19 minutes ago, Boydstun said:
A worthwhile set of schematics to think with, I’d say, SL, at least to get started. I notice that internally, there are random processes that affect a human life in a deterministic way, such as the appearance of a cell mutation (truly random at first cell alteration) we call cancer. It could deterministically become, say, non-Hodgkins lymphoma. In the particular case of person having it, though in advance of therapies, we might say it’s a matter of chance whether the therapy will be effective in this case; that is just our ignorance, and when the particular outcome eventuates—say death from the cancer—we sensibly say that this outcome was a matter of objective, determined fact from the time the therapy had begun. With the same stage of cancer and the same age of life when the therapy would begin, different patients would make different yes-no choices over whether to undertake the therapy. Each patient could weigh all sorts of common and uncommon factors in coming to a decision. It might become clear enough to a patient which way she should go, or she might end very unsure and decide to let a coin-flip decide which way. But I’d say each person of mature sound mind freely comes to their decision.
One thing that seems key in my current thinking about this is that alternatives as alternatives on what to do are not something merely out in the world without their being an agent confronting the world. The thinking agent is able to generate alternatives, and though they are drafted over what all is in the world, the more powerful at generation, the more free is the agent in the sense of having organized outputs more distant from, more deliberately organized than, immediate-emergency fight or flight response (I’ll pose the latter for William O’s deterministic case). And so long as the thinking agent’s conscious, purposive control system has been in the overall control, greater freedom seems also to go with greater distance from random acts, or anyway acts without large purpose, such as acts of someone who has lost their mind (which I’ll pose for William O’s randomness case).
The division between internal and external may be illusory, but with respect to the discussion about free will they are primarily meant as providing some locus to encourage some focusing on what one would defines as free will (structure and process).
The locus of the process is meant to distill how fundamentally that process works, and although determinism (classical) and random (quantum) processes were specifically shown, real systems and hence real processes can be combinations of these processes. The upshot, is that a combined process can involve randomness, unlike a deterministic process. Free will was presented as a separate process for consideration.
So the circle is not the body, but a line circumscribing what is internal versus external to the process, and being, of a free will (wherever and however manifest). The deterministic effects on the body, therefore are external factors (and knowledge of it are inputs) to the locus of free will as a process of some natural structure (ie the relevant subset thereof). The circle although arbitrary, does help because there is no need to quibble about what really is inside versus outside, only that if such a faculty exists it has identity, if we include too much into that identity, i.e. that which has no relevant causative effect, then it can lie there ineffectual.
In your cancer example, you conclude with “freely comes to a decision”. For argument’s sake, I’d note that the defining aspect of that “freedom” is the ability to have chosen otherwise, not merely that the complex system came to an independent decision in a certain way based on certain abilities to construct alternatives.
With respect to your discussion about alternatives, I am sympathetic to your identification of the sophistication of the choice giving rise to what we see as wider possibilities or possibilities more nuanced or effective… this goes IMHO to the quality of the choice, to the productive capacity of the will, and not specifically to its being free or not.
One could imagine a complex and sufficiently effective Watson or other system, making “purposive” decisions and creating by trial and error or by some neural network, possible outcomes and scenarios and testing them… all in a deterministic manner (including so called random number generation determined from something like ambient temperature). Such would generate and determine choices… eventually, a single choice, but without any freedom at all. In fact the wider the system, the greater its capacity and the more information it houses or has access to, perhaps the more determined the single “maximal” or optimal choice becomes… ignorance might have lead to more unique choices…
In systems in which a free will IS operating, I agree that the cognitive apparatus supporting that locus has an effect on the sophistication and creativity in the final choice made, and can and do take it in a different direction from what a primitive cognitive system might choose… and yes a simple system or a complex one in fight or flight contexts (which adapt to become a simple one…) probably do drive the free will process towards a simple random process.
In the end I find the “free” in free will to be more interesting and glossed over, than the “will” in free will, and trying to determine just what we mean is incredibly important.
I have heard many arguments purportedly proving free will exists, and others purportedly proving free will does not exist, all the while without enough of an explanation of what the person MEANS by free will. Saying one does not understand how or why free will exists, is not the same as and in no way is a valid excuse for, not knowing what one means by “free will” when one apparently has all the confidence in the world to claim proofs about it.
Until a philosopher can distill just what would qualify, at a high level, as a process with some amount of free will he has no means of determining whether anything, human or artificial, exhibits it.
I have tried to circumscribe the minimum abstract physical requirements I have for free will (sophisticated or not), not necessarily the ultimate requirements for it. So far, I do not see any reason why it could not be composed of a combination of deterministic (classical) and random (quantum) processes, however, I do not believe it possible to be composed entirely of deterministic processes.