The Changing Nature of Man and its effect on Ethics in regards to Anim

The Changing Nature of Man and its effect on Ethics in regards to Animal life

It is very probable (nearly inevitable) that in the near future mankind will have achieved the ability to mass produce meat and other animal products in an industrialized fashion. We will no longer be forced to raise (and in many cases destroy) an entire living animal to attain the desired materials, and it won’t make economic sense to do so once the technology is mature.

When we no longer need cows to produce cheeseburgers or cute furry animals to create beautiful fur coats, the Nature of Man will have been changed significantly as we no longer need to kill animals for survival or even for pleasure (Mmmmm, this is a tasty burger!) ; we will have further distanced ourselves from the hunter/gatherers of our past.

Once this happens, how do you view this affecting our Ethics in dealing with Animals? Should it have any effect at all?

It won’t affect it one bit. Our ethical relationship is not determined by the fact that we have no other cost effective way to get meat.

I’m curious what technology you think is going to do this in the near future?

It won’t affect it one bit. Our ethical relationship is not determined by the fact that we have no other cost effective way to get meat.

Clearly cost is not the determining factor in ethics; I mentioned cost as one of the reasons why we would see these products in the future.

I’m curious what technology you think is going to do this in the near future?

Check this - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_vitro_meat - obviously this as with any technology will evolve significantly.

If man can grow beef in a factory (sans cows), the number of cows in the world will fall drastically. If the same thing happens with milk, there will be very few cows in the world. Folks won’t breed cows the way they do today. Our “relationship” will become like our “relationship” with … camels? buffalo? We’ll have them in zoos and petting farms, and exhibits about the quaint life of the 2000’s.

We’ll have them in zoos and petting farms, and exhibits about the quaint life of the 2000’s.

I suppose meat, leather en milk producers would keep a few herds arounds for genetic-banking purposes. Also perhaps to continue selective breeding for favorable traits as regards production. As for zoos, I can’t think of few exhibits more boring than cattle.

Say, if we did away with livestovk, could we also do away with raising complete plants for food? Lab-grown apples would be cheaper without apple trees attached, insofar as fruit is merely the reproductive aspect of the trees’ life cycle. Wheat without chaff, rice without rice paddies. I like the idea.

If man can grow beef in a factory (sans cows), the number of cows in the world will fall drastically. If the same thing happens with milk, there will be very few cows in the world. Folks won’t breed cows the way they do today. Our “relationship” will become like our “relationship” with … camels? buffalo? We’ll have them in zoos and petting farms, and exhibits about the quaint life of the 2000’s.

I was in New York over the weekend and I had buffalo ribs at the Denver Rib Restaurant on west 42 nd street (a good place, if you are in New York and like ribs).

Camels are slaughtered and eaten in the middle east. In some parts of the world horse flesh and dog flesh is eaten by people.

If it is meat and someone is hungry it may very well be consumed.

Bob Kolker

Clearly cost is not the determining factor in ethics; I mentioned cost as one of the reasons why we would see these products in the future.

So what do you think might be a determining factor in this senario.

Check this - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_vitro_meat - obviously this as with any technology will evolve significantly.

Yeah this will be a while before actual meat is economical, unless you want “meat sludge”, which will still be ungodly expensive.

As for zoos, I can’t think of few exhibits more boring than cattle.

Boring For sure. That reminded me of when I visited the Beijing Zoo. They had an “American Beagle” on exibit. The looks we got when petting this caged animal were pretty amusing.

I was in New York over the weekend and I had buffalo ribs at the Denver Rib Restaurant on west 42 nd street (a good place, if you are in New York and like ribs).

I knew someone would pick up on the buffalo :lol: . The point holds, because the relative number of buffalo is a reflection of the relative demand for them. I recently saw a TV program about Ted Turner’s buffalo ranch (and he’s soon going to have steak houses too). Though the buffalo are being eaten, part of his motivation is to propogate buffalo. (As for camels, if people in the west ate camels, there’d be ten times as many.)

