Animal rights

When a dish is broken or an animal dies, the dish and the animal, in effect, do not exist any more. Those existents are now named “trash” and “carcass” to indicate the difference.

LOL :lol:

What? I’m just saying! :lol:

Note that the only sigificance of what the dogs were bred for is that they probably wouldn’t make very good tasting food. Not that it is somehow immoral to eat them.

Note that the only sigificance of what the dogs were bred for is that they probably wouldn’t make very good tasting food.  Not that it is somehow immoral to eat them.

Actually, dogs are eaten as a delicacy in the north-eastern (mostly tribal) parts of India. I met a herpetologist once who had done research in that area and said that dog meat is really tasty. Carnivore meat, it seems, is salty and this adds to its taste.

The point for the vegetarians, however, is that one wouldn’t eat one’s own pet because one considers it as a companion, not because it has any rights.

Consider what is actually being argued against by (most) vegetarians. As Old Geezer put it, and I have heard, they say that they don’t like meat from factory farms. (I won’t discuss the agrument about cruelty here.) What would it mean if we closed down these farms and only allowed the organically raised as our sources of meat? The first thing to happen would be a dramatic rise in cost, because there would be a lot less meat. Then, because there is less meat available, and what is available is costly, many, many people would be forced to go without. This is a gross violation of human rights, on the most basic level. What gives anyone the right to determine what another eats. Obtaining sustenance is absolutely basic to the survival of any living thing.

This is the same ol’ tyranical play for power over people; they’ve just put on a different mask and use different props. One may argue that there is a better way to manufacture our food, and I’m sure there is. There is a question, for instance, about whether injecting cows with certain antibiotics might be detrimental to human health (because, they say, it causes the bacteria to mutate and lessens the effectiveness of antibiotics in humans). But all such questions are technical and, as such, they are the provence of science, not politics. The government only gets in the way of solutions to these problems when they dictate regulations that stiffle innovation.

Morally, if someone chooses to be a vegetarian, it’s no skin off my nose. When these people become activists supporting force, however, they put themselves outside the discussion and become an enemy to human life.

" What would it mean if we closed down these farms and only allowed the organically raised as our sources of meat? "

Most vegetarians I know dont advocate the “shutting down of factory farms” what they do is choose to spend their money on products in line with their values. If they earn their money, this is well within their right.

If any have tried to convince me to become vegetarians, that is also within their right. (as long as our relationship does not involve force)

What I am asking is how one might respond to the argument for refraining from factory farms because of respect for life..

Chasing a deer and killing it still constitutes respect for life. So too does raising a domesticated animal for food. (In both cases, the animal is living in allignment with its nature… but if I were to say step on my German shepard to reach the cookie jar, that would not allow it to be in allignment with its nature)

a classic example that is presented to me is that of “free range chickens” vs. a “factory farm” the chickens literally are packed so tight that they are constantly shitting on each other., often force fed (to meet productions schedules) they are then drugged to prevent movement and squished into these little crates to be processed. The drugs wear off during travel and the chickens wake up.

Domesticated chickens do not normally shit on each others heads , or refrain from walking.

Free range chickens are treated differently, and probably would act no differently if the gates were lifted. (In fact, having worked on a free range farm before, I didnt see a difference in their behavior when the gate was broken for a little while)

Old salt,

I appreciated your comments, care to respond to above?

Maybe it is just that people in Washington state are hippies, but most the vegitarians I have met are, at the least, activally against the mere existance of factory farms. Many argue, among a host of other anti-man policies, against the existance of free range farms as well.

What I am asking is how one might respond to the argument for refraining from factory farms because of respect for life..

If their respect is for human life, they will recognise the vastly increased productivity/effeciancy of the factory farms. These things allow more consideration/manpower to go towards the things that make the life of a human being comfortable (medicine, etc…).

In my experience, however, nearly all vegitarians are activally anti-production; anti-man. Most won’t try to present a reasonable arguement otherwise, and many will admit it straight-up.

Maybe it is just that people in Washington state are hippies, but most the vegitarians I have met are, at the least, activally against the mere existance of factory farms

Oh you poor person! I feel for you. :unsure: I once had someone from washington state tell me “in a way, the trees are smarter than you”

“If their respect is for human life, they will recognise the vastly increased productivity/effeciancy of the factory farms”

That argument might apply if factory farming was healthier than the type of diet people would be able to afford without factory farms… But factory farming is more likely to cultivate an environment where dangerous disease thrives , and the research on meaty diets is mixed at best.

