Why Objectivism

That said, context does not determine truth absolute. My context does not change the chemical makeup of a rock, nor the number of people in Ethiopia. Contextual means simply taking all of your knowledge into consideration. One cannot contextualize the existence of an invisible, infinite, all-powerful consiousness. Our knowledge comes from discovery of reality, and integrating it with the rest of our knowledge. Knowledge ONLY comes from reality. As God has not presented himself, nor has he left evidence of his existence, knowledge of God is impossible. God does not fit into any context, aside from the imaginary.

There are those that say that they see evidence of God everywhere (like the woman who sold the “Jesus Toast” on ebay),

That last statement seems a bit base don’t you think? Christians believe that evidence of God is everywhere, yes, but not in toast. A good example would be in Nature, the Bible, people etc. Most Christians I know would laugh at the toast example.

That being said, wouldn’t you agree that saying that God is imaginary, just because you can’t see Him is a bit serving for your POV?

If you just want to kill someone to take their sneakers, then yet, it’s wrong.

This is an absolute statement.

If you are defending yourself from attack, then it’s the right thing to do.

This is also an absolute statement.

The question, “is it wrong to kill?” must be answered contextually - absolute statement.

Just some food for thought I guess

This is an absolute statement.

This is also an absolute statement.

The question, “is it wrong to kill?” must be answered contextually - absolute statement.

Yup, they are contextual absolute statements. Reality is absolute. One evaluates a particular context with reference to the facts.

Note, this is not a commandement. Thou shalt not kill. That is, killing is not intrinsically bad.

Again, you seem to be unable to break the subjective / intrinsic dichotomy. First Objectivsim is relative, then its “absolute”. It is neither. It adheres to the contextual facts of reality.

Yup, they are contextual absolute statements. Reality is absolute. One evaluates a particular context with reference to the facts.

Note, this is not a commandement. Thou shalt not kill. That is, killing is not intrinsically bad.

Again, you seem to be unable to break the subjective / intrinsic dichotomy. First Objectivsim is relative, then its “absolute”. It is neither. It adheres to the contextual facts of reality.

Ok. Is it atheistic in nature?

Cause to me - it seems like it could be very much in line with Christian thinking about the world.

Is the goal of objectivism happiness? Contentment?

No, not quite. The goal (of the ethical part) is figuring out what will best further a human being’s life, in principle. The idea is that if one does this right, it will result in long-term happiness, but one cannot get to the principles by feeling what makes one happy. Some things make one happy, others make one sad, others make one happy now but unhappy the next morning, and so on. So, the real goal is to sort out that mess and see what works and does not work in principle in the long term.

The ethicist asks: what is the nature of man? what evidence do we have about his nature? what general principles of action should he follow in order to best benefit his life? what evidence do we have of this benefit?

I can see that you might find it hard to see the difference between this and subjectivism. To compare, one might kinda put it this way: The subjectivist ethic says “this is good because I feel so/I will it/God wills it” (no further argument). The Objectivist ethic says: “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life”.

Ok. Is it atheistic in nature?

Cause to me - it seems like it could be very much in line with Christian thinking about the world.

It is absolutely atheistic. I didn’t know what you meant before about being like Theist thought, nor this comment about Christian thinking. Could you elaborate?

Cause to me - it seems like it could be very much in line with Christian thinking about the world.

This couldn’t be further from the truth. Whereas Christians accept their god and “morality” on faith (without evidence), Objectivists seek the evidence (reality) that shows them what is really best for their lives (morality). Whereas Christians believe man is inherently evil and unable to save himself on his own accord (and must be save by his belief in God and Jesus), Objectivist know that man is capable of living a proper life, that he is capable of “saving” himself; that he does not have to be “saved” by some external mystical force.

While it may appear that some issues of Objectivist ethics and Christian morality parallel, the important distinction is that there are 1) no “commandments” for Objectivists, and 2) Objectivists can reference reality to determine morality versus referring to “the word on high”.

