite a few humans I would like to see dead. Their lives have NO value to me.

Again, I agree.

SOME human lives are a disvalue and are best extinguished - for example, terrorists, dictators such as Hitler, Stalin, Castro etc.

In many other instances, the life or death of many individuals is of no noticeable consequence to me. I do not wish them death, nor would I endeavor to bring about their death, but I will not feel loss if they die.

True, you would not feel loss if they die because you do not know them - they, in particular, are not of value to you personally. I have mourned the death of my cats - but I don’t mourn the death of some random stranger I read about on the obituary page. My doing so, of course, has zero implications that I somehow hold cat lives over human lives.

However, my guess is that when you read of some innocent stranger who is brutally murdered and when you hear of terrorist attacks on completely innocent strangers you are profoundly outraged. Why? Because you recognize the profound value of human life and the potential that is open to all human beings. Thus you are outraged because such murders are a profound act of injustice.

It is the same thing when a person tortures an animal for no reason other than to make it suffer - it is a profound injustice to a living creature. This is true even if the continued existence of the living creature is a disvalue.. Let’s say that I am a farmer and a wolf is killing off my livestock. I obviously would get rid of the wolf. But to stand over it while it twists in agony after I have given it a disabling but not immediately lethal wound and get some sort of satisfaction out of it is profoundly sick - even if I am still upset about the loss of my valuable livestock. A wolf does not know right from wrong - going after livestock is in its nature. Because of that nature, I must kill it. But it does not justify my wanting to see it suffer.

I can also agree that such senseless or needless torture is indicative of some serious psychological issue and/or should be morally judged. I would say that such behavior is not necessarily indicative of the person not valuing human life (or life) in general so much as they do not properly value their own life.

I agree. The ability to value other human beings and life in general derives from our love of our own lives.

I can relate to “respectably” killing animals when there is a need. However, the main reason why I think the killing should be respectably carried out is because I empathize with what it would be like if I (or someone I loved) were to be killed in some torturous manner.

Indeed.

But in the end, dead is dead. No matter how respectably one might have killed the animal, the “value” of it’s life is extinguished. Whoever killed it didn’t value it’s life that much.

Sure. But to not value something “all that much” does not mean that one regards it as worthless or completely without value. Values are hierarchical. If you are a hunter and shoot a deer, the life of that particular deer is not of value to you in the sense that you place a vastly higher value on its carcass and the things you will get from it than you do its life. For you, that particular deer is a greater value dead than it is alive. On the other hand, if, when you take it down, you have merely wounded it to the degree that it will take a few minutes before it dies a very painful death, you are most likely going to put the creature out of its misery even though doing so is going to cost you the money it took to purchase the extra bullet.

What if my purpose is simply because I derive pleasure from it? Some people derive pleasure from hunting rabbits or (painfully) killing fish - why cant I derive pleasure from tortuning a cat?

Because doing so is a profound injustice - and, more importantly, because deriving pleasure from suffering is psychologically SICK.

No - a lot of children derive pleasure from (eg) pulling the legs of spiders or hurting the family dog, and I dont think this is grounds for sending them to a psychiatrist.

Children don’t know any better and do not fully realize the degree to which animals or even other people can suffer. It is the task of parents to teach them better. The only time one would send a child to a psychiatrist for such a matter is if it becomes habitual or they derive joy from suffering - and then it is very important to send the child to a psychiatrist because that is a major early warning sign of an emerging criminal personality.

When they grow older, they learn that we, as a society, tend to frown upon that sort of thing and hence stop doing it. But in the absence of an animal rights framework, this cant be said to be objectively correct - its just what we happen to do as a culture.

No - there is more to it than mere social convention.

The animal rights framework goes back in this country only so far. People who lived in the wilderness were the exact opposite of animal rights types - yet they were humane in their treatment of the animals they killed.

The life of the average human is of no value to me - I couldnt care less about the deaths of people I do not know.

Please re-read what you just wrote. If this is so and not merely a very badly worded passage - then you are a SICK-O and I see no point in further interaction with you.