That argument might apply if factory farming was healthier than the type of diet people would be able to afford without factory farms… But factory farming is more likely to cultivate an environment where dangerous disease thrives , and the research on meaty diets is mixed at best.

This is true. Recall, however, that we were talking about people who were vegitarians out of respect for the animals life. My point was not that there is no good reason to have a preference against factory farms, but that they were willing to sacrifice human comforts for that non-human life.

There may be valid arguments offered regarding health matters as they pertain to factory farms. Not knowing any of the science, it still seems reasonable to argue that the healthier the animal, the healthier the meat provided. My point, however, isn’t that there are always better ways of doing things, but the forcing of people to behave by standards not of their choosing.

While a chicken defecating on another chicken’s head is certainly not aesthetically pleasing, we aren’t eating that chicken’s head. Buying free range or organtically grown meat (or vegetables) is a choice. If you choose to allocate your resources for that, it is your perogative. No one here would argue otherwise (and still be an Objectivist, anyway). This isn’t the thrust of an activist’s actions, however. They do not want us to have any choice in the matter. They consider it morally reprehensible and would have their morals forced on the rest of us.

Saying that the health claims about eating meat are dubious is also not a valid reason to override my rights. One could also argue that we evolved into kind of creatures we are only after we began to eat meat on a regular basis (specifically, our brain evolved). There are certain amino acids required for human health that are available only in meat. Vegetarians and animal rights activists like to say that we no longer need meat, but I’ve never seen any objective scientific studies to back that up. Even if there were valid studies, that still would not give them the right to determine my choices.

Remember, as well, that the arguments always go further than just eating meat. The arguments against supposed cruelty to animals extend to scientific studies using animals, as well. These arguments all ignore the requirements of human life. Just because we can think and be sensitive about how we use animals doesn’t change that fact.

I would respectfully remind you that when you grant premises to one who would take away your rights you are playing a dangerous game. Just because they say that they are looking out for life doesn’t mean that they have any respect for human life. If a person is for government mandated regulation of what we may or may not eat, or for regulating scientific study using animals, they are not fighting for man’s betterment, no matter how they have managed to convince themselves otherwise.

"This is true. Recall, however, that we were talking about people who were vegitarians out of respect for the animals life. My point was not that there is no good reason to have a preference against factory farms, but that they were willing to sacrifice human comforts for that non-human life."RH

This argument would only apply if A) they considered the forgoing of meat a sacrifice. or B ) they wanted to sacrifice other peoples comfort.

"My point, however, isn’t that there are always better ways of doing things, but the forcing of people to behave by standards not of their choosing."OS

I am not advocating this, I am talking about the vegetarians who who ASK you to consider their argument

"While a chicken defecating on another chicken’s head is certainly not aesthetically pleasing, we aren’t eating that chicken’s head"OS

Dont worry, they shit all over themselves, not just their heads :wink: but that wasnt my point. My point was that domesticated animals are excellent in the aristotlean sense when they are slaughtered(because that is theirpurpose) but not when they shit on themselves and dont move.

"This isn’t the thrust of an activist’s actions, however. They do not want us to have any choice in the matter. They consider it morally reprehensible and would have their morals forced on the rest of us. "

I am not talking about Veggies who would initiate force or advocate the initiation of force. I am talking about those who may find it morally reprehensible and would consequentally want to discuss this with friends/family , just as any moral issue is discussed.

"There are certain amino acids required for human health that are available only in meat. "

FYI not true :slight_smile:

“I would respectfully remind you that when you grant premises to one who would take away your rights you are playing a dangerous game.”

AGAIN , Vegetarians who advocate using anything other than their consumer dollars to affect factory conditions are not who I am talking about. In fact I went to a school that was 60% vegetarian for a short while and only met one or two of these people, and THEY were RESENTED by the rest of vegetarians .

The vegetarians who most often discuss this issue with me;

A Dr. doing it for health reasons,

My capitilist brother working for a fortune 500 company making big bucks,

and my sister working for the military.

Yes, Old Geezer, everything you said is true. This may not be true for your personal aquantinces, but most all people who claim to be concerned about the life or living conditions of a chicken are willing to sacrifice the life or living conditions of human beings.

This may or may not be the case with doctors claiming to be vegitarian for health reasons. Frankly, I believe that most doctors who make the claim that meat is bad for your health do not believe it, and do so only to encourage vegitarianism. This may or may not be the case with your friend, I don’t know.

