To be an O'ist, do you have to be an Atheist?

JMegan, have you read anything by Aristotle? If not, as I suspect, then by what right do you say his bridge didn’t hold up? You’re alone on this, even Ayn Rand acknowledged most of her achievement as standing on Aristotle’s shoulders. But even if we don’t take into account her own admissions about the subject, you cannot go waving around her conclusions and claim them as your own. Whatever her conclusions were, she verified them so she has the right to speak of them with assertiveness. What have you done to verify your conclusions?

You draw the distinction between reading many books and drawing facts from reality - ignoring the enormously ominous deductive and dogmatic implications of that statement - in this discussion the books are the facts of reality. So what you’re saying is that, while you admit you have examined facts pertaining to other issues, you did not examine the facts of reality pertaining to the discussion. Therefore, what you’re saying is that you don’t really know what you’re talking about.

That’s just being obnoxious, but it’s true.

Free Capitalist, I think this is the statement in question here:

Do you have to be an atheist to be a happy person?

…

The answer to the first question is yes. In fact right now in America, it is the atheists who spread the nihilism and the cynicism throughout the culture. Atheism does not equal virtue by any stretch of the imagination.

followed by:

Historically speaking, religious people have been the happier lot.

When I first read this, I assumed that you made a typo and that you intended to type “The answer to the first question is no.” However, when JMeganSnow pointed this contradiction out, you didn’t simply say that it was a typo. Instead, you seemed to try to justify the statement as it is written.

So- why did you say that it is necessary to be an atheist in order to be a happy person, and then go on to say that religious people are not only happy, but that they are the “happier lot”?

JMegan, have you read anything by Aristotle? If not, as I suspect, then by what right do you say his bridge didn’t hold up? You’re alone on this, even Ayn Rand acknowledged most of her achievement as standing on Aristotle’s shoulders.

IIRC Ayn Rand’s major contribution was her creation of the Objectivist epistemology, which finally solved the huge, gaping contradictions in previous epistemologies.

The Objectivist metaphysics is almost entirely derivative (is, I believe, essentially identical to Aristotle’s). However, that crucial flaw in epistemology has been IIRC, the point of attack for pretty much anyone seeking to deny Aristotolean thought.

If you thought Aristotle was absolutely, 100% correct in all respects, you’d be an Aristotlean (is that even a word?) and not an Objectivist. Likewise for any other philosophy. By what other means do you judge a philosophy? I can see judging an author as good if you agree with SOME of his ideas, or a politician as good if you agree with MOST of his policies, but I can’t see calling a philosophical system good unless you agree with ALL of it.

Do you agree with EVERYTHING Aristotle wrote? Cicero? Aquinas? Then how do you judge their philosophy to “stand up”?

Oh, and that bridge analogy was awful, btw. I hate analogies, I shouldn’t use them.

Ok sorry, big big typo, thanks for pointing it out to me!

To rephrase my rhetorical question:

Do you have to be an atheist to be happy? The answer for most of history has been: no. Today, people who are explicitly and avowedly religious are a long long way from the religious men of the Enlightenment (Founding Fathers, etc). So, as I said in a previous post in this thread, being religious in the modern environment will grant you all the benefits that the Founding Fathers derived from it, but will also burden you with the fundamentalism and the irrationalism that modern Christians engage in. Unfortunately there are no Deists any longer, and very few Unitarians. But on the other hand, opposite of empowering but highly dangerous superstition of religion, stands the intellectual and this-worldly but cynical and depressing atheism of determinism. Such has always been the dilemma.

Today, excluding Objectivism, the atheists are more interesting people to talk to, because they’re usually more intellectually inclined, but the religious people are a lot less cynical and nihilistic lot, even if usually simple-minded.

Fortunately, as I said before, today you don’t have to struggle in deciding which of the two will cause you less damage, because there’s Objectivism which combines the positive aspects of both religion and atheism - the objective morality and hero-worship with this-worldliness and the rational mind.


Now about the discussion of Objectivism vs other philosophies.

I am still studying Aristotle’s philosophy, and am currently focusing on the Nicomachean Ethics an Politics. These books are considerably different from Objectivism in their approach to ethical and political questions, not in the sense that they contradict AR’s ideas, but that they approach them from wholly different angles that she did. Still, clearing all confusions and superficial differences away, the two philosophies at least in this respect seem entirely compatible.

So, as it stands now, I consider myself an adherent of both the Objectivist Ethics and the Aristotelian Ethics, at the same time.

