Is “Contextual” a part of objectivism? Can one be Contextual and believe in an all powerful God? The way you have defined a contextual’s thoughts about truth seem to mirror the way a theist would think about truth? Is this true?
Yes, contextual is a part of Objectivism. Everything has context, and context must be taken into consideration. For example, “Is it right to kill?” must be applied to your context. If you just want to kill someone to take their sneakers, then yet, it’s wrong. If you are defending yourself from attack, then it’s the right thing to do. I’ll not be considering emergency situations, as that’s something completely different, and indeed there are many discussions about lifeboat and emergency situations.
That said, context does not determine truth absolute. My context does not change the chemical makeup of a rock, nor the number of people in Ethiopia. Contextual means simply taking all of your knowledge into consideration. One cannot contextualize the existence of an invisible, infinite, all-powerful consiousness. Our knowledge comes from discovery of reality, and integrating it with the rest of our knowledge. Knowledge ONLY comes from reality. As God has not presented himself, nor has he left evidence of his existence, knowledge of God is impossible. God does not fit into any context, aside from the imaginary.
There are those that say that they see evidence of God everywhere (like the woman who sold the “Jesus Toast” on ebay), or Mormons, who claim that when they “find god” that they get a feeling of warmth. It works with everything though, which is addressed rather precisely in the movie “Pi” (not an Objectivist movie, but a fun one nonetheless): “You’re connecting a computer bug I had with a computer bug you might have had and some religious hogwash. You want to find the number 216 in the world, you will be able to find it everywhere. 216 steps from a mere street corner to your front door. 216 seconds you spend riding on the elevator. When your mind becomes obsessed with anything, you will filter everything else out and find that thing everywhere.”
At the extreme end of things, people might claim they’ve seen an angel, or they’ve seen God, or anything that can just as easily be attributed to a hallucination, much in the same way that people with imaginary friends might be otherwise normal. Those people must realize that their mind and senses is not perfect, and are capable of making error. What one must do is simply ask the question “Do these visions fit with reality, or am I just hallucinating?” When someone claims they’ve seen God, the typical assumption (correctly) is that they are insane, or hopped up on something. For some reason, people are unwilling to attribute the same mental states to Biblical persons who claim they’ve seen God.
Personally, I’d like to extend the Bible to include the stories of anyone modern who claims to have seen God, as I think that would make the Bible even MORE crazy, and coincidentally, no less credible.