To be an O'ist, do you have to be an Atheist?

You can reserve drawing a conclusion until sufficient evidence is obtained to order to be reasonably certain you are making the right choice.  I do this every day, and so does every human being I’ve ever met.

Reserving drawing a conclusion doesn’t exclude you from that which is described by one of the two terms. If your inability to draw a conclusion results in you not having a positive belief in God, then you are an atheist.

Consider this example;

A man is born onto a deserted island. He never even hears of the concept of God, let alone holds a belief in God. This man is an atheist. He is without theism (a positive belief in God).

(My use of the word “positive” in this response doesn’t mean “certain” or “good”. It is used to differentiate between “theism,” which is a postive claim, and “atheism,” which describes a negative.)

Call it what you want, but its a valid argument.

No, the argument was out of context. It didn’t respond to what I said. I was criticizing “agnosticism” as the position that there is a middle-ground between theism and atheist, which isn’t true.

All of the following come from dictionary.com:

This, too, is out of context. I mentioned multiple times that I was criticizing the definition of “agnosticism” as used by most people. As I explained, this definition is different than the one you felt the need to quote from the dictionary. If the point you were trying to make is that the definition of “agnocticism” that most people use is different than the one in the dictionary, then I agree. But this was not my argument. If you want to disprove the argument I actually made, instead of making straw-men, then you can prove how it is possible for somebody to be neither a theist nor an atheist.

Simply applying an “either-or” condition to your argument does not refute the ideas that agnosticism expresses.

I wasn’t merely “applying” the condition. The existence of the condition is the entirety of my argument. And again- I was never attempting to refute the definition as it is written in the dictionary. I expressed the usage of the term “agnosticism” that I was refuting (as it is commonly used). Altering my premises to the point that they no longer support the conclusion I made, showing that the new premises do not support the conclusion, and then declaring me wrong is fallacious logic.

The way I see it, agnosticism is a tangent that Huxley derived from the ideas of theism and atheism, and expanded it into his own interpretation.

Once again- my argument is focused on the term as it is most commonly used. I pointed out the definition in question, and why it is irrational. The fact that you see the definition as being something different is irrelevant to the discussion. It doesn’t prove anything I have said to be wrong, because my argument wasn’t focused on the definition as you see it.

How can you, through reason, arrive at a conclusion that your lack of beliefs in the existence of a god (or gods) is true?

What is the question? How do I know that it’s true that I lack a belief in God? How do I know that God doesn’t exist?

You do not believe in god, therefore it must be true that a god does not exist? This is how I see your argument, and it simply isn’t true.

No, I never said anything like that. I never said that the fact that I don’t believe in God proves that God doesn’t exist. That is subjectivism. I don’t understand why you would see my argument that way. Please quote me from when I said that reality is subjective and that my disbelief in God proves that God doesn’t exist.

It would be more beneficial if you responded to direct quotes of mine. That way my argument can be shown as it really is, instead of as it is after being mangled by your poor cognitive skils.

By the stated definition of atheism, atheism is one who holds the doctrine that there is no god (or gods).

I disagree with this definition. I derive the definition from a more etymological standpoint, instead of a mere quote of the dictionary. The word “theism” means “the belief in God,” and the preffix “a” means “without.”

Using the proper definition, a person doesn’t even have to have heard of God in order to be an atheist (as shown in my deserted island example).

Objectivists are no strangers to using definitions that are rational yet different than those listed in the dictionary.

Ayn Rand was not an originator of this sense of life, and she herself often confessed that her original motive fuel was the last remnant of the Western heroic ideal from the 19th and early 20 century, which was inherited from the Enlightenment, which emerged from the Rennaissance, which was sparked exclusively and without exception by the millenium of ancient civilization that by then had become just a memory. In fact Ayn Rand many times said that her primary intention in life was to be a transmission belt of this sense of life to the future generations.

[bold added for emphasis.]

What are some examples of passages where she said this?

Call it what you want, but its a valid argument.

Thank you. According to the everyday usage of the definitions, I’m agnostic. According to the either-or dichotomy that has been presented here, I’m atheist. Semantics.

You draw the distinction between reading many books and drawing facts from reality - ignoring the enormously ominous deductive and dogmatic implications of that statement - in this discussion the books are the facts of reality.

You know what’s scary, is I’ve heard eerily similar statements from fundamentalist christians.

Thank you.  According to the everyday usage of the definitions, I’m agnostic.  According to the either-or dichotomy that has been presented here, I’m atheist.  Semantics.

Your “semantics” are what create misunderstandings and cause wars. For example, the “everyday” definition of selfishness is stepping on other people’s toes in order to get what you want. Of course, this is neither the dictionary definition nor the logical definition of the word. However, I have been told many times that the ideas of Objectivism lead to the “Enrons of the world” because people don’t logically understand their terms.

To quote from Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology:

An objective definition, valid for all men, is one that designates the essential distinguishing characteristic(s) and genus of the existents subsumed under a given concept–according to all the relevant knowledge available at that stage of mankind’s development.

So what is the genus of the concept “agnosticism?” We cannot classify agnosticism with atheism and theism easily because those two are systems of belief (or non-belief). They are antonyms to each other. Agnosticism does not profess to know or not know something. It is not a “system of knowledge” like atheism and theism are.

You see, agnosticism comes from the philosophy of Skepticism, the philosophy which holds that nothing can be proven or disproven. So, we can define agnosticism as “the belief that knowledge is beyond the range of the human mind.” Why did I choose this definition? Essentially, that is the epistemeolgical judgement that an agnostic makes when he allows the arbitrary into the realm of cognition.

If your friend told you that gremlins were stealing his food, you would not say, “Well, I can’t disprove you, so I will keep an open mind in the matter.” The arbitrary must be dismissed out of hand. You cannot just say, “I don’t know.” Remember, in logic, the burden of proof is on the person making the claim. You don’t have to disprove every superstition which comes along to not believe in it.

In summary, definitions should be obtained objectively and logically and should not be accepted simply because of “common usage” or usage in the dictionary.

Further reading: Leonard Peikoff has two good articles on atheism and agnosticism in The Ayn Rand Lexicon. You also may wish to read the article on “Open Mind” and “Closed Mind.”

From what I can tell, you don’t need to be an atheist to be an objectivist. You only need to throw the notion that God/ higher power/supernatural has anything to do with your life.

I like a lot of these ideas, but subscribing to only one philosophy, and only one set of books is really no different from religion. Maybe I missed something in those books, but I don’t live my life according to Ayn Rand, I live it according to me.

Thank you.  According to the everyday usage of the definitions, I’m agnostic.  According to the either-or dichotomy that has been presented here, I’m atheist.  Semantics.

Do you not disagree that everybody is either a theist or an atheist? That “agnostic” may be a description, but it is not a category seperate from theism or atheism?

If you think it’s a false dichotomy then tell me why.

From what I can tell, you don’t need to be an atheist to be an objectivist.  You only need to throw the notion that God/ higher power/supernatural has anything to do with your life. 

Your statement is completely incorrect. You do need to be an atheist in order to be an Objectivist. The belief in a god is completely contradictory to many of the tenents of Objectivism, which has been pointed out many times on this thread.

I like a lot of these ideas, but subscribing to only one philosophy, and only one set of books is really no different from religion.  Maybe I missed something in those books, but I don’t live my life according to Ayn Rand, I live it according to me.

Well, your essential attitude is a good one to have, but how is believing one philosophy no different from religion? Can you believe in Kant and Aristotle at the same time?

The dichotomy you seem to not be making is between your own philosophy and those of others. Every man has his own philosophy. Ayn Rand called hers “Objectivism.” (This should be spelled with a capital “O” by the way.) You have the choice to rationally prove or disprove her philosophy or to evade the subject completly. Those of us who are Objectivists have rationally evaluated her philosophy and believe it to be correct on all essential points. However, we don’t close ourselves to any further progress. For example, Leonard Peikoff is currently working on some theories in induction which could revolutionize our understanding of it. These theories will no doubt be valuable to Objectivists. However, his theories will not be a part of Objectivism because they are a part of his philosophy, not Ayn Rand’s.

From what I can tell, you don’t need to be an atheist to be an objectivist.  You only need to throw the notion that God/ higher power/supernatural has anything to do with your life. 

What do you mean when you use the term “Objectivism”? (I’ll capitalize it, because I’m assumg that’s what you meant.) It would seem that you use the term to refer to something other than “the philosophy of Ayn Rand.”

How do you hold a belief in the supernatural without rejecting Objectivist metaphysics?

To say this another way: assume that existence exists on its own and without regard to consciousness; what purpose could God then have in the universe?  When you see that there is none, you see that the very idea of God is arbitrary, and must be disregarded without further consideration.

This is what I was getting at. Whether or not there is a god, it doesn’t have any bearing on this philosophy (sorry for not capitilizing your little word), All that’s being said is that if there was a creating force it has no bearing on the world now.

This is what I was getting at.  Whether or not there is a god, it doesn’t have any bearing on this philosophy (sorry for not capitilizing your little word), All that’s being said is that if there was a creating force it has no bearing on the world now.

It has everything to do with the philosophy. If you believe in a god, you are accepting that belief on faith since we both agree that the term is arbitrary. Faith is the opposite of reason. Reason is what Objectivism holds to be mans sole source of knowledge (see Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology). If you believe in faith, you do not believe reason is man’s sole source of knowledge.

Likewise in metaphysics. A belief in a god says that the supernatural exsists. However, that is the opposite of what Objectivism says. Objectivism says that there is no such thing as the supernatural. A is A. The supernatural would be something other than the natural.

