Bush's Shameful Assault Against Gay Marriage

Sorry for the delay. I just noticed this.

Marriage can be considered a religious establishment, in which case NO ONE has a right to it.  The churches in question may distribute or refuse to distribute lisences as they please.

But why are we concerned at all about religious practices? A church can “marry” a man and a goat for all I care. I only care about marriage as defined in the legal documents acknowledged by the government.

In so much as your “marriage” is not a religious establishment, you do have a right to it.

Why do you put my marriage in scare quotes?

But such a marriage is no different than a “civil union” as offered to homosexuals in many states (I am assuming that the same legal benefits apply to both, if not they should).

There certainly is a significant difference. By common practice a legally married couple is accorded a special status with special privileges by many organizations, both public and private. Until the time that a civil union is accepted as is a legal marriage by, for instance, insurance companies and government tax laws alike, there will remain a difference.

Howdy All,

Great Discussion.

It would seem to me that marriage (from the point of view of the state), is a contractual agreement between two conscenting adults. Dealing primary with the property rights issues. There are agreeing to share their resources. How exactly they share is based upon the contract. Prenuptual agreements and the like.

Now what some mystic has to say is something else entirely. He might say that it had to be a contract between a man and a woman. Perhaps women depending on which “word of god” he quotes. For that matter it might require some sort of formalization of the contract in a church by the mystic for a donation of course.

The problem lies in that many of our laws, pertaining to this specific contract, are biased by the religous influence on them. If we can modify the law, or pass new law that will remove the mystical influences, it would seem to be a good thing.

Than again. The fact that we have government intrusion into one of the most basic of our human rights, i.e. The Right to Trade, is what is really at the core here. Since the right to trade is the key to any contract.

I listen to a lot of talk radio, and the conservatives crack me up about this issue. The seem to always focus in on the supposed benefits to homosexual couples. What kills me is that no one seems to think of the downside to entering into a contract such as a marriage. It can be very difficult, and or, costly if that contract is breached. Having witnessed my parents divorce, and my roomate’s dealings with her ex-husband, I would say that marriage is definetly not to be entered into lightly. Just strikes me as odd that so little is said of that. If I were a lawyer, I would brush up on my divorce law.

Thanks for the rant. As for me, I am not to worried. I am just going to wait for the lights to go out. Kerry for President! :lol:

This nonsense about marriage being essentially religious has got to stop.  It reminds me of Communist propaganda

Can you provide some evidence, please?  I’m inclined to believe that “the church” took over the idea of marriage from the Greeks, like so much else.


And AutoJC, don’t get all offended and act like you had nothing to do with this thread “evolving” into a Bush/Kerry debate.  The last line of your original post suggests otherwise, that that is in fact precisely what you intended.  Your indignant denial of it therefore strikes me as dishonest.  I agree with those who said you should try to keep that debate in one thread, because, while as it stands now I won’t be voting for Bush either, your posts really are starting to seem like part of the Kerry campaign.  Go right ahead and express your opinion, some of us here may even agree with you, but this is borderline spamming.  It has nothing to do with not having an open mind, I would say the same thing if someone were proselytizing for Bush.

Say what you want about my so-called “spamming.”

I still disagree with you and GC regarding this.

This is an important issue against Bush and one which I’d further like to point out is contrary to objectivist philosophy- regarding the faith-based right’s assault on Gay marriage.

Bush is anti-American. Someone ought to shove the Bill of Rights in front of him. He took an oath which states that he is under obligation to defend the Constitution- not limit our rights.

JC…

You are correct in saying that this is an important point about bush’s anti-americanism.

In fact, this is precisely why you should have placed it in the pre-existing topic covering that matter.

Placing it in a new topic is confusing and accomplishes nothing except to remove all counter-arguments from the discussion, thus forcing all others to repeat themselves.

Basically:

There is nothing wrong with pointing out Bush’s flaws.

There is something wrong with making 4 different threads in which to do so. Especially when one already exists.