The reason we are talking about this is that JMegan claims that until publication of Atlas Shrugged in 1957, the world has been wallowing in misery and neurotic depression for five thousand years of human civilization, and any contributions ancient philosophers like Aristotle and the Stoics made to ethics, and any rational happiness they managed to produce, were merely accidents and nothing that one could reliably reproduce.

This is a statement of enormous ignorance, because it shows complete lack of knowledge both the history and the lives of the ancient Greeks and Romans, and the ideas they adhered to.

Newsflash: the world before AR was not, at first, a mindless Stone Age of brutish men speaking like monkeys and fighting each other with stone clubs, superceded by the malevolent Middle Ages of hideous anti-life philosophy and stifling of everything human. History also records an existence of an ancient civilization which thrived for a THOUSAND years, filled with happy, self-confident, optimistic, heroic men and women whose hearts and minds were filled with moral concerns, hero-worship, and rational living.

Far from being an accidental and primitive state of mind, this view of life was so powerful and so life-giving that it was adopted wholesale by the Europeans in the Middle Ages, eventually resulting in the Rennaissance, and another 500 years of this same kind of noble and admirable existence. And then at the very end, only at the twilight of the West when the old flames were only fading glimmers, there came Ayn Rand and fixed whatever required fixing in order to preserve the fire.

Ayn Rand was not an originator of this sense of life, and she herself often confessed that her original motive fuel was the last remnant of the Western heroic ideal from the 19th and early 20 century, which was inherited from the Enlightenment, which emerged from the Rennaissance, which was sparked exclusively and without exception by the millenium of ancient civilization that by then had become just a memory. In fact Ayn Rand many times said that her primary intention in life was to be a transmission belt of this sense of life to the future generations.

Now, in the face of this historical context which was so sorely missing from this discussion, are you going to tell me that Aristotle was not really ever happy, and if so then only by accident; that George Washington was not really ever happy, and if so then only by accident, and that Ayn Rand invented the notion of reason, and of happiness, out of the blue?

Geez. :thumbsup:

In fact Ayn Rand many times said that her primary intention in life was to be a transmission belt of this sense of life to the future generations.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but her primary intention in life was to be a fiction writer; she didn’t really care too much for “future generations” as she didn’t really care much for “past generations”. She was primarily concerned with her own life for her own purposes in reference to the time of her own existence, and anyone who would benefit from that existence was only an afterthought.

Also, how exactly can you be “adherent” to the ethics of two different philosophies?

Also, how exactly can you be “adherent” to the ethics of two different philosophies?

I think what he means, and FC can correct me if I’m wrong is that the two ethics aren’t mutually exclusive. Objectivism subsumes Aristotles’ ethics and improves upon it; it doesn’t negate his ethics. Another way to think about this is when Einstein introduced special relativity it showed that Newton’s classical mechanics was just a low energy limit to relativity, and classical mechanics still held up in every day situations.

You agree with Aristotle’s Ethics? Well and good. What about his metaphysics? Epistemology? Personally, I like his Esthetics.

I have read very, very few books that I was unable to identify with at least a little. Those were pretty awful books. Likewise, it would have to be a pretty awful philosophy to not contain at least ONE worthwhile idea.

What I have been saying (and not very well in the first post) was that, before Ayn Rand, you could not go down to the bookstore, pick up a book on philosophy, and have in your hands an entire, comprehensible philosophy for living a happy life on this earth. You could obtain volumes of useful information, but it was scattered across a hundred books and mixed with so much absolute GARBAGE that the process of separating the gold from the muck would daunt ANYONE.

Ayn Rand did that, then added the one necessary thing to make it all fit together. Voila, a complete, functional philosophy . . . if one’s goals are happiness and living on this earth.

I did not EVER claim that everyone in history has been unhappy; you supplied that on your own. I claimed, and I repeat myself, that they did not KNOW (i.e. have fully, conceptually integrated) the entirety of the philosophy that is necessary FOR happiness. They may have acted on it. They may have been very happy. However, most likely (I’d say certainly but maybe someone somewhere repeated Ayn Rand’s intellectual feat of conceptual integration and never published it) their avowed philosophy (and not “sense of life”, philosophy) contained some contradictions, which, if they had acted on them fully and consistently would have made them very unhappy indeed.

It is this breach between thought and action, however tiny, that means they were not acting with FULL, EXPLICIT conceptual understanding and renders their happiness, at least in part, an “accident”. Was it completely an accident? No. But any flaw in one’s philosophy leaves one open to the chance that, faced with a choice, you will have to act on or against an internal contradiction, which introduces an element of randomness to your life.

The random, the accidental . . . these are not desirable to a human, they are not characteristics of man acting at his best, most efficient, and most effective.