That last statement seems a bit base don’t you think? Christians believe that evidence of God is everywhere, yes, but not in toast. A good example would be in Nature, the Bible, people etc. Most Christians I know would laugh at the toast example.

Why is evidence of God not in toast? Isn’t the likeness of Jesus in a piece of toast within the capabilities of God? Why wouldn’t he give us evidence of his existence in such an unpredictable place? Do you have some inside information and know something about the nature of God that we don’t?

That being said, wouldn’t you agree that saying that God is imaginary, just because you can’t see Him is a bit serving for your POV?

My apologies, I guess I assumed you were aware of the atheistic position of Objectivism, hence my using religious examples as examples of preposterousness. I won’t get into the anti-god stuff, but there are lots of posts about religion, and indeed an entire forum dedicated to religion.

That being said, wouldn’t you agree that saying that God is imaginary, just because you can’t see Him is a bit serving for your POV?

First, asking whether an argument is “a bit serving for your POV” serves no useful purpose, because only a crazy person oposes their own point of view. The right question to ask is whether that would be a valid argument, and not whether the argument advances a particular conclusion (the implication being that one’s own POV is necessarily suspect??). Well, it is entirely correct to say that god is entirely and wholely a product of the imagination, if god cannot be seen (or otherwise observed using our sense organs). The mind is capable of piecing together ideas and impressions simply out of the lower-level concepts that one has created, based on actual perception of reality. A high-level notion fabricated out of such concepts does indeed quality as imaginary, until it is directly perceived.

I can see that you might find it hard to see the difference between this and subjectivism. To compare, one might kinda put it this way: The subjectivist ethic says “this is good because I feel so/I will it/God wills it” (no further argument). The Objectivist ethic says: “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life”.

As I mentioned earlier in this post, my reason for posting in this forum is that I’ve been doing research to gain an insight into the different ways that people think. From what I know of Christianity, I would say that there are a large number of Christians that would say, “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life, just like God set it up from the beginning”

Not to say that there are not those, Christians, that might say, “this is good because I feel so/I will it/God wills it” (no further agrument).

But my experience with Christians has led me to beleive that there are a larger number of them that believe in Christianity in a way that sounds very “objectivist”, ie, basing their belief system on what they see, the “work” they see God doing in their life and in the lives of others around them, nature, the word, etc (minus the whole "objectivism is purely atheistic part - haha). This was partly the source of some of my confusion.

It is absolutely atheistic. I didn’t know what you meant before about being like Theist thought, nor this comment about Christian thinking. Could you elaborate?

Thanks for the clarification. I was just curious if there were some Objectivists that might syncronize their objectivist thinking with theism. Guess not. Reason being (like I stated above) is that I’ve found a lot of Christians that tend to think in ways that are similar to Objectivism, but rooted Biblically. (meaning, “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life, just like God set it up from the beginning”)

It was just a thought

Why is evidence of God not in toast? Isn’t the likeness of Jesus in a piece of toast within the capabilities of God? Why wouldn’t he give us evidence of his existence in such an unpredictable place? Do you have some inside information and know something about the nature of God that we don’t?

My apologies, I guess I assumed you were aware of the atheistic position of Objectivism, hence my using religious examples as examples of preposterousness. I won’t get into the anti-god stuff, but there are lots of posts about religion, and indeed an entire forum dedicated to religion.

You know, I thought I should clarify my statement prior to posting it. Haha. Yes, God could show us evidence of His existence through toast. My point was that it is not fair to single out one example (of a lady that might either be “out of it” mentally or simply “pulling a fast one” to make some money) as the only example.

My point was that there are more credible examples than toast - haha.

But, thank you for the clarification as well.