JC…

You are correct in saying that this is an important point about bush’s anti-americanism.

In fact, this is precisely why you should have placed it in the pre-existing topic covering that matter. 

Placing it in a new topic is confusing and accomplishes nothing except to remove all counter-arguments from the discussion, thus forcing all others to repeat themselves.

Basically:

There is nothing wrong with pointing out Bush’s flaws.

There is something wrong with making 4 different threads in which to do so.  Especially when one already exists.

Unfortunately I lack the tools by which to combine this thread into another.

I’ll just let the admins and the mods here make that final decision, and will abide by it.

Bush is anti-American.

I agree with you that in terms of his explicit philosophy, Bush is anti-American–although in terms of his sense of life, I think he is somewhat mixed. (Kerry, on the other hand, is anti-American through and through.)

Someone ought to shove the Bill of Rights in front of him.  He took an oath which states that he is under obligation to defend the Constitution-  not limit our rights.

And this could apply to almost every politician in America today, so I’m not sure why you single Bush out on this count. Name a president in the last century that didn’t strive to limit our rights in some way.

But why are we concerned at all about religious practices? A church can “marry” a man and a goat for all I care. I only care about marriage as defined in the legal documents acknowledged by the government.

We should not be… this is my entire point.

The marriages performed by the government are not to be confused with those performed by religious establishment.

We only differ in that I see no point in calling a government “marriage” a “marriage” at all. If you called it–keeping the same legal benifits which currently exist–a “civil union” than there wouldn’t be all this confusion about the two (specifically, churches would not claim to have any say in a “civil union,” while they do claim to for a “marriage”). This should answer your question about my use of quotations (but than again, my previous posts should have, too).

As for this:

There certainly is a significant difference. By common practice a legally married couple is accorded a special status with special privileges by many organizations, both public and private. Until the time that a civil union is accepted as is a legal marriage by, for instance, insurance companies and government tax laws alike, there will remain a difference.

You will please note the qualifier at the end of the statment to which the above is responding. It states: “I am assuming that the same legal benefits apply to both, if not they should.”

The main point of the statment is to identify that a “marriage,” as given by the government, is of no relation what-so-ever to those performed by churches. Using the long established church term “marriage” to denote something different is of no benefit, it merely confuses everyone.

Hi:

The same-sex marriage debate here is quite interesting.

If I may add, the opponents of same-sex marriage ignored the Equal Protection and Full Faith Credit clause. The U.S. Supreme Court consistently ruled that the Full Faith and Credit Clause require each state to honor the court judgments of other states. Also, marriage laws are under the jurisdiction of the state.

It would be interesting to observed whether the amendment proposed by Bush would be ratified by the states.

Q

I see no point in calling a government “marriage” a “marriage” at all.  If you called it–keeping the same legal benifits which currently exist–a “civil union” than there wouldn’t be all this confusion about the two (specifically, churches would not claim to have any say in a “civil union,” while they do claim to for a “marriage”).  This should answer your question about my use of quotations (but than again, my previous posts should have, too).

This is exactly the point I was trying to make back in the beginning of this thread. I think you’ve said it best here, though.

The marriages performed by the government are not to be confused with those performed by religious establishment. 

It doesn’t matter so much who performs the ceremony. What matters is the legal document, the marriage certificate, which the government issues.

We only differ in that I see no point in calling a government “marriage” a “marriage” at all.

Sorry, but this statement makes no sense to me. A marriage is the legal acknowledgement of the union, and that is what the government does.

If you called it–keeping the same legal benifits which currently exist–a “civil union” than there wouldn’t be all this confusion about the two (specifically, churches would not claim to have any say in a “civil union,” while they do claim to for a “marriage”). 

You are confusing the ceremony with legal act of marriage. I do not care if the ceremony is officiated over by a judge, a priest, or a porcupine. What matters is the legal document which the government recognizes as marriage.

