The Childs-Peikoff Hypothesis

But if the government is to use force against me – and to do so, itself, with justice – then we are contending that I have somehow initiated the use of force. Yes?

How so, and against whom? If I find a murderer and put him on trial and do everything that we would also have a proper government do, then am I not acting properly? – which is to say, I am not initiating force, but acting in response to an initiation of the use of force, just as any other proper governmental action?

Don,

Thanks very much for your comment.

Trials by private agencies would only be possible with close governmental oversight, again, to insure procedural objectivity. Consider the frequency with which trial verdicts are overturned because of some seemingly trivial error on the part of the court—allowing the use of tainted evidence or questionable testimony, etc. Any hint of impartiality is sufficient cause to void a guilty verdict. The role of the government is to insure absolute adherence to due process—rules of evidence, jury selection. et. al. Without ironclad safeguards on due process, there would be no assurance that justice was served in a given case.

So, yes, in the absence of such oversight, the government can legitimately intervene to stop a trial conducted by a private agency in the name of protecting individual rights. If there were no such oversight, what would stop alleged “victims” from paying private agencies to conduct “trials” for the purpose of prosecuting anyone they considered guilty of having harmed them? There would be nothing to insure the impartiality of the outcome.

The government would be justified in acting on principle to prevent the initiation of force by such agencies, even if, in a given instance, a particular agency acted properly (i.e., observed appropriate due process) without governmental oversight. That is the only way a government can guarantee the protection of individual rights in all cases.

Why do that? Why not consider them for what they are at face value: disagreement with your position.

I‘m sorry if this response seems less than civil, but you will need to learn to express yourself more succinctly if you expect me to respond. I do not have the time to read 3000 word essays on a webforum and then respond to every point. Particularly not when the purpose of the essay is to defend an elaborate fantasy whose entire theoretical basis consists of a falsehood—the alleged “immorality” of limited government.

And I suspect that when people need thousands of words to convey a simple theory, they either do not know what they are talking about or the theory itself defies rational comprehension.

Don,

Thanks very much for your comment.

Trials by private agencies would only be possible with close governmental oversight, again, to insure procedural objectivity. Consider the frequency with which trial verdicts are overturned because of some seemingly trivial error on the part of the court—allowing the use of tainted evidence or questionable testimony, etc. Any hint of impartiality is sufficient cause to void a guilty verdict. The role of the government is to insure absolute adherence to due process—rules of evidence, jury selection. et. al. Without ironclad safeguards on due process, there would be no assurance that justice was served in a given case.

So, yes, in the absence of such oversight, the government can legitimately intervene to stop a trial conducted by a private agency in the name of protecting individual rights. If there were no such oversight, what would stop alleged “victims” from paying private agencies to conduct “trials” for the purpose of prosecuting anyone they considered guilty of having harmed them? There would be nothing to insure the impartiality of the outcome.

The government would be justified in acting on principle to prevent the initiation of force by such agencies, even if, in a given instance, a particular agency acted properly (i.e., observed appropriate due process) without governmental oversight. That is the only way a government can guarantee the protection of individual rights in all cases.

Well this is interestingly similar to the theist’s cosmological argument. A “first cause” is needed to explain the existence of the universe, but then a first cause is needed to explain the supposed “first cause,” and so on, until you have an infinite regress. So the government is overseeing, in Nozickian fashion, that the correct procedures are being followed. But then if these other agencies require a “super-agency” to oversee the correct procedures are being used, who is to oversee the super-agency to ensure it is following the correct procedures? Does being a member of the super-agency somehow endow you with the ability to be objective, whereas being a member of any of the other agencies does not?

But moreover, we have this picture of the government as a “licensing agency,” so to speak, granting licenses to act within a certain set of legal rules, and being the “overseer” as Hardin wants it, of these other agencies. First of all, what exactly this means can have varying interpretations (I’ll skip listing all of them for now), but suppose that means something like the state confines itself to doing what Hardin wants it to do, ie,. to oversee that all other agencies are adhering to the correct procedures of justice. If one believes, as we both do, in such a single, uniform standard, then what possible objection could you have to this?

