The use of fracking fluids to extract natural gas, which pollutes water supplies of innocent people forever and destroys private land value, is an example of the “looting” that Rand opposed. Fracking is made possible because of corrupt politicians who waive regulations that otherwise maintain environmental justice and private property rights. In short fracking is possible because of what Rand called “collectivism”, better called corporatism, namely the collusion between crony capitalists and government. And yet at the end of the first Atlas Shrugged movie, natural gas extracters are hinted at as being an example of the “achievers”. In truth they are nothing of the kind.
The evidence indicates that fracking is pretty safe.
The evidence indicates that fracking is pretty safe.
No, the evidence shows it is exceedingly damaging to the water supplies, to people’s health, and to private property.
You’re not allowed to have your own facts, and denial of evidence does not constitute an opinion.
Fracking is the nightmare of collectivism that Rand predicted.
Watch:
Even if the evidence does show that fracking is dangerous (which is quickly reversing direction), Rand would not be against the act in principle. She would be against it if a gas company lied to a local community and then polluted their water, but not if the company set up some sort of safety precautions or compensated the damaged persons.
Fracking is made possible because of corrupt politicians who waive regulations that otherwise maintain environmental justice and private property rights.
Perhaps federal regulations were never intended to, or in any case have been inadequate to, protect the environment or private property rights then.
Tell it to Yoko Ono.
The best piece I’ve seen on the subject is Kevin Williamson’s. He makes the point, among many others, that lots of locales, including the one in Gasland, have naturally flammable water from underground methane, and people have known about them since ancient times. Fracking has nothing to do with it.
What has this to do with collectivism anyway? It’s a political or ethical theory, not a gas-extraction technology.
Even if the evidence does show that fracking is dangerous (which is quickly reversing direction), Rand would not be against the act in principle. She would be against it if a gas company lied to a local community and then polluted their water, but not if the company set up some sort of safety precautions or compensated the damaged persons.
No, the evidence is abundant and growing that fracking is horribly dangerous. It’s the crony capitalists who say otherwise. The companies that do fracking lie to their workers about the risks, they lie to the affected public, they lie to the media. They have the moral legitimacy of Charles Manson. Objectivism is not about greed and looting, as fracking advocates might like to claim it is. It’s about stopping nightmare scenarios like what happened in Stalin’s Russia, or what is happening today in America with fracking, banker bailouts, and lobbyists controlling Congress, which Rand called collectivism.
He makes the point, among many others, that lots of locales, including the one in Gasland, have naturally flammable water from underground methane, and people have known about them since ancient times.
So perfectly fine water supplies suddenly become bubbly and polluted with fracking fluids, which includes antifreeze, and your response is to blame the victims – to blame private citizens who get poisoned because of crony capitalists (frackers) are paying off corrupt politicians. You’d be guilty in Rand’s view.
Here’s a recent Popular Mechanics article about fracking.
Is Fracking Safe? The Top 10 Controversial Claims About Natural Gas Drilling
No, the evidence shows it is exceedingly damaging to the water supplies, to people’s health, and to private property.
Environmentalists come up with such claims every few years. Disprove one, and they come up with something new. One time it is DDT, another time acid-rain, then alar, then we’re cooling the earth, then we’re warming it.
Fracking is not Rand’s “nightmare of collectivism”. For that, you would have to look to people like Rachel Carson, responsible for thousands of deaths.
I suppose Michael Moore is your notion of a Rand hero?
So perfectly fine water supplies suddenly become bubbly and polluted with fracking fluids, which includes antifreeze, and your response is to blame the victims – to blame private citizens who get poisoned because of crony capitalists (frackers) are paying off corrupt politicians. You’d be guilty in Rand’s view.
That wasn’t his point. I think the claim is that fracking wasn’t the cause of the polluted water so their is no victimization in the first place. You are welcome to offer a rebuttal supported with evidence. I’m personally on the fence about fracking. I guess I have an “open” mind on the subject.
Var -
Your presumptuous psychological pronouncements about Rand and me suggest that you don’t have a lot of confidence in your case.
If you say that Rand would have opposed fracking you put yourself in the position of having why she wrote a hero (Ellis Wyatt) who made the process work.
Here’s a recent Popular Mechanics article about fracking.
Popular Mechanics lost all credibility when they cheerfully lied about 9/11, claiming that small fires caused an entire building (WTC building 7) to collapse at free-fall speed.
One time it is DDT, another time acid-rain, then alar, then we’re cooling the earth, then we’re warming it.
If you think DDT is safe, please be my guest and eat some of it. Same with fracking fluids, you’ll love the flavor.
If you say that Rand would have opposed fracking you put yourself in the position of having why she wrote a hero (Ellis Wyatt) who made the process work.
Pumping carcinogens and antifreeze into the water supply, which is what fracking entails, is not the same as oil shale extraction. Anyhow Rand clearly was not a scientist. She insisted smoking was safe, after all.
I guess I have an “open” mind on the subject.
If you review the evidence, your mind will be made up for you.
Watch:
Popular Mechanics lost all credibility when they cheerfully lied about 9/11, claiming that small fires caused an entire building (WTC building 7) to collapse at free-fall speed.
I’m sorry? That’s not what the Popular Mechanics article actually says:
NIST investigators believe _ a combination of intense fire and severe structural damage contributed to the collapse _ , though assigning the exact proportion requires more research. But NIST’s analysis suggests the fall of WTC 7 was an example of “progressive collapse,” a process in which the failure of parts of a structure ultimately creates strains that cause the entire building to come down. Videos of the fall of WTC 7 show cracks, or “kinks,” in the building’s facade just before the two penthouses disappeared into the structure, one after the other. The entire building fell in on itself, with the slumping east side of the structure pulling down the west side in a diagonal collapse.
Also, there is no claim that it fell at free-fall speed.
Read more: 9/11 Conspiracy Theories - Debunking the Myths - World Trade Center - Popular Mechanics
Popular Mechanics lost all credibility when they cheerfully lied about 9/11, claiming that small fires caused an entire building (WTC building 7) to collapse at free-fall speed.
WOA! Now there’s a red flag.
Popular Mechanics lost all credibility when they cheerfully lied about 9/11, claiming that small fires caused an entire building (WTC building 7) to collapse at free-fall speed.
I don’t think you’re going to find many (any?) like minded people on this site.
Popular Mechanics lost all credibility when they cheerfully lied about 9/11, claiming that small fires caused an entire building (WTC building 7) to collapse at free-fall speed.
Aha! Now we know.
If you think DDT is safe, please be my guest and eat some of it. Same with fracking fluids, you’ll love the flavor.
Well, there are so many levels on which this is wrong.
Firstly, remember this: the poison is in the dose. Water can kill you.
Secondly, personally, my house has been sprayed with DDT a few times… sprayed so that there was a white fog inside with me in it. The only effect on me has been that I’m not alienated enough from reality to believe conspiracy theories about 9/11.
Thirdly, here is a video of people eating DDT: