Call it what you want, but its a valid argument.
No, the argument was out of context. It didn’t respond to what I said. I was criticizing “agnosticism” as the position that there is a middle-ground between theism and atheist, which isn’t true.
All of the following come from dictionary.com:
This, too, is out of context. I mentioned multiple times that I was criticizing the definition of “agnosticism” as used by most people. As I explained, this definition is different than the one you felt the need to quote from the dictionary. If the point you were trying to make is that the definition of “agnocticism” that most people use is different than the one in the dictionary, then I agree. But this was not my argument. If you want to disprove the argument I actually made, instead of making straw-men, then you can prove how it is possible for somebody to be neither a theist nor an atheist.
Simply applying an “either-or” condition to your argument does not refute the ideas that agnosticism expresses.
I wasn’t merely “applying” the condition. The existence of the condition is the entirety of my argument. And again- I was never attempting to refute the definition as it is written in the dictionary. I expressed the usage of the term “agnosticism” that I was refuting (as it is commonly used). Altering my premises to the point that they no longer support the conclusion I made, showing that the new premises do not support the conclusion, and then declaring me wrong is fallacious logic.
The way I see it, agnosticism is a tangent that Huxley derived from the ideas of theism and atheism, and expanded it into his own interpretation.
Once again- my argument is focused on the term as it is most commonly used. I pointed out the definition in question, and why it is irrational. The fact that you see the definition as being something different is irrelevant to the discussion. It doesn’t prove anything I have said to be wrong, because my argument wasn’t focused on the definition as you see it.
How can you, through reason, arrive at a conclusion that your lack of beliefs in the existence of a god (or gods) is true?
What is the question? How do I know that it’s true that I lack a belief in God? How do I know that God doesn’t exist?
You do not believe in god, therefore it must be true that a god does not exist? This is how I see your argument, and it simply isn’t true.
No, I never said anything like that. I never said that the fact that I don’t believe in God proves that God doesn’t exist. That is subjectivism. I don’t understand why you would see my argument that way. Please quote me from when I said that reality is subjective and that my disbelief in God proves that God doesn’t exist.
It would be more beneficial if you responded to direct quotes of mine. That way my argument can be shown as it really is, instead of as it is after being mangled by your poor cognitive skils.
By the stated definition of atheism, atheism is one who holds the doctrine that there is no god (or gods).
I disagree with this definition. I derive the definition from a more etymological standpoint, instead of a mere quote of the dictionary. The word “theism” means “the belief in God,” and the preffix “a” means “without.”
Using the proper definition, a person doesn’t even have to have heard of God in order to be an atheist (as shown in my deserted island example).
Objectivists are no strangers to using definitions that are rational yet different than those listed in the dictionary.