Ah, ok. Now I think I understand. I think you may want to consider the fact that there is an intertwined history there and so what you see in Christianity may in some ways be mixed in with what you see in Objectivism. The fact is Objectivism has philsophical roots in Greek and Enlightenment philsophies, and Christianity has been highly intertwined with these for some time. Thomas Aquinas for instance was responsible for rediscovering the works of Aristotle and for setting the Catholic church on a path to attempt to reconcile reason and God (which it hasn’t).The way some people interpret Christianity should not be confused with what the doctrine says. America is a country with its most core intellectual roots in the Enlightenment, with reason and a this-worldly perspective as critical elements. Maybe what you are seeing is religion filtered through an Enlightenment lens. In some ways the Enlightenment has tempered the damage religion inflicts on rational progress. But look outside the influences of the Enlightenment, and you get a better glimpse of what havock religion, as such, causes.Objectivism rejects any form of non-reason such as religion, and firmly places its roots in Enlightenment / Greek (primarily Aritotelean) thinking.

I was just curious if there were some Objectivists that might syncronize their objectivist thinking with theism.

Theism is the last vestige of religion being removed. To the extent that a theist is this wordly and bases his conclusions on reason, then you might consider Objectivism as similar. The real question to ask is what is complimenting the belief in God in such a Theist. That is, theism leaves open a lot to non-religious influence. What fills that void will determine if it is in any way similar to Objectivism. If you are talking of the Theism of our founding fathers who filled that void with Enlightenment thinking and philosophy, then yes. If you’re talking about some new age theist, then no.

First, asking whether an argument is “a bit serving for your POV” serves no useful purpose, because only a crazy person oposes their own point of view. The right question to ask is whether that would be a valid argument, and not whether the argument advances a particular conclusion (the implication being that one’s own POV is necessarily suspect??).

You are absolutely correct - my apologies.

Well, it is entirely correct to say that god is entirely and wholely a product of the imagination, if god cannot be seen (or otherwise observed using our sense organs). The mind is capable of piecing together ideas and impressions simply out of the lower-level concepts that one has created, based on actual perception of reality. A high-level notion fabricated out of such concepts does indeed quality as imaginary, until it is directly perceived.

How do you know? I’m not saying I disagree with you, but, again, saying that something doesn’t exist because you can’t percieve it only proves that you don’t perceive it, not that the thing doesn’t exist. This is a logical fallacy.

My guess is there are things about this world (and possibly beyond) that we have yet to perceive.

My point was that there are more credible examples than toast - haha.

The Objectivist position on God in brief is that there is nothing credible that points to any evidence of one. That is because, infinite, omnipotent entities are non-sequitirs. They are contradiction in terms. They are anti-axiomatic.There are no"credible" examples that give direct evidence of God. You will always find any “credible” evidence really linked by a series of suppositions at least one of which has absolutely no basis in reality and so requires faith to accept. But, if you string enough evidentiary bits together, you can hide the one or more that require faith in something that “looks credible”.

How do you know? I’m not saying I disagree with you, but, again, saying that something doesn’t exist because you can’t percieve it only proves that you don’t perceive it, not that the thing doesn’t exist. This is a logical fallacy.My guess is there are things about this world (and possibly beyond) that we have yet to perceive.

That was my answer about it being really not an issue of proof, but rather an issue of anti-axiomatic. I have many things in this world yet to discover, but what I know about all of them as of yet undiscovered is that they have a nature, they act according to cause and effect, and they are limited. I will never find an apple that turns into an orange, without a cause which itself is based in reality.

The very definition of God flies in the face of that. It is not just an undiscovered thing. It is impossible.

My guess is there are things about this world (and possibly beyond) that we have yet to perceive.

That’s possible. But these are things that can be perceived. You raised the argument about things that can’t be perceived, which, as I said, are necessarily imaginary (“things which enter the mind only via imagination”). If you want to change your claim and say that you’ve actually seen god, then we can discuss your evidence. But for now, we are not talking about things that cannot be perceived. By way of contrast, there is another imaginary animal, a unicorn, which flies, has a horn, and is otherwise a horse. The claim, among unicorn-believers, is not that the beast cannot be seen, but has only been rarely seen, or so I’ve been told.

I would say that there are a large number of Christians that would say, “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life, just like God set it up from the beginning”

But the fact that they might say that doesn’t make it true.

