Why Objectivism

So ultimately, is it up to me to determine what is right and wrong? I assume that truth is relative in objectivism.

Those two sentences contradict each other. If truth was relative, why would there be a need to determine it? You could just make it up and call it “my truth”.

Guru

p.s. O bjectivism

Why not be moral?

What’s more virtuous, doing what’s moral because of fear of being held liable by god(s) or doing it because you think it is right?

I can’t explain every reason I do what I do, and what I consider immoral or moral but I can give you a few examples.

There’s are unwritten/written rules or contracts I accept with society and I hope society accepts with me.

I will not murder in hopes that I will not be murdered. What good is a contract if I don’t abide by it? I also do not murder because of the personal trouble it may put me through. I don’t think the risk/cost is worth the reward. Also, if it came down to it I would probably kill someone if I put in an unreasonable situation, such as self defense, in which case I am protecting myself from someone attempting to violate or is violating the contracts of society… I have more reasons of why I would not normally murder but this should suffice.

I also try to treat others the way I like to be treated. I don’t like to be hypocrite, but if anyone violates that rule I don’t have issues violating it with them.

So ultimately, is it up to me to determine what is right and wrong?

Here are some examples: it is not right to murder a person; it is right for you you survive and flourish. These aren’t things you need to determine. It is up to you to discover what is right and wrong – the word ‘determine’ is vague in this context, so let’s use more precise wording. Right and wrong are evaluations of actions in terms of furthering a purpose, specifically your existence qua man. Poison is objectively bad because it kills you, food is good because it sustains you, so taking poison is wrong and eating food is right. These are basic, universal facts. However, it is also the case that some people are highly allergic to peanuts so some food is bad, and similarly sunlight is generally good for people but it’s not good for albinos. On a less dire scale, music is generally good for a person, but which music is good will depend on the person. I don’t understand why, but some people actually like Dido, so for then, listening to Dido would be good.

It is good for people to work and be productive. But that does not mean that all people should build stereos as their form of productivity. You have to discover what career is best for your life – maybe it’s being a poet, maybe a lawyer, a race-car driver, an accountant, or a welder. I could tell you to become a lawyer and make lots of money (I can hear the law guys laughing), but that may not be right for your life, and perhaps you’re more into emotive expression and you should be a painter (portrait, not house). You have to discover those facts about yourself.

You need a hierarchy of knowledge and values to be able to make the right choice. Facts exist in relation to other facts, so if you say “Yes, I want to be a lion tamer!” and “Yes, I want to be rich!”, then you have to find the best way to implement those goals, and decide which is more important. If being a lion tamer is really your highest priority and you only have an incidental interest in money, it would be irrational to quit your lion taming job to take an accounting job that paid $10,000 a year more. But you have to discover those facts about yourself. Maybe you really are more interested in accounting, and just misunderstood your nature.

Ok - this is starting to congeal for me a little better.

Now, how about this situation. What if you had a group of people, all of whom had no aversions to committing murder. Would it thereby be “ok” for them to murder one another. I’m assuming that it would not violate any moral code if each of them had a “pre-existing” contract with their society (made up entirely of murderers).

Thanks everyone for your responses and for postulating with me.

That is subjectivism. Wrong forum. :wink:

Seriously, the test of a moral code is not wether it violates someone else’s moral code. Or am I misunderstanding you?

That is subjectivism. Wrong forum. :wink:

Seriously, the test of a moral code is not wether it violates someone else’s moral code. Or am I misunderstanding you?

Subjectivism huh - that makes sense actually - haha

I think you are understanding me, I guess I’m just so used to thinking in terms of there being an overarching moral code imposed by a 3rd party (government / church). I’m trying to find the source for doing what most people would consider right and not doing what most people would consider wrong. It sounds like, I treat others the way I would like them to treat me because it benefits me, which I understand.

But, the peice I don’t understand is, why would we punish “criminals” if a nation were governed by an objectivist standpoint?

Does my confusion make sense?

Like, let’s say I really feel no sense of remorse for any “wrong” action I might take (murder, rape, arson, etc) is it still wrong for me to do those things under the objectivist way of thinking? Is it wrong because it hurts the motives of society? Or is it wrong because it’s just wrong and everyone agrees that those things are wrong?

Like, let’s say I really feel no sense of remorse for any “wrong” action I might take (murder, rape, arson, etc) is it still wrong for me to do those things under the objectivist way of thinking? Is it wrong because it hurts the motives of society? Or is it wrong because it’s just wrong and everyone agrees that those things are wrong?

Well, that still has elements of relativism in it. It is a very common mistake. Think of it from three different perspectives.

  1. The truth is relative to me. My truth isn’t your truth. My ethics are not your ethics. This is the subjectivist view point.

  2. The truth just is. God told me it was. Society says it is. Whatever. I can’t explain it. It just is. Everyone has the same truth, and it looks an awful lot like a set of commandments.