In principle if men want the animal for some purpose (where substitutes aren’t satisfactory), that will ensure the survival of the species. And, before Bob comes back with data on whales, the principle only holds if men are allow to appropriate and own the animals; otherwise, it’s a common room shared by five messy college kids.

The story about a poor “American Beagle” in a cage at a zoo is funny. Maybe it’s to protect the beagle from connoisseurs?

Camels are slaughtered and eaten in the middle east. In some parts of the world horse flesh and dog flesh is eaten by people.

People eat all sorts of unlikely things. I know restaurants in Mexico City where you can get grasshopers and other bugs cooked in a variety of ways, worms too. The other day I saw crocodile meat and kangaroo meat for sale at an upscale gourmet mart.

I’ve even heard that some people actually eat fish.

It won’t affect it one bit.

I disagree, and consider the Michael Vick threads. Cruelty to animals (real cruelty) is immoral; whereas, it’s impossible to be cruel to meat, except by overcooking it. That’s, AFAICT, the entire extent of ethical issues regarding animals.

it’s impossible to be cruel to meat

Dude, you’re just not trying hard enough.

I was in New York over the weekend and I had buffalo ribs at the Denver Rib Restaurant on west 42 nd street (a good place, if you are in New York and like ribs).

I just learned this since moving to Colorado, but they’re not buffalo (there are no buffalo in the US) they’re bison. :lol:

I just learned this since moving to Colorado, but they’re not buffalo (there are no buffalo in the US) they’re bison. :lol:

Live and learn. What are the specific differences between buffalo (as in Buffalo Bill) and bison? The ribs were advertised as buffalo ribs. They are leaner than the beef short ribs. Have I been duped?

Bob Kolker

Live and learn. What are the specific differences between buffalo (as in Buffalo Bill) and bison? The ribs were advertised as buffalo ribs. They are leaner than the beef short ribs. Have I been duped?

Bob Kolker

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_bison

Nope, you weren’t duped. They are commonly referred to as buffalo even though it’s not technically correct. I just thought it was an interesting bit of trivia when I learned of the differences, so I thought I’d pass it along. Buffalo burgers are good too and have less fat than chicken. :lol:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_bison

Nope, you weren’t duped. They are commonly referred to as buffalo even though it’s not technically correct. I just thought it was an interesting bit of trivia when I learned of the differences, so I thought I’d pass it along. Buffalo burgers are good too and have less fat than chicken. :slight_smile:

In other words, Robert J. Kolker has been buffaloed, just like the rest of us. :lol:

Buffalo burgers are good too and have less fat than chicken.

Generally true, except for the wings.

I disagree, and consider the Michael Vick threads. Cruelty to animals (real cruelty) is immoral; whereas, it’s impossible to be cruel to meat, except by overcooking it. That’s, AFAICT, the entire extent of ethical issues regarding animals.

I agree with this assessment. However, do you consider any of the treatment of domesticated meat sources today as things that would be

a. cruel given these animals were in the future not meat sources, and

b. still regularly done to these animals even though they are no longer meat sources.

?

I would think that simple economics would prevent that situation. If the meat manufacturing process were truly perfected, to the point that lab meat was indistinguishable from butchered meat, why would anyone continue to raise livestock? Land, feed, veterinary services, and all the other necessities of the business are very expensive, and could be put to better use when livestock are not needed.

I agree with this assessment. However, do you consider any of the treatment of domesticated meat sources today as things that would be

a. cruel given these animals were in the future not meat sources, and

b. still regularly done to these animals even though they are no longer meat sources.

For some reason, I don’t understand the question, which means I get to answer what I think you asked (it’s a new rule of life that I cooked up). My prediction is that the relevant meat animals will virtually disappear (except as hobby and pet animals) when we perfect Chicken Little. While cruelty to food animals is not common now, I think it would be nearly non-existent when the survivors take on the status of pets. Though I think chickens are screwed, because they are lousy pets.

(You can tell me if I answered your question, or some other question.)