What? You mean, you have to be an atheist to be happy, but most atheists are unhappy? Or did you mean to say “no”? The second part of your statement doesn’t support your answer. It’s TRUE, it just seems like a non sequitor.
Historically speaking, religious people have been the happier lot. Objectivism is the only philosophy, that I’m aware of, that finally divorces determinism from atheism; previous atheists in history have all inevitably accepted determinism and therefore skepticism, and therefore cynicism; that’s why in history they’ve usually been found out to be pretty rotten individuals.
The whole point behind me saying that atheism in and of itself does not equal virtue is that some people, especially the younger ones, like to go around parading their atheism as a mark of an advanced mind not overtaken by superstition. What they don’t show is the cynicism that rots their soul, but which I’ve always inevitably encountered when dealing with them. Religious people are usually less intellectually vigorous, and more plain and simple-minded, but they are also happier on a fundamental level, because they don’t have to suffer from the baggage that atheism has picked up in its long history as an idea.
That’s why all the outstanding men of heroic caliber, especially in the Enlightenment, treaded that very very fine line between the baggage of atheism and the superstition of Christianity; it is not an accident that they were not full blown atheists, nor something to lament and be upset about. In fact it makes a lot of sense, if the history of atheism, and atheists, is taken into consideration.
It would be more accurate to say that Objectivists don’t have a monopoly on happiness. Objectivism was the first (and only) philosophy to define the purpose of reason and the role of rationality in procuring happiness.
Wow, you’re making extremely sweeping generalizations there. I’d like to know what other philosophies you have studied.
It is not the “best bet” for happiness, it is, in fact, the only fully integrated philosophical method for pursuing happiness, as well as any other values desirable to men on earth.
Pursuing happiness, i.e. one’s rational self-interest, under any other philosophical system is fraught with contradictions and confusions. By any other means, happiness is an accident, a temporary abberation that occurs with no understanding of how it was acheived or how to duplicate it.
Well, with all due respect JMegan, that’s just plain ignorance. If I were to take what you said here seriously, I’d have to accept the notion that everyone, in the entire five thousand year history of human civilization, has been a miserable neurotic with few short glimpses of happiness scattered throughout their hopeless lives, from 4000BC until 1957 AD when Atlas Shrugged was published.
Aristotle and Cicero especially, but many other men too, would have a field day with you.
Aristotle especially would be offended at your notion that Ayn Rand was the first one to link rationality to happiness. In fact she gave that honor (and many others) to him herself.
So again I ask, what other books have you read, and other philosophies have you studied, to back up anything you’ve said here? I’m being kinda harsh in return, but it’s likewise not meant to be personal at all.