  3. The truth and ethics derive from the facts of reality and the requirements of mans survival. Everyone’s truth is the same, but the facts of reality differ in each case. That is, there is context to factor in. Given the same context, the truth is the same, but reality tells you the context, so all variations on ethics are contextual, not relative or absolute.

1 is subjectivism

2 is intrinsicism

3 is Objectivism

Does that help?

Why should man survive?

Why should man survive?

In general that is an question with a complex answer.

The short answer is it is man’s survival which creates the “should”. The choice to survive is therefore “pre-should”. That is, given man’s choice to survive, ethics comes into being, because _ value _ comes into being. Survival qua man is the standard of value.

Net effect is, if you don’t want to survive, then don’t. It is an amoral choice. But given your choice to survive as man, then you have set the basis for value, and thus ethics.

the more i think about it, the more it appears to be subjectivism. Rather, the more I think about it, the more subjectivism seems to be objectivism. Or maybe I’ve always practiced objectivism and just didnt know it had a name. For example, awhile ago, when i was depressed beyond words, I thought about suicide, but to me suicide is stupid because death offers nothing and life offers opportunity. But I also picked up a bad habit of cutting myself. I was wondering one day what made it “wrong” to cut myself? Why was it a big deal when I had no intentions of taking my life, and I washed the knife i used in soap and water? I realized there is no “wrong” or “right” in that scenario. In africa, many tribes practice self-mutilation as a right of passage, and indeed, I thought of my scars more as a reminder to live and not forget next time that I’ve been through these things before. Here in the states its taboo. Either or view is subjective on the matter, but I’m thinking my “objectivism” is the ability to see all subjective frames and realize when and why certain ones were appropriate. If I’m right, then I have a new word for my pre-existing philosophies, but I would still hesitate to associate myself with a leader-figure.

I midnightrequiem,

First off, I’m sorry to hear about your bout with depression. I hope that you were able to resolve it or deal with it effectively.

Second, your analysis is really not in line with Objectivism. Could I ask what you know about the philosophy? What books have you read of Rand’s? How did you find the forum and what is your intent here. It might help me understand a little bit about how you mean what you mean.

Objectivism is not subjectivism. The rationalization of the habit you describe is not an Objective analysis. I feel for your situation, but if you are looking for something to help you rationalize what you already think about things, then that would not be Objectivism.

I’m doing fine. I wasn’t rationalizing my habit, I denounce it personally. I just noted that “right” and “wrong” is very subjective and attached mostly to societal norms. I found this site by a fluke. I was bored and looking up what people thought was the “worst moment in history” because I wanted to see how many people actually think it was 9/11, and I found a link taking me to a discussion on this forum. I was under the false impression that this site was dedicate to debate under the idea of “objectivity” like in journalism. This wasn’t disappointing though because I found most of the people’s comments and discussions to be intellectually stimulating (which I love… except this one on whether or not we should just nuke tehran haha that was just funny). Then I dug further until I realized what Objectivism, and not Objectivity, was.

I have read nothing, nor do I really intend to, besides ask questions. If the main goal of Objectivism is that every person’s life goal is the pursuit of one’s own happiness, then we agree. My philosophy is based on that single idea 1) reaching contentment, the state where one is happy with one’s self, their surroundings and how they interact with those surroundings. Everything else I call my “sub-philosophy” because I think most things are subjective (which would be my difference). My idea is that reality exists apart from our perception, but we have nothing else to draw from except our perception which is incomplete; basically it doesn’t matter what is “real” because whatever you believe is what will run your life.

I know that my knowledge is largely incomplete, but I have noticed some trends, at least on some posts here. The objectivists seem to take on the persona of Ayn Rand. She grew up in a Communist society, so from a psychological standpoint, it seems logical that she would denounce Communism and its little brother socialism. I myself am a socialist of sorts, but not of the Communist variety, more along the lines of the hopelessly unrealistic utopian socialists, pre-marxist socialism haha. I know, it won’t happen, so realistically I do agree with Ayn Rand.

Well this is going to keep my mind flowing a time to come :] I spend a long time writing these things not only because i write a lot, but because I literally sit and think for 10-30 minutes every so often while I’m writing.

midniterequiem, it sounds like you might really like Objectivism. The philosophy is basically a guide to living life in the best ways. If you like novels, Rand’s two best-known, The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged, are both great as books and also great at showcasing her philosophy. If not, pick up any one of her non-fiction works and read a bit, it may surprise you!

I have a bad history with reading books haha. I like reading, just not being still. The more I read about Objectivism here and online though, the more interesting it is. My life philosophy works well for me though, so I don’t see myself making any huge changes, although I agree a lot with Ayn Rand, and therefore Objectivism already. Although I still remain a socialist, by pre-marxist standards, or maybe my own kind. I think I’m going to redirect some my friends here, or at least somewhere at Objectivism, though. While my life philosophy works very well for me, they typically don’t even have one; I don’t consider anything intrinsic much of a way to see the world. One of my friends actually likes Nietsche. I hate Nietsche! Not really, I just don’t like a lot of his ideas. Anyway, adieu.