Also, Objectivists reject faith. If you believe in a god based on faith, then your epistemology is not in line with Objectivism. And if you cling to the arbitrary in the face of irrefutable logic against your god’s existence, then you reject reason as your only source of knowledge, which is also contrary to Objectivism.

I consider myself agnostic because I haven’t seen enough proof of the existence of a god, nor have I seen the “irrefutable logic against [God’s] existence.” You can’t prove that what we know of as the universe isn’t just some fishbowl of an enormous giant. (Or can you?) Doesn’t mean that you should believe in it, but of course it’s possible. It seems like atheism requires a leap of faith since you are saying you know that there is no such thing as a supernatural Daddy. Agnosticism is more like the scientific stance where you say, “I have not seen proof of this so I can’t support it as a valid theory.”

You can’t prove that what we know of as the universe isn’t just some fishbowl of an enormous giant.  (Or can you?)

Actually, I agree. We can’t prove it. But I also can’t prove that little gremlins are hiding under my feet and force me to go everywhere, but that you can’t see them because invisible and can’t touch them. You can’t PROVE such ideas because they are arbitrary. They are outside knowledge, and therefor on the scale of knowledge (false, possible, probable, certain) they aren’t even on it. Such an idea is ARBITRARY and should be immediatly dismissed.

Actually, I agree.  We can’t prove it. 

Even more than that. Not only can we not prove it, it doesn’t have one iota of bearing on one’s life. If such a thing were proven to be true, what would it change? Would you suddenly stop wanting to be happy? Would the facts of existence alter, inverting gravity and flinging us all out into space suddenly from the mere realization of it?

If you wish to conjure up fictional god and super fish bowls, fine. Tell me exactly how their existence would change anything about how I live my life, and I’ll listen.

The fact is, even if such things are true, nothing else we know about the universe will change as a result of it. So the rest of reality, including life, death, and the nature of man, all remain the same in the face of such “possibilities” (even thought they aren’t, actually, since there’s no evidence to even suggest it).

I’m still going to live my life the same way, the only way that is possible to me, in the best way I can manage with what is given to me by reality.

In that context, the context of human life in this universe, any such imaginative question is pointless, and any supposed answer to it is useless. That is why is it arbitrary, and warrants no consideration.

Doesn’t mean that you should believe in it, but of course it’s possible.

“A conclusion is ‘possible’ if there is some, but not much, evidence in favor of it, and nothing known that contradicts it.” (Leonard Peikoff, Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand, p. 176.)

So, what is your evidence that the universe is a giant’s fishbowl?

I consider myself agnostic because I haven’t seen enough proof of the existence of a god, nor have I seen the “irrefutable logic against [God’s] existence.” 

You haven’t seen enough proof? You’ve seen SOME, then? What is it?

I consider myself agnostic because I haven’t seen enough proof of the existence of a god, nor have I seen the “irrefutable logic against [God’s] existence.”  You can’t prove that what we know of as the universe isn’t just some fishbowl of an enormous giant.  (Or can you?)  Doesn’t mean that you should believe in it, but of course it’s possible.  It seems like atheism requires a leap of faith since you are saying you know that there is no such thing as a supernatural Daddy.  Agnosticism is more like the scientific stance where you say, “I have not seen proof of this so I can’t support it as a valid theory.”

“Agnostic” is a popular stance to take these days- especially among intellectual hipsters (I’m not saying is necessarily the case with you).

However, most people use the word “agnostic” to refer to something that is irrational. They use it to imply that there exists a middle ground between theism and atheism. When in reality, there can be no middle ground. Everybody is either a theist or an atheist. This may sound like a surprising claim at first, but think about it.

However, most people use the word “agnostic” to refer to something that is irrational. They use it to imply that there exists a middle ground between theism and atheism. When in reality, there can be no middle ground. Everybody is either a theist or an atheist. This may sound like a surprising claim at first, but think about it.

What’s irrational about saying, “I don’t know and I don’t care”? When it comes to arbitrary questions where there is no proof one way or the other, why bother thinking of them? I don’t give a sh*t (what’s the stance on profanity here?) whether someone believes in a Sky Daddy or Gremlins or Fairies as long as it doesn’t interfere with me. It’s when they try to put a monument up on public land that it becomes something I think about and then just to say, “No monument.”

