The case of how a rational value system fits in the case of killing/farming/mistreating sentinent creatures has always looked complex to me.
Man is omnivorous and the point is not whether we should eat animals or not, but whether we should mind how the animals are treated.
For example, let’s say if I am Korean and like dog’s meat. What if I find out that, as I have heard, there is certain way to kill dogs in Korea (at least in some towns, at some times) in which dogs are beaten up until they die, so that their flesh can be softened (which is, by the way, physiologically absurd, as the dog’s muscle would be contracted as hell). I would find irrational to support that method of killing by buying and eating that meat.
I think it is reasonable to expect that animals will experience pain and distress when raised in conditions that are far different from the conditions that they are meant to live by their own evolutionary process.
Locking chicken or cows within very small cages where they can barely move is objectively very different from the normal conditions that fit their nature.
In nature, cows are hunted for few minutes at a time by a predator, and experience danger for those few minutes. But they live most of their time as cows.
In pre-industrial stages, cows also lived most of their lives as cows, with a lot of freedom, the ability to graze wherever they liked within broad limits, mate, breastfeed their calves, etc. When killed by the farmer, they experienced what they would have experienced with any other predator. There was no significant departure from the realization that a cow was a cow.
In a modern industrial farms, however, it seems to me that cows are treated as if the weren’t sentinent creatures but machines.
Even up to this point, industrial farming as such is far from evil. Industrial farming allowed millions of people to have access to proteins by lowering the cost of meat. And obviously men interests are above cow’s interest.
The point has come, however, when in wealthy Western societies we have cheap access to so many options to enjoy a healthy, diverse and tasty meal, that it is becoming increasingly harder to support the claim that meat is essential. And even when we decide to eat meat, it is hard to support why whe would choose meat produces in farms where cows are treated as machines instead of more traditional farms where cows are treated as cows.
My position is that the life of animals, particularly higher mammals, should be respected as it is, inasmuch as it does not clash with man’s rational self-interest.
In the same way that babies and severily mentally disabled people are valued by rational men, animals with higher mental states are valued for rational men.
Rational men tend to value everything that resembles volitional conciousness, or comes close to it. The more rational a behaviour seems to be in a sentinent being, the more is it valued.
By the same token, the more the animal’s pain is linked to our survival or progress, the less we care. But when the link is lost or unclear, our eyebrows start to raise.
That’s why a rational man is more likely to feel horrifed by the sight of a gorilla being mutilated to sell its hands as ashtrays than by the sight of a guinea pig being dissected in a lab to explore the toxic effects of a new drug.
We have said that a man who tortures animals is more likely to despise life altogether.
Well… by the same token, a man who treats sentinent creatures as machines, is perhaps more willing to to treat people as machines, to enslave others, to be a collectivist, to deny individuality.
In conclusion, I am not saying that eating meat is immoral. I am not saying that modern farming is immoral as such… and I am not vegan or pro-vegan at all.
I am just saying that we may benefit from considering the whole context: what we eat, how animals are treated, what our personal options and circumstances are, and act accordingly.
The answer may be different for different people. For some, buying meat from modern farms will be unavoidable to ensure access to cheap proteins. For some, eating meat is a proper way to indulge himself now and then. to celebrate the company of friends, traditional cuisine, etc. And seeking meat from traditional farms can be an option. But still for others, who can benefit from a diet based on fish and vegetables, sparing the suffering of cows or pigs in modern farms might be feasible.