Bush's Shameful Assault Against Gay Marriage

Ash, the greeks may have had a concept which you can now compare to marriage… but it would have been more similar to the concept of slavery than of our marriage today.

Sorry, but that’s factually not true.

The Greeks of the time would think you crazy for comparing their wives to slaves. It’s true that they didn’t have political rights (i.e. - voting or being elected to office) - but they were considered citizens with rights, and the actual treatment they recieved was much better than in most countries TODAY, and certainly better than slaves.

It’s enough to read some Greek plays, to understand the inherent respect the Greeks had to any individual, man or woman - even slave.

Many Greek women were politically influencial, through their masculine friends. There were even debates in Athens wether or not to allow women to elect and be elected, and I think most intellectuals supported it - more than 2300 years ago! (Compare this with the fact that in most western countries women got voting rights only during the 19th cetury, and in Swizerland women got the right to vote only in the 1970s!)

I think the modern concept of marriage is taken mostly from the ancient Romans, not the Greeks. And surely not the Catholic Church! :o

If anything, I believe that the term marriage shouldn’t be used in cases like Muslim countries where the wife is actually the slave of her husband, which has other wives too.

Marriage is, in the proper form, a romantic, legal and economical union between a man and a woman. In barbaric cultures (like in today’s Middle East, and in the Dark Ages) the romantic was usually dropped, and more significance was given to the legal and economic - with religion being used as a mere fig leaf.

I do not know where these mistaken ideas about marriage are coming from, but they are historically inaccurate and lack reasonable justification. The Marriage Act of 1753 established the modern cultural and legal basis of marriage, with the English state issuing a legal certificate validating the act. Religion has no more rightful claim to the concept of marriage than it does to the concept of ethics.

Ash, the greeks may have had a concept which you can now compare to marriage… but it would have been more similar to the concept of slavery than of our marriage today.

Comparing the Ancient Greek concept of marriage to slavery is truly obscene. There are certainly questionable aspects of the treatment of women that we can now reflect upon, but the label of slavery is a gross injustice. Clearly you have not studied the history of Ancient Greece. Have you even read the Odyssey?

“And for thyself, may the gods grant thee all that thy heart desires; a husband and a home may they grant thee, and oneness of heart a goodly gift. For nothing is greater or better than this, when man and wife dwell in a home in one accord, a great grief to their foes and a joy to their friends; but they know it best themselves.”

And more importantly, as Joe pointed out, the concern is not about the origins of the term but about the roots of its usage today.

You have not once provided a single shred of evidence in support of your assertion that the roots of marriage today lies with religion and that the concept of marriage belongs to them. As I said in a previous post, religion has no more rightful claim to the concept of marriage than it does to the concept of ethics.

The idea that Greek marriage was like slavery is wrong (as Eran and Stephen have already pointed out). Most Greeks were farmers, and in those households the wife was practically the equal of the husband, managing the “business” side of running the household while the husband (along with one or two slaves, who were otherwise more or less treated as part of the family, eating at their table, etc.) worked in the field. The idea that Greek marriage was like slavery is liberal, multiculturalist (which is somehow always anti-Western culture) nonsense, and your antipathy toward marriage as such as a purely religious rite is, as I’ve said before, eerily reminiscent of the views of many Communists during the early Soviet period (in fact, there are parts of We The Living that deal with this issue).

How can you say that pre-Christian marriage is irrelevant to the discussion, but Christian marriage is relevant in today’s secular context? Be consistent. Either both are relevant, or neither. Either way, your arguments are nonsense.

Alright… I stand corrected (about greek marriage).

Perhaps legal marriage ought to keep the term, and religion should adopt another. There does, however, need to be a distinction between the two.

your antipathy toward marriage as such as a purely religious rite is, as I’ve said before, eerily reminiscent of the views of many Communists during the early Soviet period

This, however, is absurd. I have claimed nothing against legal marriage, I simply proposed calling it something else. In fact my reason in doing so was so that it could be made more distinctly seperate from the religious rites you speak of.