I see no harm in keeping my mind open to a paradigm shift. Do I think it’s likely that someone can prove the existence of God? No. Am I ready to hear what those people have to say? Sure. I have the suspicion that there’s more going on in the world that science can’t explain yet, and some of these unexplained phenomena will be explained some day. There are billions of people who believe in something supernatural, and maybe they are touching on something we just don’t have an explanation for yet. Before science made it possible to see germs, people thought they were demons. So strange coincidences that seem meaningful and visions of dead people or whatever it is, maybe all these are tied to something that only seems mystical because we don’t have the means to fully perceive it at the moment.

Now things like creationism, where they believe that the earth is only 6000 years old and other BS, no go for me. They have to go through a lot of mental hoops to hold onto these beliefs. If someone believed that God snapped his finger and that started the Big Bang billions of years ago, sure. I don’t care. As long as it doesn’t affect me, you can believe there’s some f*cking invisible monster pulling our strings.

I think the flaw in thinking is those who are too dogmatic. If you are a devout Atheist, you are just being dogmatic about your unbeliefs. I never understood Atheist clubs where they get together and talk about how God doesn’t exist. What a waste of time: The Anti-Church.

What’s irrational about saying, “I don’t know and I don’t care”?

You misconstrued what I actually said. What I actually said (make sure you comprehend what was said before you attempt to comment on it) was that the reason why the common notion of “agnostic” is irrational is because it refers to somebody being neither theist nor atheist- and that isn’t possible. Everybody is either a theist or an atheist. There is no middle ground.

When it comes to arbitrary questions where there is no proof one way or the other, why bother thinking of them?

It’s not a matter of “questions” here. It’s a matter of allegations to the truth. A theist is somebody who holds a belief in God. An atheist is somebody who is without theism, or, somebody who is without a belief in God.

If you feel that there is a middle ground between these two catagories (I’m assuming you do, since you called yourself “agnostic”), then please give me an example of how somebody could be neither a theist nor an atheist. Describe to me how it is possible to neither believe in something nor not believe in it.

I see no harm in keeping my mind open to a paradigm shift…

At this point you begin to babble on about subjects that don’t relate to anything I said.

What’s irrational about saying, “I don’t know and I don’t care”? 

You don’t live in a vacuum, or on a deserted island, so you don’t get to not care. Plus, if you didn’t care, you wouldn’t be reading this thread and you definitely wouldn’t be posting in it :frowning:

Besides, accepting the existence of god(s) or not has very real consequences for the individual. You will live your life differently, utilizing different premises, depending on which way you go. Those who accept god(s) live for the afterlife, to please their god(s), etc… whereas, those who reject the notion live for this life, in this universe, on this planet.

And you know this, so to claim that you don’t care means that you don’t care if you live your life by any particular principles whatsoever. We are talking about the choice of the primary purpose of one’s life – and to say you don’t care about that leaves you twisting in the wind, directionless and with no ultimate goal to seek. In this regard I have far more respect for consistent, principled theists than drifting, uncertain, unprincipled, fuzzily-brained agnostics.

When it comes to arbitrary questions where there is no proof one way or the other, why bother thinking of them?  I don’t give a sh*t (what’s the stance on profanity here?) whether someone believes in a Sky Daddy or Gremlins or Fairies as long as it doesn’t interfere with me.

There’s the rub. It always interferes with you to the extent to which the theist lives his life by his religion’s principles. Most are heavily compartmentalized, but there is some negative effect, always.

I have the suspicion that there’s more going on in the world that science can’t explain yet, and some of these unexplained phenomena will be explained some day.

That’s more than a suspicion, its a fact. Otherwise, we’d have a cure for every disease now known and yet to evolve, forever (as an example). The theists always argue “by design”, and its getting old, at least for me. The false dichotomy of universe by design or universe by chance throws the truth out the window as a non-option. That truth (and the option they do not consider) is: the law of causality.

There are billions of people who believe in something supernatural

If billions of people jumped off a cliff, would you jump?

Good, then don’t. Because they are, they just don’t know it.

Before science made it possible to see germs, people thought they were demons.  So strange coincidences that seem meaningful and visions of dead people or whatever it is, maybe all these are tied to something that only seems mystical because we don’t have the means to fully perceive it at the moment.

For someone who “doesn’t give a sh*t”, you sure put a lot of effort into thinking about this :frowning:

I think the flaw in thinking is those who are too dogmatic.  If you are a devout Atheist, you are just being dogmatic about your unbeliefs.

Dogmatism is bad, to be certain. You’ll get no argument from Objectivists on that point.

However, our atheism is not dogmatic. We do not have a list of things we must believe, that includes atheism. There is no “10 commandments of Objectivism”. There isn’t even one commandment.

