The New York Times’ A.O. Scott said it had Ayn Rand elements. A link to that review is on the other “Incredibles” thread.
But, Scott Holleran, an Objectivist, says the movie is Nietzchean and has an anti-business streak. But, if you can overlook that, it’s pretty good.
I’ve still gotta see it though, just to be sure.
Scott’s a good guy, but I often disagree with his movie analysis. This is one of those times.
The basic issue at stake is: conformity and anonymous mediocrity vs. greatness and individualism. Should these heroes use their abilities to their utmost potential, fight for justice, and have the courage to risk their lives in battle – or kowtow to the whines of the mob of mediocrity and give up and blend in?
I think this is my favorite Pixar movie to date – and that’s saying a lot, since they have yet to make a movie that was less than terrific. Pixar is today what Disney once was: a movie company that created movie after movie with beautiful animation with stories to match.
Scott’s a good guy, but I often disagree with his movie analysis. This is one of those times.
I second that. Scott is a long-time friend, and a really great guy, but more often than not we disagree about movies.
I think this is my favorite Pixar movie to date – and that’s saying a lot, since they have yet to make a movie that was less than terrific. Pixar is today what Disney once was: a movie company that created movie after movie with beautiful animation with stories to match.
I completely agree with the sentiment expressed, but, based on what I was told by the Pixar people themselves (I wrote about this) I would reverse that order and say “created movie after movie with a beautiful story and animation to match.” As much of technical wizardry that Pixar has become, with them the story still comes first.
Scott’s a good guy, but I often disagree with his movie analysis. This is one of those times.
The basic issue at stake is: conformity and anonymous mediocrity vs. greatness and individualism. Should these heroes use their abilities to their utmost potential, fight for justice, and have the courage to risk their lives in battle – or kowtow to the whines of the mob of mediocrity and give up and blend in?
I think this is my favorite Pixar movie to date – and that’s saying a lot, since they have yet to make a movie that was less than terrific. Pixar is today what Disney once was: a movie company that created movie after movie with beautiful animation with stories to match.
I saw the movie last night and enjoyed it immensely. However, perhaps because I’d read Scott’s review, I couldn’t help noticing the “don’t think, it’s in your blood” remark and the fact that the bad guy was an inventive genius who believed he could foster an egalitarian (altruistic) society by selling his inventions and making everyone “super” so that “no-one will be.” I don’t think that’s a good ad for capitalism, because although he was going to first sacrifice the Incredibles in order to achieve this egalitarianism, his remark suggests that greatness is strictly inborn and non-volitional. And that creating and selling inventions to society (one essential component of capitalism) is somehow in pursuit of egalitarianism. I really don’t know how that’ll go down with kids, who are sure to see it again and again.
That said, I thought the movie was fantastic! I enjoyed the technical wizardry and the story very much. The bits with Dash discovering the range of his powers were particularly exhilarating. I consider the film superior to many real-life action movies I’ve seen. And even if it does fall on the Nietzchean side of the ethical controversy, better that than the wimpy, its-no-use-being-a-superhero-whining that “SpiderMan 2” had to offer. If I had children, I’d much rather they saw a movie with strong, upright characters who self-confidently used their powers than with one who whined needlessly about his gifts. Even the villain in Incredibles seemed more motivated by “ego” than Alfred Molina’s Dr. Octopus, who wanted to foster the “good of the society,” blah, blah. Syndrome just wants to avenge himself.
I saw the movie last night and enjoyed it immensely. However, perhaps because I’d read Scott’s review, I couldn’t help noticing the “don’t think, it’s in your blood” remark and the fact that the bad guy was an inventive genius who believed he could foster an egalitarian (altruistic) society by selling his inventions and making everyone “super” so that “no-one will be.” I don’t think that’s a good ad for capitalism, because although he was going to first sacrifice the Incredibles in order to achieve this egalitarianism, his remark suggests that greatness is strictly inborn and non-volitional. And that creating and selling inventions to society (one essential component of capitalism) is somehow in pursuit of egalitarianism.
I saw the movie last night and enjoyed it. Yes, there are secondary aspects to the movie that are wrong, but the main theme of the movie is that egalitarianism is bad and heroism is good.
We’re going to have to get used to looking for the good fundamentals of things (like movies), and separating out the not-so-good secondary messages. Otherwise, we’ll end up alienating ourselves and missing out on the rising tide of Objectivism-related ideas in contemporary culture.
We’re going to have to get used to looking for the good fundamentals of things (like movies), and separating out the not-so-good secondary messages. Otherwise, we’ll end up alienating ourselves and missing out on the rising tide of Objectivism-related ideas in contemporary culture.