It appears to me that some folks are saying that context doesn’t matter, it’s connotation is so strong that context isn’t important.

RationalCop, my arguement is that using the same word to describe to simliar but distinct things allows for others to confuse the word. It is not that rational people cannot communicate with such words, but that people who want to be deceptive can do so more easily with such words.

For example, many people are outraged at the concept of gay marriage because it will change their religious institution (obviously, it doesen’t because gay (legal) marriage has nothing to do with religion what-so-ever). The churches, and the president, and others, perpetuate this by saying that such marriages would change the definition of the word. By deliberatly confusing the context, and thereby bypassing the fact that the term has more than one meaning, they cause the outrage which we today see about the concept of gay marriage (even when “civil unions” are going on with little concern).

It is not that rational people cannot communicate with such words, but that people who want to be deceptive can do so more easily with such words.

RH,

People who want to be deceptive will do so regardless of the relative ease that one word has over another. I don’t think it’s worth the effort to argue over how much easier it is, if it even is easier. That, to me, is beside the point.

many people are outraged at the concept of gay marriage because it will change their religious institution (obviously, it doesen’t because gay (legal) marriage has nothing to do with religion what-so-ever).

I think those same people would be against gay marriage regardless of a change in verbage. The verbage neither helps nor detracts from their prejudice. The real prejudice is against the act, the affront to their beliefs, their god, not what it’s called.

In terms of what marriage means to people, it can easily be subtlely different to each person anyway. Should we then create a series of different words for each subtle variation?

For example, to one person marriage may mean an obligation you have to a woman because you accidentally knocked her up and it’s the right thing to do. Love, committment and trust may have no bearing in that meaning. To another person, marriage may mean you spend most of your time with that person, but it doesn’t exclude having sex with another person. Or to expand on that theme, marriage means they live together and reap the economic benefits, but they both swap partners with other people. To some marriage may mean the act of obligation to marry a person your parents picked for you at an early age.

At any rate, I just don’t see that the term is that much of an affront to me. Many words change their meaning over the course of time, regardless of their origin.

You may be right that a change or a clarification is needed. I’m just not convinced that it causes that much confusion.

VES

I think those same people would be against gay marriage regardless of a change in verbage.

Even if the gay couple was only engaging in a civil union? If the state stopped using the religious tainted term “marriage” don’t you think the religious types would not get as involved? This is not something that needs to happen, it is just merely a suggestion, one that makes sense to me and that I think would work. We all know that the purpose of a documented marriage is for legal purposes, but nearly everyone who is against gays getting married, 55% of America (according to USA Today), think that its purpose is mainly religious in nature. Find someone who is against gay marriage and ask them what they think marriage is, you might here them mention that it is also a legal matter but don’t hold your breath.

Alright… I stand corrected (about greek marriage). 

The issue was not only the realities of marriage in Ancient Greece, but the historical roots and significance of marriage. The argument made was that religion has no more rightful claim to the concept of marriage than it does to the concept of ethics.

Perhaps legal marriage ought to keep the term, and religion should adopt another.  There does, however, need to be a distinction between the two.

There already is a distinction, which I have repeatedly struggled to communicate. There is: being married in the eyes of the law, and being married in the eyes of god. What’s the problem? I know the difference, and so do millions of Americans. Note that people legally dissolve their marriage in a divorce, while some religions do not approve. Do we also need to change the word “divorce?”

I know the difference, and so do millions of Americans.

Then why are 55% of Americans against gay marriage? Its a religious thing. There is obvious confusion.

Not that this has anything to do with the issue, but what I think Richard was referring to when he compared the Greek concept of marriage to slavery was that women were often, depending upon what time period we are talking about, bought from there fathers/families by there soon to be husbands. During a different time women were betrothed by force before they were old enough to walk. They were considered property like a slave. They were not, however, usually forced to do labor. A marriage is, according to the Merriam online dictionary: “1-the state of being united to a person of the opposite sex as husband or wife in a consensual and contractual relationship recognized by law”. If you were being bought by your husband or subject to arranged marriage, this is not what we today would call a marriage.

