Sorry, but this statement makes no sense to me. A marriage is the legal acknowledgement of the union, and that is what the government does.
Since when is a marriage the legal acknowledgement of a union? Only reletively recently. First it was a religious pledge, absoultely controlled by the church.
When we call something completly different–the legal acknowledgement of the union–marriage, the chruches mistakenly think that the government is fooling around with their domain and that, therefore, the should have some say in how that is done.
Since you seem to not understand how my previous statments have already answered your questions–and so it is unlikely that you will see how the above does as well–I will tackle them individually.
It doesn’t matter so much who performs the ceremony. What matters is the legal document, the marriage certificate, which the government issues.
I agree here. I simply see no reason to call that legal document a “marriage” certificate rather than a “certificate of unionship” or something of the like.
Sorry, but this statement makes no sense to me. A marriage is the legal acknowledgement of the union, and that is what the government does.
See above.
You are confusing the ceremony with legal act of marriage. I do not care if the ceremony is officiated over by a judge, a priest, or a porcupine. What matters is the legal document which the government recognizes as marriage.
How you figure that I am doing this is beyond me. I am addressing the problems with using a word which once denoted–and, in many minds, still does denote–a religious pledge to describe a legal recognition. When a preist performs a marriage there is a difference between what he is performing and what a justice of the peace performs. My concern is not over who performs it, but over what it means.
Sorry, but I still cannot make sense of your point in doing so. [speaking here of using quotes around the word marriage]
Hopefully by now you recognise that there is a difference between a religious marriage and a legal one. My use of the quotes was to differentiate between the two (the reasons I chose to use the quotes arond the legal ones should be obvious by now).
From a seperate post:
Incidentally, none of my remarks ever addressed the issue of homosexual marriage. I have been responding to what I consider to be rather strange views of marriage per se.
Yes, it should be obvious that we both think that the legal recognition of a union should be attainable by anyone in such a union.
Just to be perfectly clear, you are not responding to strange views of marriage (unless you are suggusting that there is no fundamental difference between a legal recognition and a religious pledge) as my views are on the useage of the word, not the marriage itself.
Honestly, I really don’t see why you think it is so important to use the church word to discribe non-church unions.