This should answer your question about my use of quotations (but than again, my previous posts should have, too).

Sorry, but I still cannot make sense of your point in doing so.

As for this:You will please note the qualifier at the end of the statment to which the above is responding. It states: “I am assuming that the same legal benefits apply to both, if not they should.”

The main point of the statment is to identify that a “marriage,” as given by the government, is of no relation what-so-ever to those performed by churches. Using the long established church term “marriage” to denote something different is of no benefit, it merely confuses everyone.

I am not confused. The issue is quite clear to me.

I agree with you that in terms of his explicit philosophy, Bush is anti-American–although in terms of his sense of life, I think he is somewhat mixed.

It depends on how exactly you define “anti-American.” Possible definitions are:

  • A person whose philosophy differs from that of the Founding Fathers (applies to Bush)
  • A leader whose policies are not fully aligned with America’s national interests (applies to Bush)
  • A person who hates America (doesn’t apply to Bush)
  • A person who actively seeks to destroy America (doesn’t apply to Bush)

I strongly suspect that the latter two do apply to Kerry.

Marriage existed from ancient times. The church only turned it to a sacrament in the 12th century A.D.

I do think that gay couples should find another term, but not because of the religious connotations - but because of the ancient connotation of a man and a woman looking to establish a family together.

Even in ancient Greece, where homosexuality was common, they usually did not refer to it as marriage. Marriage was a term refering only to the union of a man and a woman, as a basis for forming a family.

Emperor Nero married a Greek boy called Sporos, during a tour to Greece, because he reminded him of his late wife Poppaea (which he had accidentaly killed). He staged a mock marriage, with guests and presents - and introduced everybody to his new “wife”". It is said that he even forced the guests to offer the traditional wishes that the union might be blessed with children.

Nero was mocked in his own time, which goes to show how unusual it was back then.

Incidentally, none of my remarks ever addressed the issue of homosexual marriage. I have been responding to what I consider to be rather strange views of marriage per se.

It depends on how exactly you define “anti-American.” Possible definitions are:

  • A person whose philosophy differs from that of the Founding Fathers (applies to Bush)

  • A leader whose policies are not fully aligned with America’s national interests (applies to Bush)

  • A person who hates America (doesn’t apply to Bush)

  • A person who actively seeks to destroy America (doesn’t apply to Bush)

The first is clearly a matter of explicit philosophy, which is the context I specifically defined in saying that Bush is anti-American (to the extent that he has one). The third is (at least in the case of a non-philosophical person) clearly a sense of life issue, which is the context in which I said Bush is mixed.

Read or re-read Leonard Peikoff’s “Religion vs. America” to see why I say that Bush is in fact anti-American, regardless of what his intentions might be.

Sorry, but this statement makes no sense to me. A marriage is the legal acknowledgement of the union, and that is what the government does.

Since when is a marriage the legal acknowledgement of a union? Only reletively recently. First it was a religious pledge, absoultely controlled by the church.

When we call something completly different–the legal acknowledgement of the union–marriage, the chruches mistakenly think that the government is fooling around with their domain and that, therefore, the should have some say in how that is done.

Since you seem to not understand how my previous statments have already answered your questions–and so it is unlikely that you will see how the above does as well–I will tackle them individually.

It doesn’t matter so much who performs the ceremony. What matters is the legal document, the marriage certificate, which the government issues.

I agree here. I simply see no reason to call that legal document a “marriage” certificate rather than a “certificate of unionship” or something of the like.

Sorry, but this statement makes no sense to me. A marriage is the legal acknowledgement of the union, and that is what the government does.

See above.

You are confusing the ceremony with legal act of marriage. I do not care if the ceremony is officiated over by a judge, a priest, or a porcupine. What matters is the legal document which the government recognizes as marriage.

How you figure that I am doing this is beyond me. I am addressing the problems with using a word which once denoted–and, in many minds, still does denote–a religious pledge to describe a legal recognition. When a preist performs a marriage there is a difference between what he is performing and what a justice of the peace performs. My concern is not over who performs it, but over what it means.