Even if the gay couple was only engaging in a civil union?

Yes. As I stated, I don’t believe their prejudice is really rooted in the word marriage, it’s rooted in the affront that gay sexual activity represents to their values and religious system.

VES

They why are 55% of Americans against gay marriage?  Its a religious thing.  There is obvious confusion.

I would say that a similar number of Objectivists think the same, and it is not because of religious issues. Gay marriage remains a contentious issue among Objectivists, as does homosexuality itself.

There is obvious confusion.

Yes, there is confusion, but not the one that you and Richard think.

They why are 55% of Americans against gay marriage?  Its a religious thing.  There is obvious confusion.

No, what’s obvious is the prejudice against gay people and gay activity. They’re not confused, they are bigoted.

You can find churches that will accept gay members and do not condemn homosexual activity, but they are rare.

Perhaps this can be illustrated by this web site:

http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_chur2.htm

I think if you review this, you will see that there is largely a prejudice against gay people and gay activity in general, in that most denominations view homosexuality as “not compatible with the scripture”. The issue of gay marriage is just an extension of that prejudice.

VES

(edited due to grammar and spelling errors… I really need to proof-read better before submitting)

I don’t believe their prejudice is really rooted in the word marriage, it’s rooted in the affront that gay sexual activity represents to their values and religious system.

It is defiantly not rooted in the word. The word is just a holder for the concept. I am saying that their confusion lies in the real concept behind the words. I believe that most of those who appose gay marriage do so because they think marriage is a religious concept, it is not. Do you think that 55% of Americans would be for a ban on all homosexual behavior? I don’t. If what you are saying is true I would think that about the same amount of people who are against gay marriage would be against gay everything; gatherings, parades, bars, national coming out day (yes they have one), etc. Why are they only willing to ban gay marriage? People understand the right to free speech, they are often confused about the reason behind marriage.

I would say that a similar number of Objectivists think the same, and it is not because of religious issues

Then do you care to say why?

Gay marriage remains a contentious issue among Objectivists, as does homosexuality itself.

I don’t see how a straight shooting Objectivist would find anything wrong with gay marriage. Anyone who wants to be legally acknowledged as someone else’s wife/husband or whatever should be allowed that. Marriage should, in the eyes of the state, be only a legal matter. What many Objectivists don’t agree with is homosexuality in general, morally. But if marriage is indeed only viewed as legal documentation then what is the problem?

Yes, there is confusion, but not the one that you and Richard think

Again, care to say why you think we are wrong? What is the confusion?

If anyone who thinks that the confusion is not due to religious influence I would be interested to hear what your take on it is. But I am not interested in only hearing that you think I am wrong with no evidence to back your opinion. I find that very rude.

No, what’s obvious is the prejudice against gay people and gay activity. They’re not confused, they are bigoted.

Then why are they willing to ban gay marriage and not other gay activities?

prejudice against gay people and gay activity in general, in that most denominations view homosexuality as “not compatible with the scripture”.

True, but why is only marriage ban worthy? I think it is because people do not view marriage as only a legal issue. They see all other gay activities as freedom of speech or something else that is legally protected by the state.

Joerj11,

I will address both of your posts in this one.

Then why are they willing to ban gay marriage and not other gay activities?

Well for one, they couldn’t ban any of the things you listed above because of the US Constitution. There is nothing about marriage protected in the constitution. Being prejudiced is not an all or nothing gambit. There are varying degrees, so it’s not realistic to say that all people who are prejudiced against homosexuals would ban everything having to do with them. And in some cases, they can’t ban things, and wouldn’t even try. Some folks prejudice merely extends to things like, “well as long as they’re not in my neighborhood”, or " as long as I don’t have to know they’re gay".

Prejudice is often masked by other issues. To say that you couldn’t have a parade, which I’m sure SOME people would like to see, would suggest that you bring your bigotry into the open. There’s no other reason to hide behind when you deal with public places (parades, gatherings) or private places (bars, etc.). And actually where I work, there are people who constantly call and complain on people at a gay bar where they live. The gay people around the bar are not committing crimes, but the people call for us (the police) to harass them, and make up complaints.