Why be good? Because it creates values. …and values are what we try to gain or keep. Values are positive and life giving.

Here is one example. Being good means in the epistemological sense, being rational. Thinking and coming to reasoned conclusions that benefit your life and those around you. Being good affects yourself positvely and at the same time - others. Making proper decisions benefits you - you gain! It could be material gains. It could be spiritual gains. It could be both! Living positely opens the door for more even more opportunity and strengthens your better qualities, such as sense of justice, sense of reasoning, sense of industry, sense of your own skills and attributes…

So now go enjoy being good - to yourself and to others.

Well, that still has elements of relativism in it. It is a very common mistake. Think of it from three different perspectives.

  1. The truth is relative to me. My truth isn’t your truth. My ethics are not your ethics. This is the subjectivist view point.

  2. The truth just is. God told me it was. Society says it is. Whatever. I can’t explain it. It just is. Everyone has the same truth, and it looks an awful lot like a set of commandments.

  3. The truth and ethics derive from the facts of reality and the requirements of mans survival. Everyone’s truth is the same, but the facts of reality differ in each case. That is, there is context to factor in. Given the same context, the truth is the same, but reality tells you the context, so all variations on ethics are contextual, not relative or absolute.

1 is subjectivism

2 is intrinsicism

3 is Objectivism

Does that help?

It does help.

Could one say that their objectivism is really subjectivism, however, because it is directly related to their personal experience? Or do objectivists beleive that their philosophy is derived from outside of themselves - based on the laws (scientific, economic, etc) of the universe.

Is the goal of objectivism happiness? Contentment?

Don’t confuse subjectivism with contextual. Subjectivism would say that the truth has no cause. It is whatever you want it to be. Even if you were in my shoes, with all the same circumstances, your truth could be different from mine.

Contextual recognizes that reality is primary, that truth is not causeless, but based in reality. For any situation, the truth is determined by the facts of reality in that case.

Contextual recognizes that reality is primary, that truth is not causeless, but based in reality. For any situation, the truth is determined by the facts of reality in that case.

Is “Contextual” a part of objectivism? Can one be Contextual and believe in an all powerful God? The way you have defined a contextual’s thoughts about truth seem to mirror the way a theist would think about truth? Is this true?

Is “Contextual” a part of objectivism? Can one be Contextual and believe in an all powerful God? The way you have defined a contextual’s thoughts about truth seem to mirror the way a theist would think about truth? Is this true?

Yes, contextual is a part of Objectivism. Everything has context, and context must be taken into consideration. For example, “Is it right to kill?” must be applied to your context. If you just want to kill someone to take their sneakers, then yet, it’s wrong. If you are defending yourself from attack, then it’s the right thing to do. I’ll not be considering emergency situations, as that’s something completely different, and indeed there are many discussions about lifeboat and emergency situations.

That said, context does not determine truth absolute. My context does not change the chemical makeup of a rock, nor the number of people in Ethiopia. Contextual means simply taking all of your knowledge into consideration. One cannot contextualize the existence of an invisible, infinite, all-powerful consiousness. Our knowledge comes from discovery of reality, and integrating it with the rest of our knowledge. Knowledge ONLY comes from reality. As God has not presented himself, nor has he left evidence of his existence, knowledge of God is impossible. God does not fit into any context, aside from the imaginary.

There are those that say that they see evidence of God everywhere (like the woman who sold the “Jesus Toast” on ebay), or Mormons, who claim that when they “find god” that they get a feeling of warmth. It works with everything though, which is addressed rather precisely in the movie “Pi” (not an Objectivist movie, but a fun one nonetheless): “You’re connecting a computer bug I had with a computer bug you might have had and some religious hogwash. You want to find the number 216 in the world, you will be able to find it everywhere. 216 steps from a mere street corner to your front door. 216 seconds you spend riding on the elevator. When your mind becomes obsessed with anything, you will filter everything else out and find that thing everywhere.”

At the extreme end of things, people might claim they’ve seen an angel, or they’ve seen God, or anything that can just as easily be attributed to a hallucination, much in the same way that people with imaginary friends might be otherwise normal. Those people must realize that their mind and senses is not perfect, and are capable of making error. What one must do is simply ask the question “Do these visions fit with reality, or am I just hallucinating?” When someone claims they’ve seen God, the typical assumption (correctly) is that they are insane, or hopped up on something. For some reason, people are unwilling to attribute the same mental states to Biblical persons who claim they’ve seen God.

Personally, I’d like to extend the Bible to include the stories of anyone modern who claims to have seen God, as I think that would make the Bible even MORE crazy, and coincidentally, no less credible.

Is the goal of objectivism happiness? Contentment?

One could say the goal of Objectivism is happiness, assuming you hold the same definition of happiness: “Happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one’s values.”

Happiness is a long-term, overall state of mind, in which case, yes, you could say that’s the “goal” of Objectivism.

The proper way to phrase it, though, is the pursuit of one’s rational self-interest. Happiness is merely emotional response of achieving that.