You see, saying “well yes, if they use the correct procedures, then it’s okay, as long as one agency oversees the correct procedures” doesn’t escape Don Athos’ question. Let’s think what this would look like for a second. We’re supposed to have a variety of competing agencies on the free market, and one organization takes upon itself the job of forcing all the other agencies to conform to the single, uniform standard of objective justice. But it’s the only organization doing this, so then suppose another organization enters that field and competes in the job of being the “licensing agency” certifying in accordance with the same exact principles of justice. Does it then prohibit competition in that field? Even if the other agencies are “overseeing” in accordance with the exact same principles, as per Don Athos’ question? If so, then it is an unjust aggressor on its own grounds, for if the coercive imposition of these objective principles of justice is permissible, then it is permissible for anybody. Secondly, it is also undesirable on incentive grounds (the same reasons we don’t want licensing laws, e.g. in consumer protection or for the medical industry), since all coercive monopolies (and licensing laws) lack the very checks and balances that make us want competition in the first place, and so this type of argument completely fails on its own grounds.

I‘m sorry if this response seems less than civil, but you will need to learn to express yourself more succinctly if you expect me to respond. I do not have the time to read 3000 word essays on a webforum and then respond to every point. Particularly not when the purpose of the essay is to defend an elaborate fantasy whose entire theoretical basis consists of a falsehood—the alleged “immorality” of limited government.

I think this requirement for “succinctness” is funny. First I give you the condensed version, for which you complained was “blurting out” “assertions.” But now it’s just all too much to read.

Suppose I say “you’re defending and elaborate fantasy whose entire theoretical basis consists of a falsehood.” Your position is “pure, undiluted rationalism.” “This is just rationalist crap,” my position is obvious, why, “no sane person disagreeds with me,” etc. (your actual words) and make a whole string of one-sentence assertions, well if my name is Dennis Hardin, then I don’t need any evidence for that. I don’t need any supporting argumentation for this lines. I don’t need to show any line of reasoning. I can just say them.

On the other hand, suppose you’re 2046, and you’re saying something other than just regurgitation of conventional Randian phrases and lines (mostly from the Ayn Rand Lexicon), why then these become “obfuscations” and “unsupported assertions.” And of course people may reasonably expect an explanation, or supporting reasoning, for what I mean. But I can’t give such reasoning if Dennis Hardin-style “succinctness” is required. Nice isn’t it. You can only repeat conventional thoughts under this criteria.

And I suspect that when people need thousands of words to convey a simple theory, they either do not know what they are talking about or the theory itself defies rational comprehension.

Have you ever studied physics or medicine or something like that? You can’t distill a lot of these theories in such a manner.

2046, I am interested to here more about your theories, but I always see them in response format. Would you be willing to start a new thread where you lay out a synopsis of your political theory?

You see, saying “well yes, if they use the correct procedures, then it’s okay, as long as one agency oversees the correct procedures” doesn’t escape Don Athos’ question. Let’s think what this would look like for a second. We’re supposed to have a variety of competing agencies on the free market, and one organization takes upon itself the job of forcing all the other agencies to conform to the single, uniform standard of objective justice. But it’s the only organization doing this, so then suppose another organization enters that field and competes in the job of being the “licensing agency” certifying in accordance with the same exact principles of justice. Does it then prohibit competition in that field? Even if the other agencies are “overseeing” in accordance with the exact same principles, as per Don Athos’ question? If so, then it is an unjust aggressor on its own grounds, for if the coercive imposition of these objective principles of justice is permissible, then it is permissible for anybody. Secondly, it is also undesirable on incentive grounds (the same reasons we don’t want licensing laws, e.g. in consumer protection or for the medical industry), since all coercive monopolies (and licensing laws) lack the very checks and balances that make us want competition in the first place, and so this type of argument completely fails on its own grounds.

This comment reflects zero progress in your understanding of the concept of objective restraint on the use of force. I don’t know if you are honestly unable to grasp the concept or actively working to sustain an evasion, but in either case, there is obviously no point in wasting further time with you discussing this matter.

Your follow-up post was pure invective. So, again, no comment by me is needed here.

This comment reflects zero progress in your understanding of the concept of objective restraint on the use of force. I don’t know if you are honestly unable to grasp the concept or actively working to sustain an evasion, but in either case, there is obviously no point in wasting further time with you discussing this matter.

