Life (as such) is not a value without context anymore than any other “thing” is a value without context.
I agree completely. I hold that life is a profound value. But there are certain living beings whose existence in my proximity is a huge disvalue to me and I would have no problem killing such a being. My only point was that I would not wish for it to suffer a painful and tortuous death.
One other reason why one would subscribe to the notion that man has rights in the first place is not necessarily because human life (in and of itself) is a value, but because their life is a value.
I agree completely. And, to take it further, the bond that I have with all other living creatures is that I profoundly value my life - and, in the same way, I have a profound RESPECT for life, as such. Having such respect does not mean, however, that I equate all forms of life or even all human lives with my own. Nor does it suggest that I attach value to particular lives, human or otherwise.
By extension, some other specific human lives have value to them as well, but not necessary human life in general. Now I would agree that “human life in general” certainly can be a legitimate value and probably is for a great many people. From my own point of view, the world would be a lonely place if I was the only one in it.
I can think of quite a few humans I would like to see dead. Their lives have NO value to me.
Again, I agree.
SOME human lives are a disvalue and are best extinguished - for example, terrorists, dictators such as Hitler, Stalin, Castro etc.
In many other instances, the life or death of many individuals is of no noticeable consequence to me. I do not wish them death, nor would I endeavor to bring about their death, but I will not feel loss if they die.
True, you would not feel loss if they die because you do not know them - they, in particular, are not of value to you personally. I have mourned the death of my cats - but I don’t mourn the death of some random stranger I read about on the obituary page. My doing so, of course, has zero implications that I somehow hold cat lives over human lives.
However, my guess is that when you read of some innocent stranger who is brutally murdered and when you hear of terrorist attacks on completely innocent strangers you are profoundly outraged. Why? Because you recognize the profound value of human life and the potential that is open to all human beings. Thus you are outraged because such murders are a profound act of injustice.
It is the same thing when a person tortures an animal for no reason other than to make it suffer - it is a profound injustice to a living creature. This is true even if the continued existence of the living creature is a disvalue.. Let’s say that I am a farmer and a wolf is killing off my livestock. I obviously would get rid of the wolf. But to stand over it while it twists in agony after I have given it a disabling but not immediately lethal wound and get some sort of satisfaction out of it is profoundly sick - even if I am still upset about the loss of my valuable livestock. A wolf does not know right from wrong - going after livestock is in its nature. Because of that nature, I must kill it. But it does not justify my wanting to see it suffer.
I can also agree that such senseless or needless torture is indicative of some serious psychological issue and/or should be morally judged. I would say that such behavior is not necessarily indicative of the person not valuing human life (or life) in general so much as they do not properly value their own life.
I agree. The ability to value other human beings and life in general derives from our love of our own lives.
I can relate to “respectably” killing animals when there is a need. However, the main reason why I think the killing should be respectably carried out is because I empathize with what it would be like if I (or someone I loved) were to be killed in some torturous manner.
Indeed.
But in the end, dead is dead. No matter how respectably one might have killed the animal, the “value” of it’s life is extinguished. Whoever killed it didn’t value it’s life that much.
Sure. But to not value something “all that much” does not mean that one regards it as worthless or completely without value. Values are hierarchical. If you are a hunter and shoot a deer, the life of that particular deer is not of value to you in the sense that you place a vastly higher value on its carcass and the things you will get from it than you do its life. For you, that particular deer is a greater value dead than it is alive. On the other hand, if, when you take it down, you have merely wounded it to the degree that it will take a few minutes before it dies a very painful death, you are most likely going to put the creature out of its misery even though doing so is going to cost you the money it took to purchase the extra bullet.