Why is it that visitors come in and ask, “Does Objectivism hold that…” or “Is it consistent with Objectivism that…” or “What would an Objectivist do?” ect.
Is it a misunderstanding of the nature of Objectivism? Is it not clear to curious readers that Objectivism is not a list of dogmatic rules written in an ancient text? I often think that the nature of Objectivism may be misrepresented because of the fact that much, if not all, of the genesis of the philosophy can be attributed to a single person. As if to say Ayn Rand sat down and wrote down a set of rules rather than methodically developed the process and the basis of Objectivism.
I think that it is necessary to make the distinction that Objectivism is a process, not a rule book; that it be differentiated from the dogmatism of religion and represented as something not to be check against rather used to discover the answer to visitor’s questions.
Any thoughts?
I think that it is necessary to make the distinction that Objectivism is a process, not a rule book; that it be differentiated from the dogmatism of religion and represented as something not to be check against rather used to discover the answer to visitor’s questions.
I disagree, since I think that Objectivism is a philosophy, not a process (or a rule book). Unlike nihilism, libertarianism, or Platonism, it is a very specific philosophy, namely the system identified by Rand. Platonism comes the closest to being a specific philosophy, if you identify it with “the philosophy esposed by Plato”, but many people want to fuzz the edges of Platonism up, by inventing variations on Plato’s philosophy. Unfortunately you see that very often in the study of Objectivism: people setting forth ideas that don’t have anything to do with Objectivism. I’m not really sure why people ask those “Does Objectivism say” questions, but one explanation might be that they don’t know because they aren’t familiar enough with the writings of Ayn Rand. Some of them are semi-tough, for example does Objectivism have a position on homosexuality or Beethoven. Somebody may have heard about the Ford Hall comment, and that would at least be a basis for initially thinking that it is something that’s part of Objectivism. Usually, I assume that people who ask those questions simply don’t know the answer.
I’ve always taken it to mean that they’re really asking “Do Objectivists think thus-and-so?” and they just have a hard time differentiating between ideology and the various subscribers to that ideology.
The people I’ve seen asking the question generally seem to fall into one of three groups: people that have only read one book and not bothered to do any more reading before trying to jump in headfirst, people that are looking for ammunition to look down on Objectivists, and people that have a generally difficult time applying abstractions to specific concretes.
The third group is worth all kinds of explaining, the other two not so much.