I think that, overall,t his movie was wonderful. From the previews it seemed like the main superhero would be this bumbling idiot who could lift cars and break walls, but at the same time couldn’t lock the seat belt over his bulging beer belly. I’m glad the movie was nothing of the kind. Although some of the themes I wish they did a liiitle bit better, others were spectacular - the value of family, the value of one’s own uniqueness, the dis-value of mediocrity - all explicitly stated and woven into the film’s primary storyline.
If nothing else, the best part about this movie was that it was an exuberant film about values, that was not afraid of itself, nor tried to trivialize its message. It was an unbridled romp of exciting and joyous struggle for values, and that alone made it a very rare film. Take the big modern classics, like Rambo, or Terminator. Sure they have fun adventure and explosions and big muscled tough guys, but in the end of the day, what moves the main characters other than an animal desire for survival? Take practically any movie today, and think about what the point of the movie is, and what you carry away in the end. In this analysis, The Incredibles is so rare as to be incredible itself
A man with super powers being kept down by society, only to break out again and win the day, might sum it up. The super heroes were tied down and turned into mediocrities. But, the protagonists had great senses of life and heroic qualities through and through. They couldn’t be kept down.
I loved the 1960s look and feel to their life style, and the mixture of James Bond-esque spy scenes and Star Wars-esque action scenes. The saucers chasing the boy were mindful of the levitating bikes in forest chase scene of The Return of the Jedi.
The movie was flat out fun! The computer animation is awesome.
Now, I didn’t like the way business was portrayed. They were down right malevolent people running that company. Very vicious. The movie comes down a couple of notches for that. That’s my only caveat.
Definitely worth seeing and even owning, with that one caveat.
What interested me more were the numerous previews before the Incredibles for a movie called “Bigg’s Adventure”- or something along those lines. The main characters have mottos such as “I can do anything” and “I would have built Rome in a day.” What’s even better is that they appear to use their minds and machinery to accomplish their feats, instead of supernatural powers that they were mysteriously born with.
There was a short scene in the Incredibles, from inside the Incredible’s house, where a bookshelf in the background had noticeable lettering for titles. However, the shot went by so fast I couldn’t make any of them out. I have a feeling Pixar threw in some self-references there, and I can’t help but wonder if there were any other interesting titles there… something heroic… about the men of ability…
It’ll have to wait until DVD and freeze frame, I guess.
There was a short scene in the Incredibles, from inside the Incredible’s house, where a bookshelf in the background had noticeable lettering for titles. However, the shot went by so fast I couldn’t make any of them out. I have a feeling Pixar threw in some self-references there, and I can’t help but wonder if there were any other interesting titles there… something heroic… about the men of ability…
It’ll have to wait until DVD and freeze frame, I guess.
They put stuff all over the place. A few that have been noted:
– A squad car in the police chase had the license plate “KR 54,” a reference, of course, to the 1960s TV show.
– Kevin O’Brien is one of the storyboard artists for the movie. A framed TV guide on the wall in the Indredible’s house reads “Kevin O’Brien: First Artist on the Moon.”
– Dash’s principal’s name is John Walker (as seen on a plaque of his wall), also the name of the producer.
I’m sure that many others have already been found, and I am equally sure that, as gnargtharst implies, many more will be found when the DVD arrives. These are clever and playful guys!
I have not seen the movie, but I am puzzled: if all these critics despise Ayn Rand, why are they so eager to use the movie to attack Objectivism, when the parallels are indirect, at best? Or is this just a case of parroting the original Rand reference?
GC, if you didn’t see The Incredibles, then what explains your short review of it here? I ask because in that post you have a link to a review by an Oist who calls this movie Nietzschean, as if you agree with him and thus point your readers in that direction for more info. Yet you haven’t seen the movie, so how do you know the validity of that review?
I have a question about the “PG” rating. Would those who have seen it comment on whether there is anything that would be inappropriate for a 7 year old and their 6-year old friend?
I’m sure some (much?) of the movie would go over my daughter’s head. But, specifically, is there anything that would be inappropriate. I tend to be on the prudish side of “normal” when it comes to exposure to sex. (For instance, I find aspects of many Disney flicks inappropriate.)
I have a question about the “PG” rating. Would those who have seen it comment on whether there is anything that would be inappropriate for a 7 year old and their 6-year old friend?
I recall some hugging and brief kissing, nothing more explicit than that. At one point Mr. Incredible is working on getting back into shape, and his wife twice eyes him hungrily and tugs him back inside, but I think your child would gloss over it as random slapstick.
As far as language, I don’t remember anything more aggressive than a “gee golly” or a “shucky darn.”