I am talking about those who may find it morally reprehensible…

On what grounds, surely it is not morally reprehensible for me to let chickens live in poor conditions so that I may eat at a lesser expense. It would be immoral to put chickens in such poor conditions for no reason, but there is a goal here, one which effects the quality of life of billions of human beings. What you must ask is: is it the improvement of this quality of life which your friends find morally reprehensible? For most vegitarians, the answer is yes.

"What you must ask is: is it the improvement of this quality of life which your friends find morally reprehensible? For most vegitarians, the answer is yes. "

I dont quite understand where you are getting this generalization from?

I dont quite understand where you are getting this generalization from?

I have spoken to many vegitarians, and even taken a class in “Environmental Ethics” (it was required, believe it or not). Almost all arguements for any sort of consideration for the well being of animals are admittedly anti-man, most others hide it only on a surface level.

Note that when I consider an animal’s well being necessarily implies that I go out of my way to make that animal’s life better. Surely, it is silly, a waste of time, even immoral, to harm an animal for no reason… but to cause yourself any sort of inconvience on account of an animal is at best a mistake.

I am having considerable difficulty imagining how chickens could ever survive in the wild.

Spell-check: vegetarian, affect, acquaintance (Richard_Halley).

Yeah, I should start running spell check on my posts… I am a horrendous speller.

"I am having considerable difficulty imagining how chickens could ever survive in the wild."YF

Me too. what of it?

“Note that when I consider an animal’s well being necessarily implies that I go out of my way to make that animal’s life better”

A)it necessarilly implies nothing

B ) the issue isn’t the well being of the animal, but rather respect for life itself.(not deference to animal life, just respect for life’s struggle for existence) If the issue was well being than there are certain ways in which the animals are better off under a factory system (higher weight, preventative antibiotics)

i) If the standard of excellence for the food is taste than I have several questions; 1. Do you feel that food preferences are a rational choice?? If they are than might exposure to new information lead to different choices? If they arent, then why do food preferences vary?

ii) if the standard of excellence is cost, than a veggie diet is cheaper.

iii) if the standard of excellence is health, the jury is still out in my mind.

iiii) if the standard of excellence is cultural, YIKES!

anyway, what do YOU consider the standard of excellence for food?

Old Geezer:

I have had many discussions with vegans and vegetarians over questions of health. My own health is atrocious and I am pretty much boat bound most of the time because of it (Oh, I live on a boat). Fellow boaters who are vegetarians talk to me all the time about the kinds of things you’ve mentioned; they seem to think that all my genetic make-up could be changed if I just ate differently. They are always respectful to me personally. Anytime I’ve delved any deeper, however, these lovely, non-activist people would have the world acting on their beliefs BY LAW (i.e., by force). It would, their argument goes, be healthier for *the most* people in the population, cause less harm to animals, end government subsidies to factory farms (freeing up the money to support organic farming), put an end to obesity – the list goes on and on, and changes with each discussion. These are nice people who would never dream of hurting another human being.

At first, our discussions only went as far as the kind you are talking about. We discussed the merits of this and that. I tried to get them to back up their assertions with science, asking them to give me something to go on besides blantantly biased pamphlets and books and their own understanding. (For an instance of this, consider that you didn’t give me anywhere to go that says we don’t need certain amino acids found only in meat. You merely said that it was untrue. I know you were giving the short answer, but the short answer does nothing to persuade and, in fact, I have been told differently by the doctors who dictate my diet.) Whenever we got into discussing the actual facts, the conversation invariably turned to the morality of eating animals in the first place.

This discussion provides a fine example of the kind of question which buries a false assumtion, such that any direct answer to the question grants the assumption. The assumption in this discussion is that it is immoral to eat animals. It is a question, then, of ethics, not science. Science is used because the ethical aspect is more inflamatory and it is easier to persuade using science.

The fact that the speaker doesn’t have a clue of what he is doing isn’t relevant. If you are to ferret out the true meaning behind the questions being debated or discussed, to paraphrase Toohey, don’t bother to examine such assumptions, merely ask yourself what they accomplish.

That’s the short answer, anyway. ;~)

I hope that made sense. I have days when what seems reasonable to me comes across to others as gibberish. It’s an amino acid, broken synapses thing.

Heh.

"an instance of this, consider that you didn’t give me anywhere to go that says we don’t need certain amino acids found only in meat. You merely said that it was untrue. I know you were giving the short answer, but the short answer does nothing to persuade and, in fact, I have been told differently by the doctors who dictate my diet.) "

Proving a negative is difficult, OS… Which amino acid are you refferring to? I am an avid weight lifter and am not aware of any amino acids not available via a vegetarian diet.

Please Name an Amino acid that cannot be obtained from a vegetarian diet.