Ok sorry, big big typo, thanks for pointing it out to me!
To rephrase my rhetorical question:
Do you have to be an atheist to be happy? The answer for most of history has been: no. Today, people who are explicitly and avowedly religious are a long long way from the religious men of the Enlightenment (Founding Fathers, etc). So, as I said in a previous post in this thread, being religious in the modern environment will grant you all the benefits that the Founding Fathers derived from it, but will also burden you with the fundamentalism and the irrationalism that modern Christians engage in. Unfortunately there are no Deists any longer, and very few Unitarians. But on the other hand, opposite of empowering but highly dangerous superstition of religion, stands the intellectual and this-worldly but cynical and depressing atheism of determinism. Such has always been the dilemma.
Today, excluding Objectivism, the atheists are more interesting people to talk to, because they’re usually more intellectually inclined, but the religious people are a lot less cynical and nihilistic lot, even if usually simple-minded.
Fortunately, as I said before, today you don’t have to struggle in deciding which of the two will cause you less damage, because there’s Objectivism which combines the positive aspects of both religion and atheism - the objective morality and hero-worship with this-worldliness and the rational mind.
Now about the discussion of Objectivism vs other philosophies.
I am still studying Aristotle’s philosophy, and am currently focusing on the Nicomachean Ethics an Politics. These books are considerably different from Objectivism in their approach to ethical and political questions, not in the sense that they contradict AR’s ideas, but that they approach them from wholly different angles that she did. Still, clearing all confusions and superficial differences away, the two philosophies at least in this respect seem entirely compatible.
So, as it stands now, I consider myself an adherent of both the Objectivist Ethics and the Aristotelian Ethics, at the same time.
The reason we are talking about this is that JMegan claims that until publication of Atlas Shrugged in 1957, the world has been wallowing in misery and neurotic depression for five thousand years of human civilization, and any contributions ancient philosophers like Aristotle and the Stoics made to ethics, and any rational happiness they managed to produce, were merely accidents and nothing that one could reliably reproduce.
This is a statement of enormous ignorance, because it shows complete lack of knowledge both the history and the lives of the ancient Greeks and Romans, and the ideas they adhered to.
Newsflash: the world before AR was not, at first, a mindless Stone Age of brutish men speaking like monkeys and fighting each other with stone clubs, superceded by the malevolent Middle Ages of hideous anti-life philosophy and stifling of everything human. History also records an existence of an ancient civilization which thrived for a THOUSAND years, filled with happy, self-confident, optimistic, heroic men and women whose hearts and minds were filled with moral concerns, hero-worship, and rational living.
Far from being an accidental and primitive state of mind, this view of life was so powerful and so life-giving that it was adopted wholesale by the Europeans in the Middle Ages, eventually resulting in the Rennaissance, and another 500 years of this same kind of noble and admirable existence. And then at the very end, only at the twilight of the West when the old flames were only fading glimmers, there came Ayn Rand and fixed whatever required fixing in order to preserve the fire.
Ayn Rand was not an originator of this sense of life, and she herself often confessed that her original motive fuel was the last remnant of the Western heroic ideal from the 19th and early 20 century, which was inherited from the Enlightenment, which emerged from the Rennaissance, which was sparked exclusively and without exception by the millenium of ancient civilization that by then had become just a memory. In fact Ayn Rand many times said that her primary intention in life was to be a transmission belt of this sense of life to the future generations.
Now, in the face of this historical context which was so sorely missing from this discussion, are you going to tell me that Aristotle was not really ever happy, and if so then only by accident; that George Washington was not really ever happy, and if so then only by accident, and that Ayn Rand invented the notion of reason, and of happiness, out of the blue?
Geez. 