Sorry, but I still cannot make sense of your point in doing so. [speaking here of using quotes around the word marriage]

Hopefully by now you recognise that there is a difference between a religious marriage and a legal one. My use of the quotes was to differentiate between the two (the reasons I chose to use the quotes arond the legal ones should be obvious by now).

From a seperate post:

Incidentally, none of my remarks ever addressed the issue of homosexual marriage. I have been responding to what I consider to be rather strange views of marriage per se.

Yes, it should be obvious that we both think that the legal recognition of a union should be attainable by anyone in such a union.

Just to be perfectly clear, you are not responding to strange views of marriage (unless you are suggusting that there is no fundamental difference between a legal recognition and a religious pledge) as my views are on the useage of the word, not the marriage itself.

Honestly, I really don’t see why you think it is so important to use the church word to discribe non-church unions.

Since when is a marriage the legal acknowledgement of a union?  Only reletively recently.  First it was a religious pledge, absoultely controlled by the church.

You keep saying this, but both Eran and I have suggested that the church took it over from the Ancients. Do you deny that the Greeks had a concept of marriage, and that it was not just (if at all) religious in nature?

Hopefully by now you recognise that there is a difference between a religious marriage and a legal one.

I have understood the difference since I was a child. Both I and my government could care less about the former and are only concerned with the latter. Marriage is a legal contract for which conditions and validation are set by the government. That the government permits certain clergy to sign the license which the state issues just means that the clergy are acting as agents for the government, and in no way implies that the government recognizes any religious claim to marriage.

I am at a complete loss to understand your concern for “religious marriage.” At best, it is a private ritual performed by a bunch of confirmed mystics, having no more legal significance than an exorcism.

From Richard’s post

I agree here. I simply see no reason to call that legal document a “marriage” certificate rather than a “certificate of unionship” or something of the like.

From Stephen’s post

I am at a complete loss to understand your concern for “religious marriage.”

Stephen,

Why do you keep thinking that Richard is concerned with religious marriage? It is very clear to me that his concern lies solely in the confusion in the use of the term, which I think has become very relevant within this discussion. As it is used today, marriage is often used interchangeably as both a religious and legal ceremony. As you said yourself there is a difference between the two, don’t you think that there should be a distinction between the two?

And Ash,

I don’t really think the ancient Greek/Roman’s view or concepts of marriage, if they can really compare to today’s conception of marriage, is relevant to this issue. Richard’s point was that in today’s culture the term marriage was taken from the churches use of it, which is true, and that all this contributes to the confusion about what the real purpose of a marriage is.

You keep saying this, but both Eran and I have suggested that the church took it over from the Ancients. Do you deny that the Greeks had a concept of marriage, and that it was not just (if at all) religious in nature?

Ash, the greeks may have had a concept which you can now compare to marriage… but it would have been more similar to the concept of slavery than of our marriage today. And more importantly, as Joe pointed out, the concern is not about the origins of the term but about the roots of its usage today.

At best, it is a private ritual performed by a bunch of confirmed mystics, having no more legal significance than an exorcism.

I agree. This is precisely why I am so amazed at your adoption of the term which has long denoted this mystical practice. I am not at all concerened with religious marriage, only with the distinction between it and legal marriage.

It seems to me that all this fervor over the word marriage is reminiscent of political correctness. It appears to me that some folks are saying that context doesn’t matter, it’s connotation is so strong that context isn’t important. I have to disagree. As with any word that has multiple meanings, it’s important that the speaker uses the word in it’s correct context. Anyone who doesn’t like the word can avoid using it and substitute it in the manner he/she sees fit, while those who do use it should make sure the context is clear, just as they should with any word or words. It’s already stifling enough to have to limit one’s vocabulary because of the over-sensitivity of others without adding more words to the list.

Yes, I’m bachelorly-challenged.

VES