In a polycentric legal system, are there any principles that work to compel the enforcement of objective law?
From the arguments presented, it seems there could exist some population( a frontier type city or some such) that would not be protected in their rights, if there existed no monopoly agency for law enforcement. What if justice dispensing agencies did not come about, what if no indvidual or group of individuals decidied it was not worth their while provide those ‘services’?
To begin with, I think it’s worth asking whether there are any principles that work to compel the enforcement of objective law in a monopolist legal system. I’m reminded of the (possibly apocryphal) story of, I believe Andrew Jackson, who disregarded a Supreme Court verdict saying “they have made their decision; now let us see them enforce it.”
So perhaps we could critique a “polycentric legal system” by asking what would happen if “justice dispensing agencies decided it was not worth their while” to dispense justice… but I think that’s potentially an equal critique of any other legal system. I mean, when you ask about a “frontier type city,” my first point of reference (and perhaps yours as well) is to picture the “Wild West,” which existed under the monopoly government of the United States. Whether I can provide satisfactory answers to these kinds of questions, I guess my first answer is that these are problems with “governance” generally, and not unique to the kinds of systems under discussion.
With respect to Objectivism, however, this is perhaps a more severe question… because we do not support even coercive taxation. And so one may well wonder what should happen to the administration of justice if people decided not to contribute to those local agencies that provide this sort of service. The United States government doesn’t have such an issue. Should you refuse to pay your taxes, they’ll simply cast you into prison and seize your assets. So yes – if we take seriously the idea that people should work together through means of reason and not physical compulsion, it’s worth asking: what if people simply opt not to work together at all?
But this seems to me to be equivalent to the sorts of questions one gets asked when advocating the termination of any coercively provided good. What happens when you eliminate public schooling? Will people simply stop getting educated? How can we be confident that children will continue to receive education if we’re not forcing them to do it?
To me, it ignores the reason as to why we’re concerned about education in the first place – it is a dear good. So dear, that people are and will be willing to work to provide it for themselves. In fact, it is that deep desire for education which provides the will to arrange for a public school system in the first place, and the funds, and the persistence to keep it running, even in the face of failure after failure. “The people” want education. But the means that they’ve chosen to acquire this education are coercive, immoral, and inefficient.
Obviously, the kinds of justice (and, generally speaking, self-defense) we’re discussing are indescribably dear, moreso than even education, and people flock to those who they believe will keep them safe (often in disastrous fashion). I do not fear that the provision of justice will disappear from lack of interest, once people are no longer compelled to pay for it (or when there are multiple agencies providing it), anymore than education would disappear with public schooling. Rather, I would expect a greater provision of justice – shorter waiting times on trials; fewer criminals released for want of prison space; and etc.
To look at one example, take the issue you’ve raised of the frontier town that is not being adequately served by existing institutions (and let us note that this is a problem, not alone in the “Wild West” days of the old U.S., but in current-day America, where poorer or harder-to-reach communities are sometimes poorly served). Such a community would no longer have to write letters to their Congressmen, cross their fingers and hope that some bureaucrat decided to fund a little money in their direction, but they could take action themselves – in the name of their own lives, and for their own self-defense – and legally administer the justice that their community requires.
So ultimately what this boils down to, is that individuals and groups of individuals would have to decide that justice is worth their while. I’m not concerned for it, but there is no way around that. And all such government is like this. What preserves our rights in the United States? The Constitution? That document requires the Congress to respect it in their laws, and the courts, and furthermore… it is amendable. The US system works – insofar as it does – because individuals believe in it, and work to uphold it. Government only works because people make government work.
If that’s not a comforting thought, perhaps this is another way to look at it…
Objectivists in my experience are sometimes a bit skeptical about political activism. Rather, it is felt that the current culture could not support an Objectivist-friendly government. And indeed, if it were to fall out of the sky, the people would immediately set about tearing it down and putting up something close to what we currently have. We have a statist system, because most people are statists. And so, we work on changing the culture, and improving the quality of educational materials (through things such as essay contests, inspiring students to read Rand’s novels; and getting Objectivist professors in universities; and writing essays on hot-button political topics; and participating in debates).
When Rand wrote about government financing – and the complete elimination of coercive taxation – she said:
The question of how to implement the principle of voluntary government financing—how to determine the best means of applying it in practice—is a very complex one and belongs to the field of the philosophy of law. The task of political philosophy is only to establish the nature of the principle and to demonstrate that it is practicable. The choice of a specific method of implementation is more than premature today—since the principle will be practicable only in a fully free society, a society whose government has been constitutionally reduced to its proper, basic functions.
[…]
Any program of voluntary government financing has to be regarded as a goal for a distant future.
I believe that the issue of monopoly vs. “polycentric” is also a goal for a distant future. It could only exist in a society that would also support what Rand here describes as a “fully free society, a society whose government has been constitutionally reduced to its proper, basic functions.” And in that sort of society, and among the men who would by necessity live in it, I do not fear that nobody would be interested in providing justice, or paying for it.