Your follow-up post was pure invective. So, again, no comment by me is needed here.

Your post reflects your absolute zero willingness to confront the fact that the idea of having objective restraints on the use of force doesn’t logically get us to a monopoly. We’ll let the readers be the judge of who is evading.

Is there a difference between government and dispensers of justice? If individuals are in the right to ‘dispense’ justice , as long as they follow correct procedures, then there is no need for government?

Quid custodiet ad ipsos custodii? Who shall guard, the Guardians of justice? And what keeps a righteous group of citizens from becoming a vigilante gang?

That problem is as old as the notion of government and justice. 8000 years later and there is still no sure fire answer.

ruveyn1

2046, I am interested to here more about your theories, but I always see them in response format. Would you be willing to start a new thread where you lay out a synopsis of your political theory?

I appreciate it of course, but I don’t want to run afoul of the forum rules, so I don’t open a new thread. However, I trust responding to or analyzing various arguments presented falls under the category of “honest questions about such subjects.” I think the links in #18 are definitely worth reading in regards how a free market legal order could work, and historical examples are discussed. A good starting point for understanding how law without a state is possible is books like Bruno Leoni, Freedom and the Law, Edward P. Stringham (Editor), Anarchy and the Law, Bruce Benson, The Enterprise of Law: Justice without the State.

As to why should we have a free market legal order, the foundations are the same as the argument for a laissez-faire capitalist society. The question of what kind of constitutional structure we should have goes along with the question of what our goals are. So you have articulated philosophical principles on the one hand, and the question of political structure on the other hand. We get conclusions like, we should have a society that respects the non-initiation of force principle, we should have restraints on the use of retalitatory force, so we should have objective law, etc. So then what kind of system will produce objective law and will have the best incentive structure for maintaining respect for individual rights. So what is objective law? What are its requirements? Can a state satisfy these requirements, or does objective law require a free market? I mean, you could imagine a dictator that only wanted objective law, but that kind of system would have a terrible incentive structure, so you wouldn’t want it. You would want a constitutional structure incorporating checks and balances, separation of powers, etc. So where Rand stopped short and supported representative democracy, I think if we analyze her arguments, you will find defficiencies, and I think that the incentive structure of the free market provides the best constitution for a free society.

So the question boils down to what kind of constitution should a free nation have? In trying to answer that question we immediately think in terms of a Bill of Rights, restrictions on governmental power, and so forth. And any constitution worth having would certainly include those things. Usually Objectivists answer “well we should have a written constitution,” and that would solve a lot of the structural problems. But mere paper constitutions are neither necessary (look at Britain) nor sufficient (look at Soviet Russia) for actually operative restraints. What matters is a nation’s constitution in the original sense of the actual institutions, practices, and incentive structures that are in place.

So a constitution has no existence independent of the actual behaviour and interactions of actual human beings.Things like “separations and divisions of powers, and checks and balances,” are not structures that exist as external limitations on society, as if they are being imposed from without. But in fact those structures exist only insofar as they are continually maintained in existence by human agents acting in certain systematic ways. A constitution is not some impersonal, miraculously self-enforcing robot. It’s an ongoing pattern of behaviour, and it persists only so long as human agents continue to conform to that pattern in their actions.

So if a constitution is to be more than a wish list, it must also specify the political structure necessary to ensure that people have an incentive to keep acting in a manner consistent with the articulated philosophical principles that you’re attempted to put in place. And so the incentive structure you put in place must encourage people to act in a manner consistent with individual rights, to produce objective law, to encouraging social cooperation, persuasion instead of force, and peace. So in discussing whether a government or the market is the best for this, you have to look at the incentives of each strucutres, and I think there are problems with coerced monopoly, and I think the opponent of competition has some considerations to surmount before they can prove their case.

I still do not understand how in the abscence of unilateral(?) rule of law there could exist conditions for a market.

I still do not understand how in the absence of unilateral(?) rule of law there could exist conditions for a market.

That may well be because you are unwilling to evade the fundamental difference between the free exchange of goods and services and the exchange of gunfire.

I still do not understand how in the abscence of unilateral(?) rule of law there could exist conditions for a market.