Marriage however is a different story. It’s one more step of what people call, “in your face”. People can hide behind the scripture, they can say it assails their religious beliefs, they don’t have to admit their bigotry. And certainly your recognize that a lot of people are also against gay adoption, so it’s not only marriage. In polls I could find on the internet, results ranged from 42-50% being against gay adoption. So for the sake of argument, I’ll give you the lower figure.

It is not hard for me to look at this data, and my experiences and say that right now, roughly 50% of the nation is prejudice against gay people. It just happens that the hot button topic right now is marriage.

In my work, I’ve seen enough prejudice against gay people (not to mention virtually any ethnic group) to know that not all people are not up front about it.

VES

Then do you care to say why?

I don’t see how a straight shooting Objectivist would find anything wrong with gay marriage. Anyone who wants to be legally acknowledged as someone else’s wife/husband or whatever should be allowed that. Marriage should, in the eyes of the state, be only a legal matter. What many Objectivists don’t agree with is homosexuality in general, morally. But if marriage is indeed only viewed as legal documentation then what is the problem?

I am not going to rehash the debate among Objectivists which has gone on for some time. But, in essence, there are a large number of Objectivists who think that homosexual couples should have the right to be married in the same manner and for the same reasons as are heterosexual couples. There are also a large number of Objectivists who do not want to permit homosexual marriages. Instead they offer a separate legal agreement to acknowledge some of the legal issues which are legally acknowledged by marriage.

I personally know many of the Objectivists on both sides of this debate, and most are “straight shooting Objectivists.” None of the issues on either side are religious in nature.

Again, care to say why you think we are wrong?  What is the confusion?

If anyone who thinks that the confusion is not due to religious influence I would be interested to hear what your take on it is.  But I am not interested in only hearing that you think I am wrong with no evidence to back your opinion.  I find that very rude.

What do you think I have been doing in all of my preceding posts, if not providing evidence? If I have been talking to myself, then this is a waste of time. As to rudeness, I chose to ignore several remarks made by two posters which were, in fact, rather rude. But, if I am going to talk at all, I’d rather talk about the issues, then talk about the talk.

There is nothing about marriage protected in the constitution

The allowance of gay sex is not in the constitution. Why are they not trying to ban that? You are right, however, that once it is perceived as a legal issue people back off. This is what I think would be helpful.

Prejudice is often masked by other issues.

If 55% of America was that prejudice they would not have to mask it.

There are also a large number of Objectivists who do not want to permit homosexual marriages.

I have never heard of this being true. Would you care to provide us with a link to prove this claim, or for starters tell us who in the real (ARI) Objectivist community believes this? Because this:

Instead they offer a separate legal agreement to acknowledge some of the legal issues which are legally acknowledged by marriage.

does not make sense to me. Maybe you are simply not getting the point across that you are intending but this sounds like the exact same thing as a heterosexual marriage. What is the difference?

I personally know many of the Objectivists on both sides of this debate, and most are “straight shooting Objectivists.” None of the issues on either side are religious in nature.

Then what is the source of their disagreement?

What do you think I have been doing in all of my preceding posts, if not providing evidence?

Evidence for what? You have not said. You said that there was confusion and that Richard and I were wrong about the source, would you mind telling us what you think the confusion is really about?

I think that if there was a direct distinction between legal marriage and religious marriage, like if the state only referred to it as a civil union or something of the like, that it would help people recognize that a marriage in the eyes of the state has nothing to do with any religious beliefs or practices. Once people realize it is only a legal matter they would not care to ban it, at least not in as many numbers nor as avidly. If you believe me to be wrong, please show why and do not just say that that is what you have been attempting to prove the whole time, because for a major chunk of this conversation I thought it pretty apparent that you were not even aware of what was being discussed (the use of the term marriage).

Also this:

If I have been talking to myself, then this is a waste of time.

I consider a bit rude and too.