The Incredibles

*This talks about a little scene of the movie in relation to Objectivism, but is not a major plot spoiler:

I loved the part when upon arriving home from work, Mr. Incredible has a fit with his car and lifts it midair. A little neighbor boy passing by on his tricycle eyes him in amazement. After this spectacle, the youngster yet again appears in another scene lingering at the foot of the driveway. Mr. Incredible then demands, “What are you waiting for!?” In reply the kid innocently states, “I don’t know. Something amazing, I guess.”

Those lines had the same effect on me as the scene from The Fountainhead between Roark and the boy on the bicycle.

“Don’t work for my happiness, my brothers-show me yours-show me that it is possible-show me your achievement-and the knowledge will give me courage for mine.”

:dough: Super

I saw a quote from the director of the Incredibles, which seems to put to rest some of the notion of an Objectivist base to the movie. Kind of disappointing, but it was still a great movie nonetheless.

Q:“The Incredibles” generated quite a lot of ink on op-ed pages, where pundits debated the film’s thesis that mediocrity is celebrated in America and that people with special abilities were being discouraged from being quite so special. Were you surprised?

Brad Bird:The idea that “The Incredibles,” a mainstream animated feature, was thought of as provocative was wonderful to me. I was very gratified, though I thought some of the analysis was really kind of goofy.

Q:Such as?

Brad Bird:Some pieces compared the viewpoint to the objectivist philosopher Ayn Rand. I thought that was silly and the writers were humorless. I was into Rand for about six months when I was 20, but you outgrow that narrow point of view. Some compromise is necessary in life.

Source

Wow, I’ve never heard that line before…

Well at least he’s consistent. He certainly compromised when it came to his film.

This explains the movie perfectly in fact. The film’s basically good and heroic message was corrupted by several irrationalist ideas. That the director is roughly familiar with Objectivism but failed to grasp it fully makes sense. I take it as another sign that Objectivism is spreading.

This movie failed to reach its potential, both cinematically and philosophically, but I still enjoyed it a great deal.

I was into Rand for about six months when I was 20, but you outgrow that narrow point of view. Some compromise is necessary in life.

Sounds like my creative writing teacher in College and just about anybody else I come across most of the time. Especially when the talk gets to being about love. A good example is the fact that I am an Atheist and lets say I may be attracted to woman who is religious. Why is it assumed that I would be the one who would have to make the compromise?

:slight_smile:

I think, in terms of Objectivism, that a movie like this is a great way to get the foot in the door. It’s the kids who watch movies like that, and want to be like that, who will later read and accept Rand. That’s really a big step for movies, I think.