From what I can tell, you don’t need to be an atheist to be an objectivist.  You only need to throw the notion that God/ higher power/supernatural has anything to do with your life. 

Objectivism holds that reason is man’s only means of gaining knowledge. So, the things that must be “thrown out” are all those beliefs that require the suspension of reason, i.e. all those notions that must be accepted on faith. Such notions include God, ghosts, witches, warlocks, the supernatural, etc.

I like a lot of these ideas, but subscribing to only one philosophy, and only one set of books is really no different from religion.  Maybe I missed something in those books, but I don’t live my life according to Ayn Rand, I live it according to me.

Religion is a primitive form of philosophy. It is an attempt to give men a comprehensive view of life by postulating the existence of a supernatural being that created existence and defines the rules to live by.

Objectivism rejects religion because it rejects faith and acknowledges that reality exists independent of the content of anyone’s consciousness, including god’s. This is a fundamental difference that cannot be dismissed on the grounds that both religion and Objectivism are described by “one set of books.”

What do you know about Objectivism? What have you read?

What do you know about Objectivism?  What have you read?

Very little. Mainly just this thread, which is probably why I’m so confused, because, it seems that even most of you don’t agree.

I’ve read “Anthem,”“Atlas Shrugged,” and I’ve begun “The Virtue of Selfishness,” and “The Fountainhead.”

and many, many Neil Peart Lyrics.

Very little.  Mainly just this thread, which is probably why I’m so confused, because, it seems that even most of you don’t agree. 

I’ve read “Anthem,”“Atlas Shrugged,”  and I’ve begun “The Virtue of Selfishness,” and “The Fountainhead.”

and many, many Neil Peart Lyrics.

If you have read “Atlas Shrugged”, you have read more than “very little”.

What is it that you are confused about?

For example, Leonard Peikoff is currently working on some theories in induction which could revolutionize our understanding of it. These theories will no doubt be valuable to Objectivists. However, his theories will not be a part of Objectivism because they are a part of his philosophy, not Ayn Rand’s.

Really? So, no one can add anything new to Objectivism? A lot of Objectivist intellectuals expand on certain points, add extra info etc. They aren’t changing the substance of Objectivism, they are extrapolating/clarifying etc.

I could see that if someone writes something based on Objectivist principles that isn’t part of philosophy per se (such as the book Kevin Delaney is working on) it could be considered an Objectivist book, but not part of Objectivism, but OPAR was written entirely by Leonard Peikoff and it is very much a part of Objectivism (in fact, it’s the major presentation of Objectivism).

I’m just thinking there’s a difference between small acts of fine-tuning and going off to work in an entirely different area.

Very little.  Mainly just this thread, which is probably why I’m so confused, because, it seems that even most of you don’t agree. 

We agree on the essentials (generally), what we tend to disagree about is the nitty-gritty applications. Objectivism is a broad, abstract guide, and even if we all understood and agreed with it equally we’d STILL disagree about application because applying abstract principles is based on context and we all have different lives and thus, different context.

That was rather a run-on sentence. Oh well.

Very little.  Mainly just this thread, which is probably why I’m so confused, because, it seems that even most of you don’t agree. 

I don’t see why you’d be confused. Multiple people now have explained why theism contradicts Objectivism. Try asking specific questions on subjects that confuse you.

Really?  So, no one can add anything new to Objectivism?  A lot of Objectivist intellectuals expand on certain points, add extra info etc.  They aren’t changing the substance of Objectivism, they are extrapolating/clarifying etc.

That’s correct. Nobody can add anything new to Objectivism. Peter Schwartz addressed this issue in the Q&A portion of his recent Ayn Rand Centenary speech. Objectivism is the philosophy of Ayn Rand. An Objectivist theory is “Objectivist” necessarily because she created it- not necessarily because it can be derived from the axiom that A is A. Extrapolating and clarifying is different than adding.

Ok, I am new to objectivism having just recently finished Atlas Shrugged (so please be kind! :stuck_out_tongue: ) but I was wondering, to be an Objectivist do you have to be an atheist? Can you believe in some sort of higher power and still be an objectivist?

I ask because my mother, who introduced me to Ayn Rand, is catholic and still considers herself an objectivist, yet Rand herself was an atheist along with most other objectivist.

That can only come from a person who has never really given any serious thought to either Objectivism or religion, and people who do not think about what they choose to accept as true cannot be called Objectivists. So, yes; your mother may not know it, but she is being dishonest.

The most difficult thing to explain to a non-thinking person, is the neccessity of thought. And I don’t mean some random thought, but an active, focused, consciouss thinking. In Objectivism, THAT, along with embracing its principles, is the most important demand.

Merging religion and Objectivism is an act of either a non-thinking person, or of a person who rejects some of Objectivist principles. The former is lazy, go-with-the-flow kind of man, the latter is dishonest.