Just as a heroin addict might say that shooting heroin makes him happy.

But the fact that they might say that doesn’t make it true.

Agreed.

That’s possible. But these are things that can be perceived. You raised the argument about things that can’t be perceived, which, as I said, are necessarily imaginary (“things which enter the mind only via imagination”). If you want to change your claim and say that you’ve actually seen god, then we can discuss your evidence. But for now, we are not talking about things that cannot be perceived. By way of contrast, there is another imaginary animal, a unicorn, which flies, has a horn, and is otherwise a horse. The claim, among unicorn-believers, is not that the beast cannot be seen, but has only been rarely seen, or so I’ve been told.

So then, I guess my question now focuses on whether or not you believe God can be percieved? I would guess that the average objectivist would say to someone that says, “I’ve ‘perceived’ God” that they are out of their mind.

From what I know of Christianity, I would say that there are a large number of Christians that would say, “this is good because the evidence about human nature and the rest of reality show that this futhers your life, just like God set it up from the beginning”

If one traces one’s actions back to the fundamental of “God’s will”, then – in theory – anything goes. It’s becomes anybody’s guess as to what God’s will really is, because they’re guessing about something fictional. What you seem to be saying is that many people disgree fundamentally with Objectivism on epistemology (i.e. how we arrive at knowledge), but end up agreeing with Objectivism on ethics.

Of course a lot of regular mildly-religious folk try to live in ways that are quite practical: get a job, find some interests, seek romance, and so on. Not just Christians, mind you, even many Muslims (today’s poster child of the religous mentality) do so.

People who are agnostic or strictly deist think that even if God exists, he is essentially irrelevant to our ongoing life. One cannot compare the ethics of such people – as a group – with any other ethical theory because they look elsewhere than religious texts for ethical theory. Today most of them accept some type of secular-altruist theory or some sort nihilist theory. If a religous person rejects religous text and relies on reality and his mind for ethics, then one should compare the particular ethical theory (altruism, hedonism, nihilism) with Objectivism, to really understand the differences.

So, if you want to understand ethical thinking for this sub-group of people, don’t classify them as “Christians”. Instead (for example) understand them as being “altruists”, who share an ethical code with muslim altruists, communist altruists, and so on, and compare against Objectivism at that level.

If one traces one’s actions back to the fundamental of “God’s will”, then – in theory – anything goes. It’s becomes anybody’s guess as to what God’s will really is, because they’re guessing about something fictional. What you seem to be saying is that many people disgree fundamentally with Objectivism on epistemology (i.e. how we arrive at knowledge), but end up agreeing with Objectivism on ethics.

Of course a lot of regular mildly-religious folk try to live in ways that are quite practical: get a job, find some interests, seek romance, and so on. Not just Christians, mind you, even many Muslims (today’s poster child of the religous mentality) do so.

People who are agnostic or strictly deist think that even if God exists, he is essentially irrelevant to our ongoing life. One cannot compare the ethics of such people – as a group – with any other ethical theory because they look elsewhere than religious texts for ethical theory. Today most of them accept some type of secular-altruist theory or some sort nihilist theory. If a religous person rejects religous text and relies on reality and his mind for ethics, then one should compare the particular ethical theory (altruism, hedonism, nihilism) with Objectivism, to really understand the differences.

So, if you want to understand ethical thinking for this sub-group of people, don’t classify them as “Christians”. Instead (for example) understand them as being “altruists”, who share an ethical code with muslim altruists, communist altruists, and so on, and compare against Objectivism at that level.

Great info - thanks

If one traces one’s actions back to the fundamental of “God’s will”, then – in theory – anything goes. It’s becomes anybody’s guess as to what God’s will really is, because they’re guessing about something fictional

Not quite. This presupposes that Christianity is fictional (which it very well might be). Also, Christians believe that “God’s Will” is not “anything goes” or “anybody’s guess”, but has been revealed through the Bible. Just thought I would help to clarify.