21 minutes ago, MisterSwig said:
What is the goal of bacterial action?
Could one say that it wants to survive? Or perhaps it acts like it wants to survive.
23 minutes ago, MisterSwig said:
How do you determine if a lion is aware of a choice, that’s the problem.
How do you determine if a lion is aware? What is the difference with “that problem”?
Similarly, how do you determine if a bacteria is not aware?
If it is aware, did it choose it?
Can something be aware, but not able to make any choice? If volition is “focusing”, then just being aware indicates a defacto level of focus. From this perspective, awareness seems to be a concomitant of volition.
In other words, that which is aware, has chosen to be aware.
22 minutes ago, MisterSwig said:
I think it needs to be aware of a simple choice, that’s the foundation.
A lion is thirsty.
It sees a fork in the road.
It goes left. (or right) randomly (trial and error)
That would indicate a choice. (or is there an objection to that?)
It finds the water there.
Next time, it hits that fork in the road, it goes left again.
Purposefully.
Because, last time it went left,
that is where the water was.
Meanwhile, it could have gone right.
Where there is no water.
So it make a choice (based on some perspectives)
Is it aware that if it had gone right, it will miss out on the water?
Maybe not, maybe all it knows is it “feels good” to go to the left.
But didn’t it choose? Wasn’t that purposeful?
Isn’t liking something and doing something about it choosing it?
The lion acts like it knows that it should go left to get the water. Somewhat like a human would (purposefully).
Now, is it aware that it makes choices? Is it aware that it made a choice to go left?
But is that awareness necessary to make a choice? Or to choose?
After all, it did go to the left,
when it could have gone right.