The fact is that while you can’t prove a negative, and hence cannot prove that god(s) do not exist, you can validate it by comparison to all other knowledge gained by starting with the statement “existence exists” and going forward rationally from there (i.e. Objectivism).

For example: if god(s) exist, then existence does not have primacy over consciousness, and all conclusions based upon that premise (just about all knowledge, including the concept “proof”!) are all actually flawed.

Describe to me how it is possible to neither believe in something nor not believe in it.

You can reserve drawing a conclusion until sufficient evidence is obtained to order to be reasonably certain you are making the right choice. I do this every day, and so does every human being I’ve ever met.

This doesn’t mean you can avoid drawing a conclusion forever, though. You still have to choose if you want to move forward, and this is such a basic question with such far-reaching consequences to one’s life that most people actually make the choice implicitly, even if they are explicitly “undecided”.

I’ve always thought of Atheists as the people I mentioned earlier, with a devout, dogmatic view of the non-existence of God. To me, that’s as silly as its opposite. When defined in the dichotomy of “believes” or “doesn’t believe,” then I’m surely an Atheist. But I’m always open to be proven wrong.

For someone who “doesn’t give a sh*t”, you sure put a lot of effort into thinking about this :frowning:

:frowning: I like to think about abstractions.

You misconstrued what I actually said. What I actually said (make sure you comprehend what was said before you attempt to comment on it) was that the reason why the common notion of “agnostic” is irrational is because it refers to somebody being neither theist nor atheist- and that isn’t possible. Everybody is either a theist or an atheist. There is no middle ground.

It’s not a matter of “questions” here. It’s a matter of allegations to the truth. A theist is somebody who holds a belief in God. An atheist is somebody who is without theism, or, somebody who is without a belief in God.

If you feel that there is a middle ground between these two catagories (I’m assuming you do, since you called yourself “agnostic”), then please give me an example of how somebody could be neither a theist nor an atheist. Describe to me how it is possible to neither believe in something nor not believe in it.

At this point you begin to babble on about subjects that don’t relate to anything I said.

Call it what you want, but its a valid argument.

All of the following come from dictionary.com:

ag·nos·tic  (g-nstk)

n.

1.      a. One who believes that it is impossible to know whether there is a God.

          b. One who is skeptical about the existence of God but does not profess true atheism.

Word History: An agnostic does not deny the existence of God and heaven but holds that one cannot know for certain whether or not they exist. The term agnostic was fittingly coined by the 19th-century British scientist Thomas H. Huxley, who believed that only material phenomena were objects of exact knowledge. He made up the word from the prefix a-, meaning “without, not,” as in amoral, and the noun Gnostic. Gnostic is related to the Greek word gnsis, “knowledge,” which was used by early Christian writers to mean “higher, esoteric knowledge of spiritual things” hence, Gnostic referred to those with such knowledge. In coining the term agnostic, Huxley was considering as “Gnostics” a group of his fellow intellectuals“ists,” as he called them who had eagerly embraced various doctrines or theories that explained the world to their satisfaction. Because he was a “man without a rag of a label to cover himself with,” Huxley coined the term agnostic for himself, its first published use being in 1870.

Quite different from…

a·the·ism (th-zm)

n.

1.      a. Disbelief in or denial of the existence of God or gods.

        b. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

2.      Godlessness; immorality.

the·ism   (thzm)

n.

Belief in the existence of a god or gods, especially belief in a personal God as creator and ruler of the world.

Simply applying an “either-or” condition to your argument does not refute the ideas that agnosticism expresses. The way I see it, agnosticism is a tangent that Huxley derived from the ideas of theism and atheism, and expanded it into his own interpretation. How can you, through reason, arrive at a conclusion that your lack of beliefs in the existence of a god (or gods) is true? You do not believe in god, therefore it must be true that a god does not exist? This is how I see your argument, and it simply isn’t true. By observing definiton “b” as stated above in the agnostic entry, one must refer to the definition of atheism, as stated in the definition. By the stated definition of atheism, atheism is one who holds the doctrine that there is no god (or gods).

I think what he means, and FC can correct me if I’m wrong is that the two ethics aren’t mutually exclusive. Objectivism subsumes Aristotles’ ethics and improves upon it

I know what you’re trying to say; however, Objectivist ethics don’t entirely subsume Aristotle’s, and make the latter irrelevant. There is a significant overlap, particularly in the fundamentals, but Aristotle covers some things AR doesn’t, and similarly she covers things he doesn’t. It would be wrong to say that Ayn Rand covers everything important from Aristotle, and as I’ve said in other places, there are things I have found in Aristotle that I sorely wished Ayn Rand would talk about.