I don’t understand that either. Good thing that’s not what we’re arguing here, as I have explained to you at least 5 times now. At some point you have to stop ignoring responses and make an argument instead of asserting things.

That may well be because you are unwilling to evade the fundamental difference between the free exchange of goods and services and the exchange of gunfire.

What would that even mean? Obviously we are not for “free exchange of gunfire” so this meaningless sloganizing is argument by assertion.

I don’t understand that either. Good thing that’s not what we’re arguing here, as I have explained to you at least 5 times now. At some point you have to stop ignoring responses and make an argument instead of asserting things.

Actually I think the situation is just that your assertions are more verbose, you have not shown, at least 5 times, that markets can operate without the rule of law.

Actually I think the situation is just that your assertions are more verbose, you have not shown, at least 5 times, that markets can operate without the rule of law.

I know I have not shown that. That’s probably because I’ve never attempted to show that. And I think you know that.

I don’t understand that either. Good thing that’s not what we’re arguing here, as I have explained to you at least 5 times now. At some point you have to stop ignoring responses and make an argument instead of asserting things.

Whether markets can operate without the precondition of the rule of objective law is precisely what we are arguing here. You argue that there can be a “market” (i.e., competition) in the control of “gunfire” (i.e., force).

That’s the consequence of rationalist thinking: ultimately you have no grasp of what your ideas mean in reality. The more levels of abstraction you put between your floating concepts (‘police agencies,’ courts, laws, et. al.) and their referents in reality (men with guns pointed at each other), the easier it is for you to go on entertaining the foolish fantasy of “anarcho-capitalism.”

Whether markets can operate without the precondition of the rule of objective law is precisely what we are arguing here. You argue that there can be a “market” (i.e., competition) in the control of “gunfire” (i.e., force).

That doesn’t make any more sense than saying than asking if the Internet can operate without objective rules to its operation. The Internet has protocols and all that without a central, monopolized agency. In some sense there is a market, but little deviation exists precisely because no one would get along. That would especially be applicable to violence - people don’t *want* to be killed, unless we want to presume a Hobbesian world. Rules can and do exist without a central agency, so certainly police agencies/courts/laws are reasonable. If anything, this is how the world works right now. Multiple governments means multiple standards of law and of course a variety of people wielding force, and some governments wielding force wrongly. I see no difference from just saying “anarcho capitalist private agency” and “government”. At least today, in 2013.

My point is not that I think anarcho-capitalism is right, but that your arguments are bad.

If you want to really demonstrate how government should be distinguished from private agencies, go through an example of it in practice. An thought experiment I like is consider how a “slave contract” would be dealt with. Suppose I decided to sell myself to you for you to control my life, doing this with a contract. People may think I’m crazy to do that, but hey, it’s my choice I’ll claim. Would this contract by respected in any sense, and if not, what would be done about it?

That doesn’t make any more sense than saying than asking if the Internet can operate without objective rules to its operation. The Internet has protocols and all that without a central, monopolized agency. In some sense there is a market, but little deviation exists precisely because no one would get along.

Yeah Google does what they do(and Ebay) regardless of knowing they have a civil court system to protect their “internet” property, hey they must be anarcho-capitalists.

Whether markets can operate without the precondition of the rule of objective law is precisely what we are arguing here. You argue that there can be a “market” (i.e., competition) in the control of “gunfire” (i.e., force).

Right but arguing the second sentence doesn’t commit you to the first sentence. You can say that my position might be that rule of objective law is possible (or even necessary) on the free market, but that that position is wrong and would lead to there being no stable rule of law. But then we are owed an argument for that, not self-evident assertions.

Right but arguing the second sentence doesn’t commit you to the first sentence. You can say that my position might be that rule of objective law is possible (or even necessary) on the free market, but that that position is wrong and would lead to there being no stable rule of law. But then we are owed an argument for that, not self-evident assertions.

One can only argue from the stand point of the conditions necessary for a market, you can not start with a market system. On the premise that traders must know in advance that their rights would be recognized and protected, by some entity or agency, prior to trading. If trading value for vlaue were contingent on nothing other than force, who but those that can wield the most force would even think of entering any type of ‘market’ activity. It seems to go against human nature to purposely put oneself in that position, the position of being at somones mercy that a trade will in fact occur.